@hannahglennhannahglenn: This week’s essay is called “I Don’t Want to Rate Jane Austen Out of 5” and it’s on my substack now #writing #substack #videoessay
On Letterboxd there is more of a culture of recognizing that you are rating your viewing of a movie, not objectively rating the movie itself. I see a lot of people log multiple viewings of a movie and give it a different rating each time.
2025-11-15 13:49:02
742
QuasarInTheMist :
4.5/5 great TikTok, great commentary
2025-11-16 13:08:13
842
Nightmare Moonpie 📚📺🎥 :
I do like rating for my own tracking, but 1/5 is NOT nuanced enough at all for me. I hate Goodreads for this reason.
2025-11-14 16:56:06
88
Tsz Hei ꩜ :
I unapologetically give all the movies I like 5/5
2025-12-11 10:31:21
71
Amy 📚☕️✌️ :
This is so true! I think a lot of people forget that ratings can reflect different things, like a book or a movie might be simplistic and not necessarily a high brow piece of work, but a 5⭐️because it was genuinely fun and enjoyable
2025-11-14 21:33:27
103
Natalie Cross | Film & Culture :
Always appreciate your insights! I’m very active on Letterboxd and there are actually plenty of folks who don’t rate! Just log and share their thoughts!
2025-11-14 16:18:09
91
Rhi :
I think it works only if you’re aware everyone has a different way of doing it. I kind of love the collection of ratings being chaotic subjectivity
2025-11-14 21:33:39
48
ilovekhdy :
hmm i agree with your take on rating but i think the review and the replying comments are just as essential as the art itself… i think the issue is the likes attached they incentivize the creation of contrarians, thoughtless reviews, etc
2025-11-15 07:11:14
46
user69 :
One thing that I hate is people rating stuff that wasn’t made for them and not acknowledging it wasn’t intended for them. Before Letterboxd if a movie wasn’t for you, it wasn’t for you but now people will give a 2 star review and feel they’ve soemtbing to say just because they didn’t enjoy a movie that was never trying to appeal to them.
2025-11-16 02:38:35
32
denim_chicken :
sounds like the problem is with certain readers, and not the star rating idea itself
2025-11-15 06:55:28
35
Katrina Kalamar :
I hate giving star reviews. I only do a ❤️now if I truly loved it!
2025-11-14 16:03:56
56
🍒🤭💞🥺☠️✨ :
And then everyone’s a critic😭
2025-11-15 13:06:33
43
cano :
I dont rate anything anymore ever since i realized not even my ratings matched over the years i really find it pointless what is even a 4 star
2025-11-15 11:08:45
8
joyjackettt :
i agree!! stopped rating films altogether at some point, it just felt weird and inaccurate (?) even tho it’s subjective and personal
2025-11-15 09:52:54
24
JK :
I think we are lonely and crave discourse but the crowd anonymity encourages shouting and ironically makes us lonelier. 🤔
2025-11-28 09:14:38
15
tiff :
yeah i cant rate art. i can say what i like or dislike about something but it’s really hard for me to actually quantify art
2025-11-15 15:09:09
6
Charlie 🍉 :
I hate when a rating is responding to other ratings, like people are afraid to like or not like something based on how others have rated it. It is mind numbing and not really responding to the media at that point
2025-11-18 18:09:05
7
Monopoly Phonic :
Its opinions-based
2025-11-26 02:19:33
5
s :
this is why those quirky one line reviews on letterboxd irk me… it feels like an attempt to just get likes on ur reviews instead of interacting with what u just saw 😭
2025-11-15 20:32:44
22
Millennial Wallace Shawn :
Goodreads is bleak but letterboxd is, in many ways, a return to film criticism, to having a relationship with the critics you're reading, in a field that's collapsed and been replaced by rottentomatoes and rando bloggers, on letterboxd, you see what your friends and the critics you follow think. criticism is not new.
2025-11-17 03:29:50
5
Zwabi Thee OverSabi :
This is why Nosedive is the most realistic Black Mirror episode
2025-11-15 19:15:03
11
user8910417703103 :
If you’re watching hundreds of films or books it’s certainly helpful to have some idea of what my impression was through ratings
2025-11-16 03:01:40
6
zav :
i think theres a lot of value in rating as a whole as it essentially asks you to reflect on your feelings on whatever art you just consumed sure there are people who use it for clout and such but i feel like theres still a level of appreciation involved and it’s also more collective than just consuming art without sharing it
2025-11-16 23:03:41
14
chase 🖤⛓️🍒 :
I also think review platforms being turned into social media sites furthers this issue. My story graph account is just for me since I’m a big rereader, I leave long winded comments that talk in depth about what I did and did not enjoy; even getting into technical aspects of the writing. I deliberately don’t read reviews until after I’ve finished a book and written my own. This way my opinion isn’t influenced by other people’s!
2025-11-15 13:12:11
6
ale-marie 📚✨ :
John Green’s essay on this was really eye opening
2025-11-15 12:39:15
5
To see more videos from user @hannahglennhannahglenn, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.