@hypohystericalhistory: Reply to @finnduffy7 Historical misconceptions #History #war #battle #military #australia #ww2 #roman

Timmeh
Timmeh
Open In TikTok:
Region: AU
Tuesday 23 November 2021 22:40:09 GMT
233325
25519
664
200

Music

Download

Comments

matthewdavis987
matthewdavis987 :
Sir didn’t you hear the romans don’t exist
2021-11-23 23:55:49
596
superawesomecoolguy
PNW Hiker💙 :
France as a country that easily surrenders is the misconception that bugs me.
2021-11-24 03:56:41
126
b_ready4it
B_Ready4It :
Can you (or have you already) expand on the Battle of Kokoda? Why was this battle important to Australia and the Allies?
2021-11-24 04:59:27
112
thomas.baker_
Thomas :
I massively agree with your first misconception. The only accurate depiction ive seen of ancient battle is the opening scene to the HBO series Rome
2021-11-24 02:45:21
16
shyguyrulesokay
James :
Assuming Historians who appear on television sometimes get things wrong, is it driven by bias or are these just mistakes?
2021-11-23 23:01:46
14
andrewjames275
Andrew James :
Do you think the tv series Rome showed this a bit better? I remember they showed the rotation
2021-11-23 23:47:29
7
roostersrealm
Roosters Realm :
You’re consuming American media , of course it’s slanted. Fwiw I’m American and appreciated how much Australia participated, but I have Aussie friends
2021-12-18 16:48:25
2
vortex_lettuce
Bob Smith :
HBO’s Rome opening scene shows a decent example. Front row fights for a minute, then centurion blows a whistle and the next line steps up.
2021-11-23 23:27:29
50
sco88
sco :
What do you think people, who might otherwise be uninterested, stand to gain from reading about the classics/ancient history?
2021-11-23 23:16:46
4
bleestein
bleestein :
Do you have a movie to recommend that gets the closest to how the ancient battles took place?
2021-11-23 23:12:50
49
adfchat
🤞🤘 👏👌👏 :
I am so glad you mentioned the museum flags. I was in the USA and visited many museums and memorials and the Aussie flag was not even on the map.
2021-11-24 08:38:33
5
masonkane3
Mason Kane :
Hey Aussie Tobruk amongst many others will never be forgotten to the English.Banter aside(u lot are as good at it btw!😂)you guys r unbelievably tuff
2021-12-29 10:39:18
1
dennis.fang
Dennis Fang :
Do you know of a film that depicts ancient battles properly?
2021-11-24 03:52:20
2
dumbbitchofoz
Comrade :
that's everything with the US, hell even D-day is seen as an overwhelmingly US operation, despite their being more Commonwealth forces involved
2021-11-24 06:19:23
107
lankgiraffe
lankgiraffe :
As a Canadian I agree with you on the Australian thing. You guys played a massive role in WW2 that is unrecognized
2021-11-24 04:57:38
3
baddtuna
BaddTuna :
I would would pay an an entire weeks wage to see an accurate movie about the Battle of Cannae.
2021-11-23 23:26:36
3
cumberlandken
user4333307851179 :
A classic current example is the movie Argo directed by Ben Affleck. Typical. It’s the American way.
2021-12-20 20:21:20
1
mozartfx
user6104281137109 :
“American nationalist historians”? Like who?
2021-12-16 19:53:41
1
darth.tartart
Pogve :
The USA probably tried to compemsate bc of the way they handled the Philippines
2022-01-04 17:16:37
0
eagerfeat
eagerfeat :
The second one is so egregious that even as someone who has had WWII as a special interest since childhood, I really didn’t have any idea until this
2022-01-27 23:00:54
0
respol11sr
RESPOL11sr :
In gladiator maximum broke up the front lines of barbarians in a flanking Calvary charge. That would explain being in the middle of a group of enemy
2022-01-10 19:26:39
0
irishcheetah
Irishcheetah :
Would check out Historia Civilis on YouTube for a lot of great history and battles.
2022-01-28 21:49:19
0
robby1967
Rob :
Certainly the Greeks and Romans used formations, but surely the Celtic warriors were far more individualistic and lacking in discipline?
2022-01-19 20:06:52
0
lord_of_woe_
Commander Dante 🩸🪽 :
do you think Rome the TV series had better fighting? from the fight scenes they did have specially when it was Roman v Roman they fought in formations
2021-11-24 01:30:42
0
To see more videos from user @hypohystericalhistory, please go to the Tikwm homepage.

Other Videos


About