@commiespontex: #stitch with @Your Communist Friend Whether you call China socialist or not is entirely up to you, but a Marxian analysis of China’s productive activity using Marx’s theory of value demonstrates without question that the mode of production in operation there is entirely capitalist. #communist #marxism #socialism #leftist
I mean, to be fair I think the argument is more so about whether or not the Chinese system is still socialist-oriented, I doubt there is anyone knowing their stuff claiming that China is "actively" already socialist
2025-09-22 08:42:17
12
antarctic536 :
Is the US a socialist country then? Or I guess it is technofeudalist like Varoufakis says. But doesn’t that mean Marx is wrong 😱.
2025-09-21 15:03:50
1
Dr. Sirius :
The beginning of this video is just Chapter 1 of Capital. It's fundamental theory for the Marxist.
China is engaging in individualized labor processes built on profit rather than community need. They tolerate private ownership of production which allows for the appropriation of commodities in exchange for wages (and therefore an ensuing appropriation of the surplus-value created by labor). This social relation is necessarily exploitative as the capitalist can never pay the workers the full exchange value of what they produce (i.e., they cannot forfeit profit). While the PRC is moving toward socialism, it would be disingenuous to say they've already achieved this goal.
2025-09-21 16:03:28
157
steppegirl :
no country that has a stock market is socialist no matter how hard you can try to convince me
2025-09-21 22:22:25
78
ComradeLilian :
loudeeeeeer🗣️🗣️🗣
2025-09-21 10:58:19
64
sheebdog :
Do you view China as bad because of this? Are you a Trotskyist or Anarchist? What’s your analysis of China, what should they do instead?
2025-10-12 16:42:54
1
unabunca :
money was used as a mediator of value prior to capitalism though, what's the difference between Romans using currency as an abstraction of value to early or modern capitalist use of currency as an abstraction?
2025-09-23 17:46:24
4
emily☭ :
Where did the video about We Are Dancers go?
2025-09-21 11:58:59
2
frederick I :
For Marx sovereignity of the capital relation is the supreme qualifier, not the ubiquity of commodities.
2025-09-25 19:00:41
2
WiseYouthStrongAge :
Capitalism within China is like an elephant in the room: as long as the room is lavish enough and the elephant weak enough, people won’t pay attention to it. But what about the future?
2025-09-23 02:02:15
9
Ze Mog :
Thank you !
2025-09-21 11:09:40
13
ⒶInternationalistⒶ :
I love this
2025-09-22 02:12:57
0
TALOS :
Sensational
2025-09-24 21:55:30
1
Chartreusepickle28 :
YESSS
2025-09-21 12:32:14
6
Gabriel جبريل :
Lol, why are you making capitalism seem based? China has a capitalist mode of production in certain sectors, yes, duh. Their state is an act of self defense. What should they do? Abolish their state and then get invaded by Japan again? What do you suppose they do bud?
2025-09-30 16:16:05
6
M ☭🐈⬛ :
Sensational! 🤌🏾
2025-09-21 16:10:17
1
otg.TeeJ :
Too many “Marxists” on this app haven’t read Marx and it shows they use quotes they’ve seen online and never dive deeper, to actually reading the man they call themselves truly lost.
2025-09-21 14:36:54
24
robbjmtz :
Dengists have no idea what you’re talking about. They don’t care that China hasn’t abolished capital, they don’t care about production for need over profit, they don’t care about the dominant mode of production, it’s all about aesthetics to them.
2025-09-21 15:53:39
10
cima :
destroyed by real and authentic materialism
2025-09-21 11:06:09
18
To see more videos from user @commiespontex, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.