@pbsnews: A therapist’s advice for dealing with family estrangement during the holidays The picture-perfect image of happy families at holiday gatherings isn’t reality for everyone. According to a Harris poll conducted in November, about 18 percent of those surveyed said they had only limited interactions with their immediate family. Some PBS News viewers share their stories of alienation from family, and John Yang speaks with family therapist Whitney Goodman for advice. #familyestrangement #family #holidays #holidaysfamily #pbsnews #newshour #pbsnewshour #holidaygatherings #whitneygoodman #johnyang

pbsnews
pbsnews
Open In TikTok:
Region: US
Tuesday 24 December 2024 19:45:00 GMT
284702
10842
614
766

Music

Download

Comments

daviddub01
Davidduboi :
I didn't cut contact because of how I was treated as a child, I did it because of how my parents continued to treat me as an adult and their inability to listen.
2024-12-24 20:08:00
3496
.a.kiyomi
AK :
“They’re giving Donald Trump a pass & I don’t get one” damn 😭
2024-12-25 18:02:32
948
emberfoxtail
Ember Foxtail :
"im sorry for the trauma I MAY have caused" 💀
2024-12-25 14:23:36
542
feliberry_almond23
Cate :
I’m 19 and it’s going to be my first Christmas without my family :(
2024-12-25 06:35:51
111
squeejay
squeej :
Cycle breakers are unstoppable 💜✨ wishing peace to all those who have had to move on from their abusive family for their own well being
2024-12-25 16:10:17
287
cecilystar
Cecily Star :
The pain for me with having an estranged parent is how she continues to blame me for it rather than ever taking a chance to look at herself
2024-12-25 02:01:14
228
beqbx3
mimixoxo :
The moms acting like they have no idea why they would cut them off lol.
2024-12-25 21:17:27
257
tatiana_wm
Tatiana Walk-Morris :
I'm glad folks are choosing peace over being miserable for the sake of familial obligations.
2024-12-25 04:48:22
49
authormkmorris
MK Morris🤍 | Romance Author :
The adult children putting up that boundary is so brave. They deserve better.
2024-12-25 10:13:41
742
kimberlyvancetate
Kimberly Vance Tate :
Thank you PBS for real reporting that actually applies
2024-12-24 23:36:52
742
ohheyari
Oh hey ari :
The mom’s Freudian slip with “I’ve made my peace with the fact that I may not…. IT may not ever change” lol
2024-12-25 06:52:05
568
kryptimyst
kryptimyst! :
Felt relief cutting toxic ties. It is a -privilege- to be in ur adult child’s life.
2024-12-25 05:46:40
446
noellerivers
Noelle | Indie Yapper :
“That I may have caused her” oh boy
2024-12-25 11:03:24
414
alixsunnysidesup
Alix ☀️ Sun :
“Unless u can pretend to like me, I haven’t heard from her since.” a lot of our parents are bullies
2024-12-25 14:39:20
401
springbreakstan
user6552754081111 :
My holidays are so much happier and less stressful without them. My mother has screamed “you ruined Christmas” at me so many times I lost count.
2024-12-24 23:24:39
344
onlyvans_hairlesscats
OnlyVans_HairlessCats :
If my parent had listened to me when I brought up my feelings about childhood and actually cared and said sorry it would be different. But instead “it didn’t happen like that” and more led to cut off
2024-12-24 23:31:41
291
thecatfive
Five Cats to Rule Them All :
I appreciate a very real report for once. Please more of this 👍🏻
2024-12-25 02:45:02
247
ehemen1746
amanda :
My mother recognizes & acknowledges that my childhood was tough (emotionally). She lets me talk about it & apologizes. It means so much to me that she tries so hard to respect my perspective ❤️
2024-12-25 05:15:28
239
katieburke007
Katie :
People judge for being estranged from my mom until they find out she tried to yeet me from this planet.
2024-12-24 23:55:25
215
moniqueh.83
moniqueh83 :
They didn’t listen to me as a child or even as an adult. I’m done & my life has been better since I’ve cut them off.
2024-12-25 09:08:34
158
gehs.bandos
Gehs Bandos :
family isn't always where you come from or blood. family is created along the way of life. ❤️
2024-12-24 23:21:28
132
posh.foodie.professor
The Posh History Professor :
I agree that people are talking about it more, which is good because others are (hopefully) becoming less judgemental.
2024-12-24 20:32:17
94
irish89871
Irish89 :
