@butterflyastrophysics: Reply to @phillipmason3 I really hope you’re asking this in good faith, but as always, I can’t be sure. #trans #queer #discourse

Chaia Ella
Chaia Ella
Open In TikTok:
Region: US
Sunday 17 October 2021 18:28:48 GMT
36918
8668
241
62

Music

Download

Comments

wolfie_treats
Wolfie (she/they) :
also we're not a topic of debate. like it isn't debatable. we exist. it isn't up for discussion. 🥰
2021-10-17 20:30:08
335
phlegminine
Alexandria :
Absolutely, there are a lot of things I just won’t tell cis people about transness bc I don’t trust they know enough to treat that info responsibly
2021-10-17 18:40:59
270
swansongsax
swansongsax :
the entitlement it takes for cis people to expect trans people to engage in polite debate about whether our existence matters is honestly ridiculous.
2021-10-17 19:24:58
122
mercurystardust
Mercury Stardust :
As always you explained this so well xoxo
2021-10-17 20:45:31
116
brianisze
Biz Vicious :
It seems hard for people to understand that there are two topics at play in the conversation. Trans identity is not debatable. We exist.
2021-10-17 23:56:58
111
site_42
Dr. Theron Sherman :
This week must have been exhausting for you. (More than usual.) I am constantly impressed by your work; brava. 😌🙏
2021-10-18 02:29:11
75
wonderhug
WonderHug :
There’s no nuance to denying your identity.
2021-10-17 19:07:42
66
personalgenius
PersonalGenius :
Not just because of bad faith, but the general idea that existence is something that can or should be argued against.
2021-10-17 19:04:27
45
radioactive_voidfish
Nope :
Cis people forget that they aren't the only person who has a billion questions. We have to explain & justify ourselves to EVERYONE we meet. It's-
2021-10-18 06:16:02
43
j_mck
Arctic Harmacist 🇳🇴🏳️‍⚧️ :
I don't debate my existence with anybody. I've cut off family over this.
2021-10-18 06:00:06
42
revmikeumc
The Rev :
I believe that God made us all. I was born to the body intended. Some where not so lucky. So glad science can get you to you. Stay strong.
2021-10-17 23:49:33
37
xjaydenprincex
user5218306288239 :
ughhhh what is a debate? it implies that both sides deserve to be heard. like should heinz ketchup be considered ketchup.
2021-10-17 19:46:46
35
orhanai
orhanai :
in order to have a conversation, you have to have ground rules. "people are entitled to self identification" is a valid, even necessary rule to demand
2021-10-17 19:23:39
29
hydramez
Hydramez :
Trans people are under no obligation to justify their own existence!
2021-10-17 18:31:51
26
msmysticforest
Laura :
This is so true. I’m also willingly keeping myself away from certain conversations for this exact reason
2021-10-17 18:44:23
17
rojo_roja
nalidrojoroja :
I think people forget how much us trans people are still oppressed
2021-10-17 18:37:45
15
psyangelic
Nevani :
nobody is entitled to your time. this reminds me of people constantly asking black folks to explain racism. no we're tired, they can do some reading.
2021-10-18 05:49:00
12
restlessinnskeeper
edgrin🧝‍♀️ :
there's a reason why these approaches are bad faith... because the ultimate point isnt to understand trans women, its to undermine and deny them!
2021-10-18 09:56:37
11
mao_zebong
PucePunch :
I'm actually done caring about explaining stuff/debating with cis people. I spent too much time not working on myself for cis losers online
2021-10-17 19:07:36
10
theoriginalladym
Myrinda Dixon :
my trans kids don't owe anyone anything!
2021-10-17 21:13:11
10
adorable_rainbowfist_
(ADORA)ble 🌈👊 :
lol where is this "nuanced conversation" cishets are having about us?
2021-10-18 10:44:45
6
lemonplanter
Lemon🍋Planter :
is it really surprising to cis folks that we can, you know, TELL when someone's asking in bad faith?
2021-10-18 15:27:34
6
penelopep4386
penelope parker🐝💛 :
the thing is: i actually LOVE conversations! i believe they’re a good way to solve issues, sway someone’s opinion, or learn new things! but…
2021-10-18 06:13:37
6
vlad_tepid
Vlad Tepid :
I think he means above reproach.
2021-10-17 20:06:10
5
To see more videos from user @butterflyastrophysics, please go to the Tikwm homepage.

Other Videos


About