@jmmcarter: September is a bit of a mixed month for my book subscriptions. Two of my books are going to a new home (and are saving me some money) and I've been convinced to keep the other three. I've been introduced to some new books while putting this list together too, which I'm excited to see more reviews for. Which books are you keeping and which are getting skipped? #bookstan #BookTok #specialeditionbooks #fantasybooktok #romantasy
I know that some people have complaints about Illumicrate's picks but I am actually really enjoying the selection this year! I was so happy they picked The second death of Locke, I am sure the edition is gonna be absolutely gorgeous ♥️
2025-08-22 11:21:32
9
ink.undermoonlight :
I had an ARC of Mistress of Bones and it was not the best, honestly. The writing was chaotic and all over the place, couldn't keep up, was confusing. I wanted to love it and love supporting new authors but it wasn't for me.
2025-09-09 13:16:41
1
Ros Burrows 🇿🇦 🐴 :
So I’m new to having a subscription box. I have illumicrate adult only and fairyloot adult. Do they do series? And if they do series do they finish them in the subs?
2025-10-01 21:44:44
0
Mothling :
I just cancelled my LL subscription, it just hasn't stood up against the other boxes the last year :(
2025-08-22 22:41:49
1
Louie_writes :
have you read sisters of fire and fury? if you like lady knights you might enjoy it!
2025-08-22 21:34:30
0
Alexandra Rayson :
I’ve got so many Waterstones preorders for September so I’ve skipped all my book boxes except for FL romantasy. I was going to keep my FL YA/A combo but I wasn’t a fan of the design of alchemised from the tease…
2025-08-22 13:23:22
2
Liv :
I’m gutted that I haven’t been taken off the waitlist for fairyloot romantasy. I want Metal Slinger so badly😭
2025-08-22 12:16:48
1
Empowering Exercise :
Have you seen the fairyloot version of Direbound!!?! 🐺 😱
2025-08-22 13:18:29
1
Becky Thomas :
This for locked library!! I hope they do a SE of when the moon hatched 2!
2025-08-22 12:37:44
1
Siobhan :
I cannot wait for Illumicrate September! The Second Death of Locke is one of my top 3 reads this year! I wouldn’t call it a ‘straight romantasy’ though. The paring is MF, however both main characters are openly queer (as is the whole main cast, so definitely not straight), and it’s not quite a romantasy either I wouldn’t say. Probably fantasy romance, but it definitely leans towards epic fantasy. I’m sure the design is going to be gorgeous 🥰
2025-08-22 11:12:28
1
Melissa🩷 books and beauty💄 :
Definitely skipping forbidden wing and possibly page and wick 😆
2025-08-22 18:54:52
1
Jelly :
September is a big month! I was lucky enough to save a kind someone a skip for the FL combo box. The rest of my keeps are IC, BB, Darkly, OC adult, & faecrate combo. Brand new to me I'm trying Book in a Box and TBB SF/F.
2025-08-23 02:58:34
1
cher_in_books 📚 :
I bet Metal Slinger will be gorgeous. I loved the story. Currently on all the waitlist so sometimes I try not to even look at what’s coming because it makes me sad. Just wish there wasn’t so many people scalping books.
2025-08-24 12:37:02
0
phoe_62 :
I wanted the fairyloot ya book, so I’ve already found someone to sell the adult book to. On the other hand, I’m SO excited for the Illumicrate book!
2025-08-22 11:32:28
1
holly.reads :
Keeping both Fairyloot, SO excited for Illumicrate too, it's the pick i've been most excited for out of all of theirs this year. Skipping Afterlight and Bookish Box. I really want my Page and Wick too - the customisations will be beautiful and I am interested in this story, but there's also so many special edition sales in September that I want to pick up too so I might have to skip it 😫
2025-08-22 12:15:33
1
ChristyLoo :
I sold my FL Adult too (at cost) and it’s been sold for close to a month already. I’m still trying to sell the YA to try and save a skip. I’ve skipped Illimicrate as my pre-orders are insane in Sept and if I decide later I want it, it’s fairly easy to get the sub book later from Illimicrate. And a note on What Fury Brings - it has not been marketed correctly. It is a DARK romance. I read the arc and personly didn’t like it - too many plot holes, ending seemed “rushed”, and the whole thing just wasn’t done well. It could have been so good, and it just wasn’t (again, just my opinion)
2025-08-22 14:44:19
0
Laura ✨ mythsandmargins 📚 :
I’m getting the Fairyloot YA box for the items alone. I read the arc of the book and it was just ok for me.
2025-08-22 19:05:12
0
Louie_writes :
I'm skipping the ya fairyloot as I've also read a few by her and they're ok but not my fave
2025-08-22 21:28:32
0
To see more videos from user @jmmcarter, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.