@goodenoughpsychiatrist: The video highlights the hallmark of adolescence: abstract thinking. The 6-year-old in the first clip is in the concrete operational stage. He struggles with ideas or possibilities that cannot be directly observed. The 13-year-old, by contrast, can use hypothetical reasoning and imagine scenarios that can’t happen in real life—hallmarks of Piaget’s formal operational stage. I shared this comparison to show how fundamentally different the worldview of a 6-year-old is from that of a teenager. The world of a 6-year-old is concrete, literal, and rule-bound. They rely on predictable structure and prefer everyone to follow the rules. This is why young children often “police” classmates about fairness, turns, or gender stereotypes. When someone breaks a rule or gets something they don’t, it can feel to them like the whole system has fallen apart. They aren’t being dramatic; they’re simply not yet able to see gray areas, make exceptions, or imagine alternative explanations. A 6-year-old upset about fairness is trying to create order in a world that still feels big and unpredictable. The world of a 13-year-old is abstract, hypothetical, and full of possibility. They can imagine futures, question rules, see shades of gray, and think about thinking. This is why teens debate everything—from curfews to global issues. Their mind is finally capable of abstraction, and they’re taking it out for a test-drive. They’re experimenting with ideas, imagining possibilities, and trying to reconcile contradictions in the world around them. Their questioning and intensity reflect cognitive growth, not defiance. Curiosity-based prompts like “Tell me how you’re seeing this” offer a window into their inner world. Understanding these developmental stages helps us better understand the inner lives of children at different ages. #goodenoughpsychiatrist #MentalHealth #childdevelopment #psychiatry

Goodenoughpsychiatrist
Goodenoughpsychiatrist
Open In TikTok:
Region: US
Friday 05 December 2025 05:26:17 GMT
615594
25587
601
743

Music

Download

Comments

lindseyrheumatoidarthrit
Lindsey Rheumatoid Arthritis :
I’m with the 6yr old lol 🤣
2025-12-05 13:15:46
2616
actualjackie
Jackie B :
"Imagine this rock is a seed" "but it's a rock"
2025-12-05 19:24:32
4742
kamatdqji5f
Endereye :
Do people not understand what hypotheticals are
2025-12-06 23:12:12
1437
yeahpanthers
Yeahpanthers :
This is a test for formal operations vs concrete operations. Elementary age children are concrete thinkers. They are not capable of abstract reasoning. The frontal lobe where abstract reasoning comes from is mot developed yet. Then by middle school, the frontal lobe is finally “turning itself on”. This is why we start to teach more abstract topics like algebra. This is NOT an example of indoctrination
2025-12-05 22:34:00
1282
leilano13
Big Libra :
Everyone in the comments demonstrating that they cannot/refuse to consider any hypothetical situation 😕
2025-12-05 21:31:02
2359
kickflipndip
🤦🤷🤓 :
I always said I didn't think a lot of people who comment on TikToks could do abstract thinking. I was kind of being facetious I did not know it was actually true. I don't know what to do with this information.
2025-12-06 07:50:33
0
kat.buckingham
Kat Buckingham :
as an autistic person this would have me spiraling cus both answers areright
2025-12-05 17:57:26
696
yslorent
loren :
once asked a 5 y/o student “if you were a bug, what would you use to make your home?” and he said “im not a BUG, im a little BOY!!”
2025-12-10 01:33:03
751
secret_fantasy
Fantastic God Bless! :
I wonder if this holds up if they use more descriptive language than “rule”. Like “in magic world, if you hit a glass with a feather, it will break”
2025-12-05 13:03:29
885
sumyallaint_it
alf :
the ppl in these comments can vote… and have/had kids btw …
2025-12-06 08:44:28
75
mosaichex
mosaic :
people in these comments are really feeling like Elmo right now
2025-12-06 01:27:07
289
bobobobobobibib
bobobobobobibib :
Comment section says hypotheticals are the devil
2025-12-06 15:40:54
318
jamesondelascasas
Jamon :
br im thirteen i would respond like the 6 year old
2026-02-02 04:48:45
11
fossilshop
big buzzer :
I can tell which commenters didnt bother to read the caption
2025-12-05 20:23:28
271
thegigglesmcgeek
GigglesMcGeek :
Maybe I am autistic
2025-12-05 14:42:17
83
usernnp25
usernnp25 :
He didn’t agree with the rule in the first place😅
2025-12-05 15:07:16
146
ivanajrome
Jessica.J.Rabbit :
by 14 your brain has developed the ability of abstract thought so you're able to carry out a logical progression there is independent of the reality you live in
2025-12-06 12:13:08
43
pnm0118
. :
It doesnt seem to have been explained well. The kid would know it but he just assumes its a lie.
2025-12-05 18:23:27
109
kligidee
Kligidee :
common sense rule in the 1600's: humans can't fly hypothetical: humans could find a way to fly by considering this hypothetical we now have airplanes.
2025-12-05 22:14:56
91
emerson_eammon_lawrence
David :
The amount of people who don’t understand that this is just an abstract thinking exercise and that the girl is in fact responding in a developmentally appropriate way is concerning.
2025-12-22 21:30:52
54
taylornexus
Taylor Nexus :
I wonder how this would differ with neurodivergent kids at the same ages
2025-12-05 21:34:24
74
tesgon_
Tesgon :
The feather was made of metal and 7 pounds. it was an art installation.
2025-12-05 15:50:31
29
masta.solidus
MaSTA SoLIDUS :
games teach abstract thinking faster. explaining that there is an arbitrary ruleset makes sense when you explain it properly
2025-12-05 15:38:41
21
k.e.z.81
Krista :
Who’s to say the feather isn’t attached to the bird?
2025-12-05 19:53:19
28
dcentioli
The Electric Monk :
My issue is more with the fact that “don hit the glass with a feather” isn’t a “rule” it’s a statement.
2025-12-06 23:30:53
115
To see more videos from user @goodenoughpsychiatrist, please go to the Tikwm homepage.

Other Videos


About