@toetallymine: One of the best representations of guilt and regret in all fiction #silenthill2 #jamesunderland #silenthill #videostar #videostar #foryoupage #fyp #silenthilledit
ppl saying James is a good man who made a mistake... HE SMOTHERED HIS WIFE BC HE WAS SELFISH AND LUSTFUL, he himself knows it, he regrets obviously and is in pain now, but he can't take it back he killed the person that loved him the most, and THAT makes him a bad man. Can't go back from there sadly.
2025-07-13 17:32:32
19556
Angel face :
James defenders when they realize they’re mischaracterizing him and the entire point of silent hill was to force him and YOU to realize he was in fact a bad person and even though he feels remorse, he is still a very terrible person who killed his wife because he was selfish.
2025-08-15 18:22:05
2785
rachel :
everyone fighting about whether he’s good or bad is supporting the creators’ whole point of the story about being a morally gray and how people can appear both good or evil and sometimes even be both. he’s not entirely good, but he’s not entirely evil either, if he was entirely evil the story wouldn’t exist, but if he was entirely good he wouldn’t have done what he did.
2025-08-01 05:31:17
4505
407.cade_error.proxy :
You smothered one wife and everybody just thinks you the bad guy now 😭🙏
2025-07-15 12:58:50
4361
Col :
2025-07-31 23:05:55
3974
JUDOLIZARD :
Regret, definitely but not the best representation of guilt. That goes to spec ops the line.
2025-07-15 14:26:10
1308
sgraces._ :
how are people defending him i dont get it. he simply isnt a good person.
2025-07-31 15:51:18
464
kollinalt :
James is meant to be an extremely complicated character - just like real people are
2025-07-21 17:59:26
1021
duvani :
Its so complicated. He isn't good, but he isn't bad. He is truly an amazingly written character. I feel bad for him but I also think he got what he deserved, he is too complex to be summarized with just "good" or "bad".
2025-07-22 23:49:11
767
Lossei :
playing as the ab*ser is one of the most iconic things about sh2 and you dont realize it until certain moments like James treating Maria well but not the other girl bc he didnt want her.
2025-08-20 09:33:19
561
MJ_Skater_Man :
I love that the point was never to redeem him, but merely to make him come to terms with what he did and why he did it. It doesn’t make him any better of a person for what he did, and it was always more complex than just good or bad. He beat his silent Hill. What will he do now? Where will he go? What an amazing game.
2025-08-02 11:25:53
625
Habibi :
he wasn't a good Man yall that was the WHOLE point
2025-07-18 05:00:44
37
calle :
finished this masterpiece today
2025-07-16 16:59:28
474
Mix 🍀 :
Not “one of the best” just the best ✌️
2025-07-01 03:29:50
918
yu narukami lover :
all these comments fighting with air by saying he's a bad man shows how they didn't get the point
the game literally forces u to think about what's morally right for you and what's wrong, it challenges your view of morality by showing you different difficult situations. there's no good or bad characters, it's called being gray. every one of them is a representation for actual real life people, that shows how mental problems affect people's lifes. it's up to you to interpret what's okay for you and what's not, but not a single person in the game is full blown demon or a saint.
2025-07-19 09:56:39
821
Kyle R :
James be like
2025-08-26 15:05:34
60
Dopa DeMine :
La gente que lo odia no jugó el juego hombre
2025-07-20 13:36:14
150
Danny Estrada R. :
Yo si te perdono James
2025-09-25 12:59:48
0
kdarius :
that "oh"💔
2025-07-11 09:41:01
157
Cadence𒉭 :
Silent Hill is peak
2025-07-10 15:58:20
398
gatsu_73 :
James has such a lethal face card
2025-07-07 23:30:46
168
ThatGuyEfrain :
2025-07-18 21:39:53
106
gasm :
Should I buy this it’s on sale is it that good?
2025-07-17 22:36:36
12
a lad :
good, bad. no defined line. everyone will see him differently. we all can either understand and forgive or condemn and punish. even James' endings are based on how we treat him and his actions. I'll never forget Silent hill.
2025-07-14 22:25:06
179
Cian :
James isnt supposed to be good or bad. He murdered his wife because he hated her, but thats the point. Thats the point, the regret, the guilt.
2025-10-21 06:49:22
5
To see more videos from user @toetallymine, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.