@gothixwarrior: litterally me: |#rdr2 #rdr1 #strangeman #edit #fyp #johnmarston #fypシ゚ #fypp #foryoupage

CrabWitDaHat :

Heidi Mccourt was to dutch how jimmy brooks was to arthur

bossmonster618 :

I feel like the strange man is the grim reaper. He's been seen by Arthur and John and both have died due to their actions finally catching up to them

HAL :

I think it's cool to think death considers every insignificant life as more important than his own

Ahmed :

You have forgotten far more important people than me (Arthur morgan)

GenericEdgyUsername :

I always liked the theory that the face the strange man takes is the man John killed in chicago at 12.

valarr :

"oh but you will"

blaize :

he is death himself, all the places he knows john from are places he himself has visited to collect the souls of the people john has killed. he goes by many names, and is an accountant “in a way”.

jack :

ive always wondered if the strange man knew heidi mccourt personally

Skips :

John apparently wasn’t the only person who saw the strange man Dutch and the other gang members saw a man with a black suit and a tophat hanging around black water after the massacre

Someonesfault :

the fact they kept bringing Heidi up, is what makes me believe rdr3 will be another prequel to rdr2

I call shotgun🤫 :

I know John and Arthur are people favorite characters, but people tend to forget that they’re probably burning in hell for the lives they took

Мурзик морган :

im writed literally me

ADragonsTale :

He says “ this is a nice spot” I think that was the same spot John was buried.

حسن :

but John didn't get shot during the backwater massacer?

Stefanus :

The song is Insomniac by Memo Boy for who wants to know

Dipshit289 :

He's the honor system

✟ :

rip van winkle

John mustard :

sh4zu1 :

3 shots the gun stopped at the 4th shot it spared jacks life

Terry Daniel’s :

He’s question John’s morality about all the people he kills with no repercussions or thought

I’m literally John marston :

I’m literally John marston

keyz :

Is he acc the devil?

_mmmaks_ :

это смерть

Harry :

I think he represents all the people John’s killed over the years

Chief Evil Daddy :

The thing is strange man might be the grim reaper or something cause in gta 5 online there is an outfit that you can buy called “the undertaker” and it’s the exact outfit the strange man has