This would only be ok to me if ALL the players knew that ANY of them could be a secret werewolf from the very beginning. Getting approval first before God-Mode-ing someone’s character is REQUIRED!!
2024-03-08 22:55:20
3248
Apple User392586803 :
At first, I thought what a wonderful idea. The party should get to choose how to deal with it. You can have a secret werewolf, but let them decide to try and find a cure or get special abilities
2024-06-04 22:44:30
0
APieceOfSushi :
I like this idea (even as a secret) as long as the person is an experienced player and they state they are willing to go with the flow of your story and doesn't have their own set-in-stone storyline
2024-03-08 20:22:52
1722
Undead_Botantist :
my question is did they think she may not play another rogue? maybe she mains rogues?
2024-03-08 19:25:38
641
*pterodactyl shriek* :
absolutely insane behavior. also secret werewolf is such a fun gimmick for a party-
2024-03-08 20:32:46
1374
Goji76 :
I actually love the idea of a campaign where one of the players is a werewolf the whole time, but nobody knows who. But I would absolutely be clear that this was how it was going to pan out beforehand
2024-03-08 21:56:46
503
Kslo :
That could have been cool and a lot of fun if they had done this right!
2024-03-08 21:18:08
445
CB Millz :
I’ve been mildly fascinated w/DND for the past year, and really want to try it because it seems like such a great way to escape from the realities of every day life. Seems something this group forgot.
2024-05-20 23:22:11
1
chubbygayLB :
ok, but going by some werewolf lore, the person who was a werewolf not knowing might be realistic.
2024-03-08 22:00:04
236
AJ :
A player’s backstory is one of the few areas the PC gets total control in. Don’t change it for them
2024-03-09 05:18:50
364
Susan Kenny :
I feel in my bones that this is more personal than the DM and ranger let on. it's not just about OP playing a rogue, it's about OP.
2024-04-03 06:13:33
185
Sari spooks :
I love the idea of a secret werewolf being in the party and the players not knowing bUT if you want to do that and still not give things away ask as a group if BS can be changed at any point
2024-03-08 20:31:13
196
lyingblood :
I like how everything went honestly. probably could have been more hints. whose to say an unknowing werewolf would remember transforming?
2024-03-08 22:20:18
1
Ana Henley :
I played a one shot with friends where the dm had us all start at max level... he didn't intro my character till the end cuz apparently he liked my character design better then the one for the BBG (1)
2024-03-08 21:09:00
81
Momma Bailey :
I GUARANTEE you, if you floated the idea of "a party member being a secret monster" at the start of a campaign, they'd be interested. This is just a train wreck 😭
2024-03-08 19:40:21
123
jollygiant69 :
I had a dm secretly make my character a doppelganger but he did it in a way that didn't change anything about my character and it was for a halloween one shot it didn't really matter in the end anyway
2024-05-21 13:56:16
25
ᛊᚢᛗᛗᛖᚱ ᚱᛁᚢᛖᚱᚨ :
Me who about to play a rogue 😳
2024-03-08 19:31:11
17
T3ddysaurus :
There is not a single point where I was expecting things to go. Those 2 players need something, idk what. But something.
2024-03-08 20:31:38
62
d_bernthold :
I AM THE ONE WHO PICKS LOCKS
2024-03-09 00:28:48
61
lynx :
As a dm its so much more fun to ask players if they want to have a hidden role. They LOVE telling stories so they tend to jump at the chance.
2024-03-08 21:12:33
1
Jingle_Jangle :
Never ever ever take agency away from a player. This is super fun if a player is in on the secret from the beginning but they have to have a choice
2024-03-20 08:02:15
12
Katt :
I feel like it would've been so much better if it was like a memory loss thing. Character sleeps and werewolf takes over and when the party finds out-
2024-03-09 13:23:56
8
Hamlet :
I do this as a "Devil's bargain" sometimes, at character creation I go "I can give you a little bonus if you help me with something..."
2024-05-18 14:54:10
16
LunarRose18 :
Honestly it is kind of a neat idea if the DM doesn't have a set choice on who the werewolf is but instead decides based on the player's behavior. Like, of COURSE the werewolf is the murder hobo!
2024-03-10 17:56:24
30
To see more videos from user @eldritchpodblast, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.