yeah I think most of us value based on probability of survival rather than worst case
2024-09-01 06:47:02
392
Able :
I think in general the question is dishonest. the way it's phrased is like a question of probability. What gives you the highest odds of survival? But what people actually mean is what could possibly go worse? I think anyone would agree that yeah In the worst case a man COULD do greater harm. But the disagreement is on the level of probability.
2024-09-01 06:11:49
151
jumbonuts :
This completely ignores probability. This is like saying if I don’t spend all my rent money on lottery tickets then best case I have my rent money but if I do best case I have 20 million.
2024-11-07 11:44:55
1
Gingey :
The argument just splits up society more n more
2024-09-01 13:07:54
615
Vmc2k3 :
Completely ignoring likelihood
2024-09-01 08:41:17
228
Why tho :
Sense when is grape worse then death like it’s bad but the forever sleep is the one thing you can never come back from
2024-09-01 04:30:58
122
Aiden Kirby :
This. This is the best argument/explanation of the scenario
2024-09-01 04:31:48
35
Ian Muir :
the problem is that the question has a ton of variables and rather than clarifying the details everybody is just assuming we're all thinking of the same thing and telling at each other
2024-10-24 19:26:34
0
harperjoe :
there is nothing worse then death
2024-09-01 13:41:19
78
Cephandrius :
I think some men are like, “I don’t know any guy that can beat a bear in a fight so it would be crazy to pick the bear” and think no further than that.
2024-09-01 04:39:48
101
Paragon :
I think for me there are those two terrible outcomes but both of those don't have the same chances of happening like 99/100 or whatever it is the man probably isn't going to be the worst outcome while
2024-09-01 01:24:08
159
The other side of the mirror :
The problem may lie in the concept of risk evaluation: potential consequence AND probability. Very often, people only evaluate the first - not also the second. Wouldn’t necessarily change much, though
2024-09-01 01:30:27
18
Sheriff Silver :
I definitely don’t think there’s anything worse then dying
2024-09-01 10:23:20
53
Joji :
Imo it’s just an issue with framing the scenario bc aside from probability, people just see it differently. For example I always saw it as a man/bear and woman get teleported to a forest island…
2024-09-11 05:38:08
0
bfeeskdnn :
I honestly think neither side of this actually stops and thinks about the actual perspective of the opposite side of the argument.
2024-09-01 01:40:03
73
To see more videos from user @schoolofhbc, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.