i'm glad she never forgave him and that her knight became like her father to her 💙
2025-09-25 16:24:16
4514
monkeydlaufey :
hated how ray never voiced out to his father about his mistreatment to dorothy, even when dorothy was kidnapped ray never got mad at his father for not saving dorothy. He was a bystander
2025-09-26 14:35:41
3005
_yVnd_cfvn :
I never understood why he hates her
2025-09-12 11:50:05
3483
Yawn :
WDY A BABY WAS KIDNAPPED AND SHE HAD TO SAVE HERSELF??! the father is unforgivable 😭
2025-09-26 03:56:57
651
Aiwasntbornyasterday :
Gallahan Lombardy could never😭😭😭
2025-09-25 08:58:59
2589
nors | 🥀 :
GALLAHAN LOMBARDY BEST DAD EVER!!!
2025-10-08 04:48:45
114
Holly_g14 :
I felt bad for ray cuz he always loved his sister
2025-09-26 10:46:24
609
Fonessari :
I still hate him tho.
2025-09-26 04:06:56
1433
V 🔹•ʚ• 🔹⊙⊝⊜ :
when she was kidnapped and saved herself 😭
2025-09-26 02:00:03
1096
SkykidDan 𓆩⟡𓆪 :
I like the fact that it suits so much and even though their own father neglected Dorothy, Her big brother was still there and supporting, adoring, and loving her like a real brother would. He thinks that Dorothy hates him and hides his pain for her 🥺 In Dorothy's previous timeline, He smiled at her one last time before being killed by her 😭😭 He never hated Dorothy 🥺
2025-09-26 03:53:34
316
rdead883 :
I just can’t like Ray an issue I always see with the bystander golden child is that they are justified to love their sibling but nothing in the actual source material often shows that
2025-09-30 19:04:29
143
V :
I hated Ray so much tbh, how could you love someone and not do anything? That's your sister, you could've said something.
2025-09-30 13:13:51
84
rrkive7 :
the dad never had a reason to hate her. he just did then regretted it
2025-09-25 17:08:22
339
def not syaf?!? :
his brother loves was a poison to her
2025-09-25 19:37:19
182
anone :
Best ever angst manhwa, you can't bear the pain😭😭😭
2025-09-26 03:29:56
0
BlackberryAce :
I can't stand how her own brother never stood up for her even when she WAS KIDNAPPED
2025-09-28 11:14:04
95
🩵💙💨TOKITO MUICHIRO 🩵💙💨 :
MY SHAYLA!
2026-02-06 19:17:35
6
Aminat Omotoyosi :
She had every right to be the villain in the first life
2025-09-29 06:52:51
146
☁︎´𝒍𝒊𝒍𝒂𝒄´☁︎ :
2025-10-05 14:38:51
36
aika♡ :
the dad pmo
2025-09-25 05:34:34
68
Lyndajeffry :
i know he's innocent but i can't help myself from hating him and ofcourse the dad. i dropped this quite early in the manhwa so pls anyone tell me the brother will tell the dad off or atleast be mad at the dad. i always hate to see the brother being all smiley😩
2025-09-26 10:30:28
94
meow :
this is such a well written manhwa actually
2025-09-30 19:21:25
8
wehellalame :
That’s right. Her dad is Stefan.
2025-09-26 07:55:14
15
Mochi_chav :
The ending was kinda rushed- I wanted to see some sort of resolution with Dorothy and the emperors relationship when he was on his death bed but no. Nothing happened and it was lokey kinda boring😭
2025-09-27 21:33:07
18
Ate Happy :
It's so unfair. Like, they're twins so why is she the only one getting hated😭 I sometimes question that is it just because she's a girl?! Why are all these manhwa dad have unreasonable mistreatment to their daughter. LET THE MOM LIVE THIS TIME INSTEAD OF THOSE👺👹
2025-10-03 01:31:25
6
To see more videos from user @eliemanhwa, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.