If Lucas liked Peyton first, then he should’ve told Peyton about his feelings for her. Later, when Brooke asked Peyton, “Hey, do you like Lucas?”, Peyton said no. So, if Peyton wasn’t honest with Brooke her best friend about her feelings for a guy that Brooke was potentially interested in, then that’s on Peyton. If Peyton didn’t give Brooke a clear answer, then Brooke had every right to go after Lucas.
2025-10-29 00:40:40
30
highbrowmeg :
It is a hot take because Peyton should’ve run off into the sunset with Jake 🤷🏾♀
2025-10-28 23:39:46
101
thatssotaihya :
Season 1, they shouldve been together but Peyton declined even after Brucas was done. But Brooke asked Peyton permission to date him and Peyton told her multiple times that she didn’t want him anymore. As for S3, Peyton will never get a pass for kissing lucas in season 3. I would never do that to my bestfriend, no matter what. Idc that she thought she was gonna 💀.
2025-10-29 01:02:12
19
Ashley BurchettAJLeefanlove23l :
Peyton is extremely overhated
2025-10-29 11:13:12
48
❀ :
ok but doing it to your bestfriend twice and brooke kept asking peyton if something was there peyton kept saying no until she finds out about the kiss while she’s already dating lucas
2025-10-29 00:13:58
21
Jdj :
Thank you!!!! Everything you said is correct! Season 1 Episode 7 Lucas and Peyton make out. Why would Brooke go after a guy that liked and made out with her best friend. Even if Peyton said she didn’t care why would someone want a guy that likes their best friend
2025-10-30 01:43:41
15
thelosoliel :
THANK U. It’s soo odd she even pursed him after they almost had SEGGS😭
2025-10-29 01:40:53
57
Blogging_w.Ju :
Let’s rewind a little more .. Brooke slept with Nathan WHILE Peyton was still with him , like are we missing that 🫠
2025-10-31 04:18:58
38
Neremie :
as a friend u never go for a guy that your friend likes
2025-10-30 13:34:01
10
Mel :
IVE FOUND MY PEOPLE !!!! YES EXACTLY!!!!
2025-10-29 03:58:12
23
jj :
Exactly! Like, Lucas and Peyton were definitely wrong, but Brooke moved crazy too. Even in Season 3, when she sent Peyton to talk to Lucas for her, she literally said, “You’re good with Lucas.” Girl, bye! Brooke always knew they had a special connection and didn’t mind using it when it benefited her. Then she always played the victim when she felt threatened. She didn’t deserve the cheating, but she enabled that mess way too much for me to see her as a true victim imo.
2025-10-29 05:15:35
23
Tnichollex :
I always said Brooke was boy crazy and she didn’t care about Peyton’s feelings. Same reason why she slept with Nathan after they “broke up” at that party. She literally never cared unless it affected her.
2025-10-30 13:29:05
25
Prettyfacequeen :
Brooke knew how Lucas & Peyton felt about each other and thought she could lucas to like her more and failed.
2025-10-30 02:38:23
9
rosie :
she had just gotten out of a borderline abusive relationship with his brother so god forbid she’s not ready to jump right in!!! Brooke trying to get them back together so she could have Lucas was insane. And the second time she went to Brooke first. All that after getting shot, losing two moms, and having a dad who basically abandons her. Way too much hate for my traumatized girl Peyton 💔
2025-10-29 13:26:58
24
aramarielee :
Girl YES AND YES and I’m convinced she was more obsessed with the idea of having him rather than Peyton and also the idea of needing him to love her more than Peyton
2025-10-29 04:02:51
9
Kenn :
Finally a safe space
2025-10-29 00:48:15
19
Tee🌺 :
Finally someone who gets it 😭😭😭 like she knew there was something between them when she swooped in when Peyton was unsure. Sure we can say Peyton & Lucas could’ve approached it a better way but I think people act like Peyton was the worst ever meanwhile don’t hold Brooke accountable for the shitty things she did as a friend. & like you said Lucas & Peyton were just inevitable. It wasn’t gonna end up good for ANYONE who tried to get in the middle.
2025-10-31 13:19:29
5
haleigh :
okay, the one in season 2 (?) is especially messed up from lucas imo because peyton thought her dad died!!! and lucas uses that to make a move
2025-10-29 15:02:51
0
Tanya :
yes, Brooke also knew that lucke liked Peyton too
2025-10-29 19:22:36
11
Pris Dimami :
Nah girl! You’re wrong for this
2025-10-29 01:33:41
18
maris👋😜 :
A wrong take. But its a take I guess.
2025-10-30 01:58:59
6
kiley 💐 :
i just hate lucas though 😭
2025-10-29 02:42:39
6
𝒥𝒶𝓎 🫶🏽 :
!!!!! yesss this is what i have been saying. it ain’t a perfect situation and they were all wrong but brooke KNEWWW and didn’t care, she wanted him and did whatever she could to get him
2025-10-28 23:40:13
5
Esha Jayy ♓️ :
somebody understands me !!!
2025-11-01 17:17:07
1
callmewhenurdope :
nah Peyton was dead wrong. they both liked him but she did know Lucas liked Peyton and Brooke did back off and that’s when Lucas started pursuing her. Peyton doing twice and then each time gaslighting Brooke, oh she’s worse than Lucas
2025-10-31 05:27:56
1
To see more videos from user @fedoramaelle, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.