@jeschneiderx: Peter Singer: The Trolley Problem - What Would You Do? #shorts #petersinger #trolleyproblem #chrisdicarlo #christopherdicarlo #drdicarlo #allthinksconsidered #trolley #ethics #ethical #philosophy #philosophytiktok #morals #morality #atheist #atheisttiktok
if the 5 people are a billionaire and his family, i would save the one other person
2024-05-23 04:10:13
1
JPilk84 :
I get the idea of pushing the person off the bridge, and would do that in theory, but in real life I probably wouldn’t because I couldn’t be sure they’d stop the trolley, 5 instead of 6
2024-05-23 12:52:20
0
McBargeface :
Both cases are the same, we are just trying to make it more emotional
2024-05-22 18:25:04
2
Jesse Duke933 :
Why kill one when you can get rid of five?
2024-05-22 21:24:09
1
the_wizard_E_fod🪄✨️🧙♂️🧙♀️ :
Trolleys run on rails.... why the hell are they on the track in the first place?
2024-05-22 19:05:09
1
ZestyLefty :
I cannot be the only person who thought to kill one to save six. You can sacrifice yourself and derail the train before it hits anyone.
2024-11-01 02:53:06
0
Free Thinker :
Question for DiCarlo: if you were the person with the backpack, would you be willing to toss yourself onto the track to save the 5?
2024-09-12 15:15:54
0
MadMamma :
I guess it depends on the quality of those people
2024-05-24 13:38:48
0
Sailor54🏴☠️🇦🇺 :
Should we sacrifice one healthy person to give a life saving transplant to five people?
2024-05-23 14:32:58
0
Willy C :
I would grab the heavy backpack and jump myself. Some of us are comfortable with sacrificing all for some
2024-05-23 11:15:44
0
Dorothy Holder :
Yes this is why we don't trust doctors.. Murder is acceptable whole natural selection is not
2024-05-23 09:51:56
0
Caonum :
pull the backup off him and throw it down, just the once rose, everyone lives
2024-05-23 06:12:38
0
Monks of The Way :
I'd make it a point never to be around that guy.. I myself don't think I get to decide who lives and dies. I think that kind of person is a monster.🙏
2024-05-23 05:37:42
0
nozrati :
When the five people you’re saving is people you identify with and the 1 person isn’t the rate goes up because of oxytocin
2024-05-23 03:02:33
0
CatcherBlock :
what if that one person is your mom?
2024-05-23 00:44:07
0
joejoeaintjoe :
A lot of is how likely the ‘solution’ is to work. Killing one person to probably not save anyone feels wrong, but killing one person to definitely save 5 feels right.
2024-05-22 21:44:30
0
CarpetFace :
This is exactly why the real option is neither of the two presented, 100% of the time
2024-05-22 20:35:59
0
Brian Smith :
I’d definitely still push the guy, the only stage I start hesitating is when you look at the version where you have 5 ppl dieing of different organ problems but you can kill one person, harvest their
2024-05-22 18:40:27
0
To see more videos from user @jeschneiderx, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.