Your peace is important as someone estranged from my only sibling. My parents are gone.
2024-12-24 20:11:46
93
hellscape2025
😈 🦹‍♀️ :
I don't miss the fighting either!!
2024-12-25 00:40:00
78
cherrybrat
🍒 :
My problem personally is that I’ve accepted what’s happened in the past, however, when I see my siblings being treated entirely different (we have different dads) it triggers my childhood pain again🙄
2024-12-25 01:34:27
73
sh3lly_g
Shelly :
“I wanted who I wanted as a mom there”
2024-12-25 13:56:49
72
maddiescroggin
Madeleine Scroggin :
As a therapist, yes yes yes to all of this. Healthy boundaries is so important, you feeling healthy, loved and valued is so important. Hope everyone takes care during the holidays ♥️
2024-12-25 03:14:24
41
feralgoblinmama3918
Feral Goblin :
I think I needed to hear this on Christmas Eve, I’m still working on healing the mother wound while navigating motherhood and it felt good to know I am not alone.
2024-12-25 02:45:45
40
retired_daughterinlaw
retired daughter-in-law :
My parents want me to acknowledge how hard their life was but refuse to acknowledge how hard mine was because of it. The projection and denial is what hurts the most.
2024-12-25 15:16:24
39
fieryphoenixrising
🐦‍🔥FieryPhoenixRising🐦‍🔥 :
my bio mother's lack of accountability and constant blamong me of things I could not possibly be responsible for, along with her saying she wished she'd allowed all the bad things to happen to me....
2024-12-25 00:02:03
38
amaiabrooke
Amaia Brooke 🇱🇺 🆘 🇺🇸 :
The narcissist mothers trying to make us feel sorry for them. Exactly why we are no contact.
2024-12-24 22:50:38
37
nt_nt_09
Natalie 🌸 :
the problem isn't the past, the trauma...the problem that they still want to be their toxic self and it's unpleasant and painful to be around them...they want to be the boss and you must shut your mouth and listen their bs..
2024-12-24 21:52:12
37
miraclius
Miraclius :
I’m estranged from my father
2024-12-25 00:36:10
36
jayshins
Jayshins :
Long story short - people are choosing to step away from abusive/toxic family members and are speaking more about it publicly instead of privately like how it’s been for most of modern time
2024-12-24 23:17:14
29
sparrowrowrowyourboat
Sparrow🐢 :
My family was already emotionally unsafe, but with the election, I have come to understand that if I was unrelated, they would treat me or ignore the way others treat me and other people.
2024-12-25 14:14:19
26
safaalbrahi1
Safa :
This is great, the girl in green is so well spoken.
2024-12-24 23:15:23
24
espeonaa
🌸Espeonaa Stephanie 🌼 :
I gotta know if any of them are related to each other. Watching the video back like 👁️👄 👁️
2024-12-24 23:32:19
23
andreaeskridge1
Andrea Stevenson Esk :
And I don’t miss it.
2024-12-25 00:15:42
18
jhenriquezz
✩ ꒻ꏂꑄꑄ ☾ :
I understand how these folks feel. I hope this video helps everyone who’s estranged with any family
2024-12-25 03:04:26
17
blkrofahc9a
MsEmotions :
I think this is a good sign of healthy boundaries.
2024-12-25 03:28:58
16
tgp1856
tgp1856 :
More often than not, children’s first bullies are their own parents.
2024-12-25 02:50:10
15
taylorgiamost
taylorgiamost :
Thank you for sharing this.
2024-12-24 23:01:21
15
keithhhh92
Keith :
I’m estranged from my older sister, her family, and my dads family as well.
2024-12-25 04:41:20
14
marlena.di
M :
Estranged parents are the problem 99% of the time. I’ve never met a person estranged from their children who didn’t do everything possible wrong and basically torture their kids into leaving
2024-12-25 00:37:33
14
ashleywithanxiety
Philomashley :
I cut off my conservative republican mother 3 years ago and I’ve never been happier. Highly recommended!!
2024-12-25 00:21:05
13
infamousmamahenry
infamousmamahenry :
Thank you for showing my normal
2024-12-25 12:38:57
12
realitybites05
Iris🏳️‍🌈🤘🔥 :
Too much stuff happen in my family for me to ever let it go or overlook it.
2024-12-25 11:39:53
11
emann.iii
Manii :
This was a great segment
2024-12-25 07:22:13
11
tay.t71
Tay T :
mine was so abu5ive &the others that she alow2abu5ve me (brother's SA)though out the yrs. I have peace. Not having them thier has been the best for me.
2024-12-25 00:41:51
11
To see more videos from user @pbsnews, please go to the Tikwm homepage.

Other Videos


About