@alifeonbooks: Is this the great American novel? Larry McMurtry's Loneseome Dove is one of the mos praised novels in the literature community, but after reading it, I feel like I have a complicated relationship with this book. First, I'll say that Lonesome Dove is a very enjoyable read. McMurtry's storytelling and character building are phenomenal. BUT.... After finishing Lonesome Dove I couldn't help but scratch my head and ask "so what was the point?" Reading through interviews wih McMurtry, his stated goal was to demythologize the American Cowboy, in fact, some people refer to Lonesome Dove as an "anti-western" but I just don't see it. For me, there were a lot of moments, that if anything, reinforced some of the stereotypes about cowboys, Native Americans, women, and people of color, generally. I am very glad I read Lonesome Dove, and I enjoyed my time reading it, but I'm not so sure if this is going to end up on any of my personal all time lists. . #lonesomedove #larrymcmurtry #westerns #bookreview #BookTok

Life On Books
Life On Books
Open In TikTok:
Region: US
Thursday 21 November 2024 01:57:47 GMT
288715
14616
409
411

Music

Download

Comments

hagostaeldmann
Brian Nelson :
McCarthy wrote a minimum of 5 better books than Lonesome Dove.
2024-11-22 22:32:42
24
erinleeauthor
Erin Lee, Author :
I am over 100 pages in and CAN'T get into it. it's so slow moving.
2024-11-22 13:11:20
96
brendead69
Brendead :
Blood Meridian is the greatest American novel
2024-11-21 10:39:15
66
birch_swinger
birch_swinger :
Moby Dick is the great American novel. Blood Meridian does far more to demythologize the American cowboy.
2024-11-22 12:16:37
290
cindyabc4
SVT❌ :
I’ve read it 5 times!!!!!!! It’s absolutely a master piece
2024-11-21 21:08:11
6
ogsavannahdawg
OGSavannahDawg :
The whole Lonesome Dove series is great.
2024-11-21 22:55:01
159
qershi__
freedom :
Holes by Louis Sachar is the great American novel
2024-11-24 16:25:12
85
curomo
Cu🪡oMo :
It’s not supposed to be a book about some grand idea. And I don’t consider it a Western, even if that’s the setting. It’s transcends that theme. It’s an unrivaled character and relationship study
2025-05-14 14:19:26
10
chicagonancy
Nancy :
Loved Lonesome Dove
2024-11-22 14:57:29
5
austintroyer1
Austin Troyer355 :
Just started it because I grew up watching the mini series. I’ve heard it’s Stephen Kings favorite book and it’s probably because of the way he does engaging character perspective
2024-11-21 22:53:46
45
alanhagerty760
alanhagerty760 :
like to see other great American novel recommendations. besides the obvious catcher in the rye, Great Gatsby, and killer pizza; my recs would be Pet Sematary, Alice in wonderland, and Carrie
2024-11-21 03:51:53
0
scottreads
Scott :
It’s excellent… i could literally smell the smells and feel the southern heat…
2024-11-21 02:17:35
44
user1456049273853
user1456049273853 :
I’m not sure if he wanted to dismantle those systems, but rather show the reader how vile things were (and still are?). But yes, those characters are unlike any I have read
2024-11-21 02:18:38
46
deanoreads
deanoreads 📚 :
I think this is a very fair review. I agree it romanticizes cowboys more than it decontructs them.
2024-11-21 14:22:03
16
user7989650142222
Apple User65329770 :
Fucking great book. Read the full series. EPIC
2024-11-21 11:05:47
8
therevdad
Will Christians36 :
From a character driven standpoint, it’s one of the best! Agree that the thematic approach doesn’t stray far from the traditional American-Western myth.
2024-11-21 02:16:01
23
msdanibabyxo
Dani Baby 📚 :
Hell yes. My desert island read. Who knew a cowboy book would have me crying!
2024-11-21 02:51:53
19
tvsharon
Sharon M :
I read this this year for the first time. Immediately became my favorite book.
2024-11-24 10:50:42
8
basalticflow
michael :
I say Gone with the Wind is the great American novel 😁
2024-11-24 22:19:33
35
erickaandj
Ericka :
The most memorable characters everrrrrrrr
2025-03-22 03:39:40
7
moviesorcinema
MoviesorCinema :
It’s one of the great pieces of work that was great as a novel and a film.
2024-12-04 20:07:33
5
goodideatom
Just Tom :
I was expecting blood meridian
2024-11-24 01:48:51
7
icantdriveorboard
RedRu :
What would you say is the great American Novel? Blood Meridian??????
2024-11-21 12:13:04
0
stevenbbemis
Steven B Bemis :
Just realized that it’s a series. Should I start with the first book or the third which is Lonesome Dove?
2025-05-24 23:11:39
0
blakekiger
Blake Kiger :
Goodreads says it’s the third book in a series, can I read it stand alone? Or do I need to read the other 2?
2024-11-21 03:14:40
0
To see more videos from user @alifeonbooks, please go to the Tikwm homepage.

Other Videos


About