@theatlantic: Motivated by Zohran Mamdani’s mayoral primary win in New York, the Democratic Socialists of America are dreaming big, Arash Azizi writes. But little from their recent convention suggested a movement intent on winning elections and coming to power. At the convention in Chicago, the DSA pledged to “build a broad left-labor coalition” and “draft a socialist candidate” to run for president in 2028. But for the average voter, “American socialists are simply not a distinct, recognizable political force,” Azizi writes. The DSA can be divided into two ideological wings. The mass-politics wing seeks to elect socialists as Democrats and build a national organization that connects with the average American, while the sectarian wing follows more extreme politics. This wing has one caucus that openly supports Hamas, another that faults the Green New Deal for failing to articulate “a clear commitment to dismantling the settler-colonial and American imperialist projects,” and another that calls for DSA “to free itself from the Democratic Party” and “fight to overthrow the Constitution.” Since 2023, the organization’s leadership has been effectively controlled by the sectarian wing. And the clashes between these two wings have had real-life consequences. The DSA refused to endorse Joe Biden or Kamala Harris in the past two presidential elections. The crowd at this year’s convention “seemed to consist of a consortium of activists, many of them focused on single issues,” Azizi writes. “Mamdani, AOC, and Sanders were absent, and so was their welcoming, practical political style.” In fact, the DSA’s national leadership has voted not to endorse AOC, and many in the organization are now actively hostile to her. A motion to discuss Donald Trump’s presidency was voted down. “Democratic socialists who seek to run mass campaigns and attain power with elections are now encumbered by sharing an organization with ‘confrontationists’ who hold fundamentally antidemocratic beliefs,” Azizi continues at the link in our bio. “If they wish to build a political force capable of coming to power, they must first decide who their allies are.” 🎨: The Atlantic. Source: Getty.

The Atlantic
The Atlantic
Open In TikTok:
Region: US
Wednesday 27 August 2025 19:49:12 GMT
24386
505
125
11

Music

Download

Comments

dplants3
dplants :
The establishment democrats who are refusing to endorse Mamdani after his primary win are the ones preventing unity within the party
2025-08-27 21:57:38
123
cjfc420
CJFC :
The owners of the Atlantic hold fundamentally anti-democratic beliefs.
2025-08-28 02:26:13
174
robbyplaysthetrombone
Robby Simpson :
"sOciALiStS cAn'T WiN!!"
2025-08-28 00:22:12
62
dtok85
dtok :
I think a better term would be accelerationists. Many on the left don’t want to improve anything because they think that will just delay the overthrow of capitalism. They’re like evangelicals waiting for the rapture.
2025-08-27 20:01:55
25
oo_mox
oo-mox :
Dems are losing their base because they are still running centrists and conservatives while isolating progressives.
2025-08-27 20:50:16
57
monstackx
Neul ఇ :
Five years ago, AOC was being sidelined by the Dems leadership (and even legacy media) for being "too extreme," yet suddenly when the Dem-socs call out her complicity in the gcide she is a victim? Pick a lane! Saying that a faction of DSAs are “extremists” because they support Palestinian resistance (armed or peaceful) and do not think that green initiatives go far enough is exactly why the Democrats are losing their base. 1947 called, they want their anti-commie, fear-mongering tactics back. Also if anything, the fact that the DSA refused to support Biden or Harris means they have an accurate read when it comes to gauging what the people are feeling. I wish I could write a better response to this god-awful post because the sheer idiocy and waffling so perfectly captures how and why most liberal/progressice voters do not support Dem politicians or even "journalists" like Azizi.
2025-08-27 20:24:24
28
brickothy
Brickothy🔻 :
Clearly this writer hasn’t read The Jakarta Method and is unaware that capitalists will commit heinous atrocities before ever letting a leftist win democratically. we live in a dictatorship of the ruling class currently & the other option is the dictatorship of the masses
2025-08-28 11:51:51
36
alexjs85
Alex S :
Pardon me for not trusting The Atlantic for good faith analysis of American socialism
2025-08-28 17:25:54
30
zacharykiebler
Zach :
Dems would have to abandon their corporate donors. The attacks are coming from inside for a good reason.
2025-08-27 20:48:23
27
movingvan
Van Wilson :
The Atlantic is trash juice
2025-08-28 00:45:27
32
dogwaterdonut
dogwaterdonut :
Please please please, I'm begging socialists to actually put their candidates in the primaries. 😭
2025-08-27 20:10:13
8
thepatrickarchy
ThePatrickarchy :
Surprise surprise, the Atlantic trying to throw cold water on promising candidates who weren’t grown in a lab at the McKinzie consulting firm.
2025-08-28 08:03:57
51
davidhawkins671
davidhawkins671 :
Not clear why radical leftists hamstring progressive politics, but radical rightists control the Republican Party.
2025-08-28 19:08:54
1
thepettyroosevelt
PettyRoosevelt :
nope
2025-08-29 02:00:21
1
imaginaryislandii
imaginary island :
Paid for by the DNC
2025-09-02 02:30:24
2
peri_bathos
Peri Bathos :
The Atlantic is capable to publishing the most banal and unrooted analysis I have seen outside of a Thomas Friedman article.
2025-08-29 01:04:52
6
nickamemus
nickamemus :
The capital owners of this country are anti democratic.
2025-08-28 16:40:21
2
michaelwilson0929
michaelwilson0929 :
No no you’re right. We should run moderate like last time. She won, right? No? Lost by historical margins? At least Mamdani lost. No? Won with historic turn out? Hmmmm
2025-08-29 02:21:34
2
mattymoron
mattymoron ☭ :
Arash had to publish his hit piece in the IDF paper? what a shock!
2025-08-28 00:27:34
21
creepwalker
creepwalker :
The Atlantic has always been corporate/aipac propaganda.
2025-08-28 14:00:57
9
jackdawack76
Jackdawack76 :
thank you the atlantic, thats something called NOT being the democratic party. and lucky for you, the DSA actually isn’t the democratic party!
2025-08-27 23:40:15
4
thegreatyeehaw77
thegreatyeehaw77 :
Yea they didn’t endorse Biden or Harris because they are the DSA not the Democratic Party, they need to win over their endorsement, glad to help clear that up.
2025-08-28 09:04:45
2
xhellcor
XHELLCOR :
Socialists don’t win bc of the CIA
2025-08-28 12:29:18
1
rossbrannon
Rossypoo :
To be clear, violent socialist revolution still has a democratic process to it.
2025-08-28 19:49:32
2
To see more videos from user @theatlantic, please go to the Tikwm homepage.

Other Videos


About