@openlynews: Trans rights advocates in Germany have criticised plans by the government to restrict legal gender change during war - a measure that seeks to stop men from abusing proposed trans self-ID rules to evade military conscription. Germany's government last month approved draft legislation allowing people to change their legal gender simply by visiting the local civil registry office, a move that was initially welcomed by LGBTQ+ rights campaigners. But trans advocates say the proposed wartime restrictions contained in the self-ID bill - which must still be approved by parliament - raise doubts about the government's commitment to self-determination. One of the articles of the draft bill includes stipulations for legal gender change in "a case of tension or defence" – a legal state that has never been declared in Germany but could be applied if, for example, the country was under attack. The section states that if someone assigned male at birth tries to change legal gender during such a period or up to two months beforehand, they would still be considered male for the purposes of military conscription. The German Family Ministry, one of the ministries responsible for the bill, said changing legal gender would still be possible if "a case of tension or defence" was invoked, but that the provision was necessary to guarantee national security. "The purpose of the regulation is to prevent the evasion of compulsory military service in the event of tension or defense and thus to ensure the defence capability of the Federal Republic of Germany," a ministry spokeswoman told Openly. LGBTQ+ activists say the wartime regulations and other articles in the bill - such as restrictions for migrants awaiting deportation - reflect persistent discrimination towards trans people by raising questions about the veracity of trans identities. "This article of the bill is really feeding into the stereotype that trans people don't really exist, that they're people trying to cheat and trans women actually are men, and that in times of war we don't have time for 'luxury items' like gender identity," said Richard Koehler, senior policy officer at advocacy group Transgender Europe, adding that “it (also comes) from a very outdated understanding of gender: the idea of the male hero being the defender of the nation and the female giving birth, staying home and taking care of the nation." #lgbtqnews #lgbtqrights #transawareness #transrights #germany #lgbtgermany #berlin
Openly | LGBTQ+ news
Region: GB
Tuesday 19 September 2023 14:45:18 GMT
Music
Download
Comments
Luna Floberg Lien :
do like norway, and have equal conscription for both genders
2023-09-23 10:33:04
30
Enrique Anarte - Journalist :
😶
2023-09-19 14:47:34
28
щавелитикс🎀 ● Подписчики :
This is a discriminatory.
2023-09-19 17:31:01
73
Spyrate🏳️⚧️ :
me with boobs and the strength of a cis women: 😑
2023-09-20 06:17:50
54
Olivia🦦 :
i wonder if it makes a difference if you already medically transitioned... like i got b00bs and the strength of a cis woman my body aint better for
2023-09-19 15:20:46
68
ccff1155 :
nobody regardless of sex or gender should be forced to fight.
this is the best solution 👌
2023-09-23 08:01:11
25
ricchi570 :
solution -> no war 😎
oh damn we cant so that ehh humanity
2023-09-22 09:31:48
9
Sidneyy :
we need more women in power so they’ll be less risk of wars
2023-09-22 12:58:49
7
samir :
very simple solution, abolish conscription
2023-09-19 15:17:40
49
User :
Equalize drafts in case of war, regardless of gender. Everyone is equally drafted. Why should only men die?
2023-09-19 16:31:46
22
🛫💜HungryAndorranCat💚🛬 :
Why are men still the only ones being conscripted in 2023
2023-09-19 15:17:45
21
laboro_ludo :
Germany?
Joining a war?!
After our last two missteps???
What Nazi was suggesting that?!
2023-09-20 17:57:24
5
Rekeji 🇬🇧🏳️🌈 :
Conscription is barbaric and should be abolished
2023-09-20 09:36:59
13
sdm007700 :
abolish conscription. just as simple as that. ridiculous concept to force people to fight who don't want to
2023-09-19 20:27:25
10
Timothy Mattnew :
If they are gonna conscript trans women on hormones they might as well commit and conscript people of any gender, seriously.
2023-09-20 05:43:25
5
Svlwester :
I'm not giving my life to any country - their problem with someone else is not my problem I just want peace for every one 💃
2023-09-19 15:17:11
24
TeaAndCake :
ez pz draft everyone
2023-09-20 01:32:45
7
Benjamin :
We have mandatory conscription for men in Switzerland and face a similar problem since changing gender was made much easier
2023-09-21 08:32:01
6
lflrfmmf :
look to norway.both genders needs to serve(yes we have conscription). and everyone can change their legal gender
2023-09-20 08:48:27
35
Potato :
I actually think that's pretty reasonable. We don't want people to use this law to cause problems🤔
2023-09-19 14:51:57
6
Rorin Cutter / David :
everyone should defend the country. period the end.😳
2023-09-21 10:18:21
11
Velyoldukilgrentia :
That's wrong, it only says that changing it right before doesn't count, but if you changed years before it's different...
2023-09-19 16:48:39
7
Ven☭ :
Forced military service isn't a thing in Germany though
2023-09-20 09:56:16
6
Friendly Facehugger :
Doesn't Germany already have a civil, free to choose alternative for military service? Make it for all.
2023-09-20 08:29:43
6
To see more videos from user @openlynews, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.