Tay $moke, MBA Candidate
Region: US
Thursday 09 January 2025 00:53:08 GMT
18827
1630
67
128
Music
Download
Comments
AlexB_SSBM :
Yes, this is why anti monopoly is so important. Communism leads to incredible suffering, and we need market mechanisms to prevent planned economy collapse. Economists hate monopoly too!
2025-01-09 16:26:02
20
Blake :
This reminds me of the concept of Market Stalinism that Mark Fisher talked about
2025-01-09 15:54:02
35
yeah :
didn’t Marx and Engels already describe most/all of this, or am i missing something? “Socialism: Utopian and Scientific” section 3 in particular seems to cover similar ground in just a few paragraphs
2025-01-10 18:00:53
34
AdamMangana :
Thank you for posting this 😅
2025-01-09 01:50:52
2
Joseph Ponzillo :
The parts in the book I liked were good but the parts that annoyed me really annoyed me
2025-01-09 17:38:29
1
David :
Love this book.
2025-01-10 23:33:36
0
Wyatt :
Read this life by Martin hagglund for a philosophical elucidation of this idea
2025-01-09 21:06:58
2
K3xTrooper :
I mean, it might be possible to plan an economy like this but each year would get exponentially harder to do with very little benefits for the average person.
2025-01-09 05:08:55
1
Sully :
Interesting, but this ingnores that neither have the majority of the market. When people purchase any products their are a variety of options for both online and retail
2025-01-12 01:46:40
0
amdsupreme :
Book seems to assume capitalism is an argument against central planning when it’s really an argument against misaligned incentives. Walmart and Amazon built these systems because their bottom lines depended on it - when you take these systems out of that environment, what incentives will prevent them from stagnating?
2025-01-10 16:01:36
8
MonkeyBrains :
What a dumb take
2025-01-10 07:16:36
1
larbyy_ :
This is not a good book. Reddit understanding of socialism. Unimpressive grad student understanding of economics
2025-01-10 13:20:52
5
Chanch :
Bro read about the democratic centralism. USSR was democratic. China is already sublating US capitalism through these exact same planning strategies and coordination ie. 5 year plans.
2025-01-10 14:39:10
2
PrinceoftheValli :
Been saying that they should convert all major capitalist corporations to government union based socialized businesses
2025-01-13 00:14:25
1
Robespierre :
You missed the point of the book that centralization is inevitable and it should be handled democratically. The solution is democracy not decentralization.
2025-01-11 00:51:54
1
Julien Clark :
Unregulated capitalism leads to fascism… this is why antimonopoly laws exist
2025-01-11 06:50:35
0
ancientlazerz :
I agree. In its essence, socialism is just a better version of capitalism. Communism is a better version of socialism and so on.
2025-01-11 05:14:39
0
Fart_Thompson :
China kicks ass because their economy is centrally planned and organized
2025-01-11 02:08:17
0
uniformtraffic :
This is the central conflict - you can't have democracy and central planning. Most people are fools who have no business making decisions for society
2025-01-10 02:21:14
0
diabloenbici :
just marxists taking credit for things that they themselves are not resourceful enough to do accomplish. nothing to see here
2025-01-10 17:09:51
0
GoingStrategic :
USSR had math and economics PhDs in their “Economic central planning”. Historic analysis showed they were smart & detailed math models. But they still failed. Free market has people on the ground factor in knowledge that the centralized few planners won’t have access to.
2025-01-10 18:15:51
0
perceivengaging :
It’s 1000% price signaling these companies arnt selling stuff that isn’t profit generating if the logistical networks have lots of nodes that doesn’t mean it isn’t capitalist profit
2025-01-10 04:20:25
0
tinytopple :
You might be interested in Paul Cockshott’s work.
2025-01-10 14:51:26
3
To see more videos from user @taysmokedank, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.
