@brettsthoughts: If Sirius Black wasnt guilty, why did he hysterically laugh? I think there was a mistake in the writing #harrypotter #siriusblack
brettsthoughts
Region: GB
Tuesday 25 July 2023 22:38:21 GMT
Music
Download
Comments
bitt 🇩🇰 :
it makes good sense. I always assumed it was a trauma breakdown; he saw Peter turn to a rat and knew he was f-ed, his best friends are dead and he'll
2023-07-25 23:03:54
2780
Chloe Gaffney :
people laugh when bad things happen it as a stress response
2023-07-25 23:12:42
1133
jadekimmm :
I always thought it was because he couldn’t believe Peter was the one to frame him but
2023-07-26 09:19:39
1
Luna | Isekai Author :
laughing is a form of stress relief so it could be because of that as well
2023-07-25 22:51:51
195
emilia :
omg I was literally thinking about this today. I just figured it was his reaction to the shock. because he realized what was going to happen now
2023-07-25 22:49:06
101
georcry :
I think he knew Peter would have to spend his life as a rat and that he’d probably die as a result
2023-07-25 22:54:33
76
Rey J :
i always thought it was just his natural reaction to the shock of the situation and knowing how peter got away but realising he couldn't stop his fate
2023-07-26 00:04:24
33
siriuslyinlovewsirius :
This is a cool theory but honestly Sirius is the type to laugh hysterically at a situation like he was in because of many reasons
2023-07-26 03:40:12
5
Elisabeth💓🌸 :
A bit far fetched for me. Sirius suggested James to make Peter the secret bearer, maybe he laughed like that coz he felt guilty+ basically traumatised
2023-07-26 07:58:55
4
Cait :
Ngl I thought he was laughing because he was traumatized after seeing jily dead and it was his reaction
2023-07-25 22:45:17
3
Rebekah Gore :) :
Cheering charm
2023-07-25 22:46:37
3
TalathienRose :
maybe he wasn't laughing and the people just reported what they thought they saw? maybe he was crying. or maybe he was laughing but like, in the way+
2023-07-30 05:10:27
2
Rwby :
Hey was laughing because he couldn’t believe that Peter Pettigrew pulled one on him
2023-07-26 07:56:37
4
OneArmWarrior :
Wouldn’t surprise me but I feel it was just bc Peter was getting away
2023-07-26 12:13:02
0
StephF :
This explanation is now canon. ✅ approved.
2023-07-26 02:36:34
0
Cordelia :
I love this theory so much it fits so well
2023-07-25 22:44:35
2
run.chereese.run :
But it also said that he went with the ministry quietly… didn’t Ron have to be taken to another room during exams for an hour bc of a cheering charm?
2023-07-26 00:45:25
0
Bella (moony’s version) :
i thought this was already canon 😭😭 i didn’t realise she never confirmed it
2023-07-26 06:44:02
0
holli.lilli :
Well in titanic, Cal was laughing when he realised he put the diamond necklace in his coat & gave his coat to rose...similar thing? 😂
2023-07-26 10:28:13
0
PizzaDude :
He might have had a mental breakdown.
2023-07-26 02:40:04
0
mikki :) :
WAIT THAT DIDNT HAPPEN?? I ALWAYS THOUGHT PETER PUT THE CHEERInG CHARM ON SIRIUS
2023-07-26 09:48:51
2
Nat.Holi :
Some prople laugh as a trauma or stress response.
2023-07-26 11:06:16
1
Natalie :
This could also be due to shock … this can happen
2023-07-26 00:50:32
0
kitkat196210 :
If she took it out that was a good writing choice.
2023-07-25 23:42:51
1
Katie Pasta :
I thought he broke down crying (having 'unalived' his friend who unalived his best friend) and media, doing what media does, reported laughter
2023-07-26 05:08:18
0
To see more videos from user @brettsthoughts, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.