For me personally a 7 makes sense with YOUR scoring system but not the one the judges seem to be using currently 😕 she could’ve been higher as compared to some others
2025-10-17 21:08:19
676
Dine&Wander :
See the thing is you still gave her 4 points higher than Andy and in line with Whitney and Mark and Robert and Whitney.
Their 7s are saying she's only 1 pt better than Andy and that's not judging fairly.
2025-10-18 00:26:58
169
Melinda 💙 :
I think the issue is they are scoring Andy too high and so her routine was lots better than Andy but to only be one point over. Love Andy so no shade on him but Elaine is so good. She’s one of my faves.
2025-10-17 21:21:04
301
libbyloo :
Alan mentioned her shoulder mobility limitations early on, and they were finding ways around it. Only so much camouflage can be done though ❤
2025-10-17 22:13:36
131
Allyson 🇨🇦⁷ :
I’m pretty sure it’s been said she had a car accident injury which gave her limitations with her shoulders/neck ?
2025-10-17 22:40:16
69
María :
Tbh I would have liked that production defined how much the “3rd” person had to be part of the dance bc some have a very active role and others like Robert had only a second in the ending.
2025-10-17 21:39:29
98
Neva Johnson :
I don’t think most of us are against her dance being scored a 7. I mean a 7 isn’t a bad score. We are just against her being scored only 1 point higher than Andy. If the judges had started off the season scoring everyone on the same rubric (Carrie Ann specifically mentioned in episode 2 or 3 that she scores no dance experience different than those with experience) and actually gave out 2-4s as they should have then we wouldn’t be in this situation.
2025-10-17 23:56:02
104
Stefany Marie :
This dance reminded me of the old school trios. Alan did an AMAZING job with the choreo!
2025-10-17 21:07:37
71
Sara Wells :
its fine if you give her that score compared to the other dancers. they are not consistent. you are more consistent. but I did LOVE Kym's tips and critiques
2025-10-18 02:55:49
33
RFK Jr hate account 🇨🇦|🇺🇸 :
I LOVED their routine and can’t believe she got 7s. Like…1 point higher than Andy? (I love Andy but come on). Alan has been killing it with the choreography too. I feel like Elaine is progressing so well each week.
2025-10-18 01:07:19
19
Harrow :
They’ve mentioned something about having to adjust certain things based on her injuries from that car accident but I don’t remember what they were
2025-10-17 21:08:51
16
breakinggab :
I've always known you were one of the best pros to be on the show ever. The way you do these videos fully explains why. The way you teach and explain things just MAKES SENSE. even to someone who's never danced. Love it
2025-10-18 01:12:45
6
Leena 🍉 :
You gave it an 8, and even if you gave it a 7 it’s 3 points higher than Andy. I think it can be difficult to process 7s for someone who is miles ahead of Andy. I think that’s what is bothering many people including myself. The same goes for giving 9s to Dylan who in my opinion didn’t deserve it and is 2 points higher than Elaine. I think the inconsistencies is what throws people off
2025-10-18 18:21:00
7
nurse.nails :
unfortunately, I didn't love that the dedicatees were involved in the dances so much, because as you said, it's hard to judge when there's heavy involvement from that third person
2025-10-17 22:14:06
40
heather_goldman :
I think I’ve heard her say because of her car accident she physically can’t keep her shoulders down
2025-10-20 08:03:39
1
Hope Curtis :
This is what I think they should do for scores. Each dance style should have a set of like 5 questions you get to give a score to. So like Foxtrot, “Did the couple stay in Frame?” Or idk other technical and then maybe 1 question for “Emotion of this dance” THEN based of those scores, you can weigh them by significance and or do an average.. higher someone smart to make a program or make an excel spreadsheet haha and that will give you your judge their final score for THAT specific dance style and couple!!! But I also expecting each celeb to be perfect at every little thing for every style of dance, while learning them in 1 week… isn’t realistic… they aren’t professionals. I don’t watch and see the small technical mistakes that the judges point out so it gets kind of annoying. So this would make it more fair in my opinion especially since they will likely never dance most dances twice in one season.
2025-10-20 17:04:43
2
Nancymollie😎 :
Me refreshing for more dance review vids 👀
2025-10-17 21:13:50
5
Pertrichord :
I really appreciate this - I loved the choreography so much but I can't read the technique super well so this helped me understand this better
2025-10-17 21:20:59
7
Marc S 🇭🇹 :
I w🥰ant Elaine and Alan to win this year
2025-10-17 21:08:29
7
Jake Vommaro :
I agree, I wish there was more of just Elaine and Alan and less of Lisa
2025-10-17 21:05:17
6
Ksrose :
I think the issue with the scoring is that it feels inconsistent as far as the show judges go.
2025-10-18 11:17:04
1
Ashley Cunningham :
I loved this dance 💃🏾 ❤
2025-10-17 21:10:57
2
Johnathan :
If you were a judge I really think you would get these judges in line!! (All, not just Carrie Anne)
2025-10-18 05:25:39
1
brittanynicole_ugc :
MY SHOW IS ON
2025-10-17 21:16:08
1
Michelle :
Love this series you’re doing! Side note, where is your table from. I love it with the chairs.
2025-10-17 22:35:57
1
To see more videos from user @sharnaburgess, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.