@scalingstories: u/Calm-Plan2521 Am I the jerk for asking my sister-in-law to return the necklace I gifted her, even though I promised her a replacement? Plus one update. 0:00 Original Post 5:29 Update (1 Month Later) #scalingstories #minecraftparkour #reddit #redditreadings #redditstories
Im sorry but the sil took advantage of her kindness. You can't agree to a replacement AND to return the original and then decide to keep it and still expect another one.
2025-08-30 18:14:51
7715
joceylachulita :
The fact she still gave her the replacement necklace🤦🏽♀️
2025-08-30 18:14:40
3238
djcmore :
Owes OP 3,000 dollars and she's still on speaking terms with her brother?! 😳😳😳
2025-08-30 18:34:50
2271
Flif :
£3000?!? And you still treated her to nice things? I think OP is absolutely in the right and should be very careful to not give the second one before being given the original again
2025-08-30 18:13:39
2481
Texas Roadhouse Bloomin' Onion :
forever grateful for Scaling Stories
2025-08-30 21:45:36
18
Azira Dandelion :
May be a cultural thing, but in my country it's normal to take back a gift if you have to make some changes (size, color, etc). I'd just take the necklace right there.
2025-08-30 22:53:14
648
VeryMindful :
Why are people saying ESH? It’s very clear OP is not an AH. I don’t get why people are assigning malicious intent to her
2025-08-30 19:02:22
783
Dj :
The back and forth soured the gift I wouldn’t gift her jewelry anymore period
2025-08-30 18:23:11
1132
tito :
op is a saint, is my brother owed me 3000 i wouldnt be buying expensive gifts
2025-08-30 21:06:11
920
JessiCaelle67 :
Why would she fear a jeweler will ruin the neckless? That's literally their job? 🤔
2025-08-30 22:17:01
300
bri xoxo :
nta, the store analogy is perfect. no exchange without turning over the original. glad op stood on business
2025-08-30 18:15:08
455
Jade :
The comments are wrong they had a verbal agreement so it’s not like OP was being greedy
2025-08-30 21:02:41
274
Grace :
honestly think they wanted both necklaces to sell or pawn off. That’s just an assumption considering the vibe the brother gives off and also how greedy the SIL is
2025-08-30 22:39:53
87
Catherine :
they got greedy and now they wont get cool gifts anymore
2025-08-30 23:57:08
83
Candy :
It’s not taking back the gift. If a Louis Vuitton shirt didn’t fit someone your returning it and buying them their size why is that different? It’s exchanging it for something more suitable
2025-08-30 23:45:51
56
Freezer🪷 :
“Requesting money from my brother” ITS YOUR MONEY😭😭😭
2025-08-31 20:01:49
29
Polynesian Potato 🌺 :
She's definitely not seeing the money from her brother, and they're definitely going to blame it on her being "petty" and "bitter" about the necklace
2025-08-30 22:54:32
128
✨BVT 🍉 :
I don’t know why people keep saying she’s taking the gift back, she’s exchanging it. The same way you exchange clothes if they don’t fit, you’re not returning, but changing it for something else. I don’t know why some commenters don’t get that
2025-08-31 20:38:02
68
RainV :
It’s crazy bc it’s already in the word “replacement”. How do you ask someone to replace something and not give them said thing? An exchange is required.
2025-09-01 04:32:54
18
barbie :
imo they want to know the value of the original necklace so they can have an idea of how much they can sell it for
2025-08-31 02:33:07
136
🇲🇽HOMOsapien🏳️🌈 :
I feel like this whole thing could’ve been advoid if she offered to get a chain extension for it instead 💀
2025-08-30 19:09:25
1109
shesblackandeducated :
The niece was never going to get that necklace — they were going to sell it and keep the money.
2025-08-31 00:00:06
30
Pipestone❌ :
Yeah, they were planning to get two very expensive necklaces out of OP and never pay her for the first one.
2025-08-31 14:51:42
24
Pinkish Usagi :
Sister-in-law “gave the other necklace to her daughter “, then basically took it away from her when she realized she wasn’t gonna get another necklace, wanted to receive the value of them, and the brother is $3000 in debt to OP. I find it a little suspicious, and think they just planned on selling the necklaces for cash. And not to pay back OP
2025-08-30 19:49:21
149
𝘊𝘌𝘕𝘛𝘐 :
OP agreed to get a better necklace, plus she was even in "know" about getting the necklace back, Sam should've let OP know that she changed her mind ATP OP should return the second necklace or keep it
2025-08-30 18:11:48
223
To see more videos from user @scalingstories, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.