celebreabird
Region: US
Friday 01 March 2024 00:06:10 GMT
15672
1409
90
21
Music
Download
Comments
RaeLynn :
I absolutely love the quality of the receipts. But I literally just realized the loss Legolas will feel when Gimli passes! 😭😭
2024-03-01 01:54:15
28
Matthew Wade :
Great explanation
2024-03-01 12:03:58
2
Laurie MacKellar :
I thought that Frodo had been granted immortality when I read the books as a teen in the 70s
2024-03-01 01:40:48
3
Hollifant🇿🇦 :
What did Tolkien mean by "So he went...to a purgatory..."?
2024-03-01 07:16:43
6
NBParrott :
were there any casualties in valinor, when morgoth and ungoliant did their thing? besides the two trees, of course.
2024-03-01 15:54:40
4
✨The Y’allest Hobbit✨ :
But why was Bilbo going?!
2024-03-01 02:22:20
1
Drater Diputs :
It’s so strange seeing Mordor in the west ;)
2024-03-02 01:06:26
0
Dilly Rilynrret (Bri Delgado) :
OMG thank you so much for explaining this, you're awesome 😍
2024-03-01 04:50:12
3
HangryCyclist :
Tolkien was an atheist up to a certain point in his life and it doesn’t seem likely that any place in the hobbit world really references heaven.
2024-03-02 04:07:09
0
stevenblankenshi9 :
wait! I thought elves just go to valinor not "heaven" the halls of mandos is in valinor right?
2024-03-02 02:26:21
0
Chris :
Do you think he’d have a special place in the Halls of Mandos when he died before he eventually went to “places known not to the Valar”?
2024-03-02 00:44:37
0
mattcan19 :
Q: we see in the films the elfs come to help Rohan but in the books this never happened. Can you refresh my memory on the Elves and Dwarfs during LOTR
2024-03-01 16:33:20
0
Rosemary🇨🇦 :
Wow thank you for going through the trouble of explaining all this
2024-03-01 15:46:33
1
The Archduchess :
Someone should build a resort/swanky retirement home and call it Valinor. I'd read it as the only place he could heal from the trauma of the Ring.
2024-03-01 00:56:06
2
MB :
The distinction is only really relevant in context if there is also a heaven. Did Tolkien write anything about an afterlife?
2024-03-05 01:24:16
0
KimBlyRen Ren :
Thanks. Great info!!
2024-03-01 00:39:15
2
TrueCanadian :
Wow, this is insanely awesome
2024-03-01 02:39:23
2
Jacob Downing :
Is Gandalf immortal? I thought I read somewhere that he was part of the Valar
2024-03-01 18:29:12
0
Margit Elise :
I personally view Valinor has a "retirement home/palliative care" after what they went through. Then it is Halls of Mandos next.
2024-03-01 08:59:23
1
N7sharp9 :
Isnt Tuor a mortal man who goes to valinor but Does get immortality though.
2024-03-01 11:51:17
2
Kelaeriel :
Excellent work. Thanks!
2024-03-01 04:20:03
1
João Marques :
Didnt The Silmarillion have a passage about Tolkiens legendarium havendo? The Halls of Mandos?
2024-03-01 00:42:49
1
Bellslestrange :
I apologize if you’ve done this already, but have you discussed how and why Saruman turned evil?
2024-03-01 04:06:17
1
Excior :
so if a Hobbits life span is normally 80 years does the undying lands prolong his life?
2024-03-01 12:50:53
1
Fensterbrew :
Lots of insight and good information. Thank you for your dedication to the subject. The Silmarillion was…difficult to follow.
2024-03-01 00:25:25
1
To see more videos from user @celebreabird, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.
