@cusdeb_com: Linus Torvalds explains why he hates the 3rd version of the GNU General Public License. Credit: The reel is based on the video "QA with Linus Torvalds" from DebConf 14. The video is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 International license. License: This carousel is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 International license. #GPLv2 #GPLv3 #LinusTorvalds
Linus throughout his career has preferred the proliferation of the kernel over its actual "freedom." He defended Tivoization, or the process of locking down a Linux-based system with DRM and anti-tamper measures, just because the Tivo used his kernel.
2026-02-07 08:05:59
0
Jim :
GPL 2 was about community, GPL 3 was about communism.
2026-01-09 10:00:58
15
Name :
That attitude is what gave us Android, where the user isn't even allowed to access their own files, let alone modify the system. GPLv3 sadly came too late to prevent that. Source code without the ability to run it is worthless.
2026-01-08 17:45:21
138
i have friends everywhere :
how does he feel about the way redhat/ibm is abusing gpl v2?
2026-01-08 11:55:45
30
Andy😎 :
And that is exactly why less and less open source projects use GPL and switch to a more permissive licence. Open source in my eyes is here to be used, shared and changed by everyone who wants to. The only restriction I like is that end users must be informed that the software they are using or parts of it are open source and where to find the code.
2026-01-08 14:19:44
79
big snake :
you are wrong Linus
completely wrong
2026-10-14 04:45:33
0
nattedweil80 :
I think Linus is wrong here. GPL isn’t about source code. It’s about freedoms. Freedoms for developers, yes, but mainly for USERS. GPLv2 left a hole that could be used to take users’ freedom away (Tivoization) and GPLv3 fixed that hole.
2026-01-09 17:45:25
11
top :
gpl 3 is for hippies that want to ensure it remains open. I don't hate it but I'm not forced to use it either
2026-01-08 19:23:27
6
mitch_travis :
I’ve only used GPLv3 on one project. It was an accessibility program I wrote/won a hackathon for hand free computer use with normal web cams. I wanted people to change it to fit more needs but didn’t want anyone to charge for it
2026-02-01 23:18:52
4
cyfr0n_ :
I think AGPL shpuld be GPLv4??
2026-01-09 18:02:06
0
Szymon :
full gplv2 is impossible with corpos
2026-03-17 20:56:09
0
Absolute Dingus :
v2 makes a ton of sense for a kernel you actively want to avoid getting usurped by big businesses. Less so for something like a library
2026-01-29 21:28:16
1
mistermrhall :
All viral licenses are an horrendous aspect of open source projects. Especially if you’re enterprise. Imagine the number of lawsuits from each webservice when that gplv3 project (with a viral license) gets embedded on a device which spans the planet, and they didn’t follow gplv3 rules 🤣
2026-01-08 19:58:43
3
Ligul :
No more bash on macOS thanks to gpl 3
2026-02-02 13:55:04
2
t :
Torvalds is dull as hell. GPLv2 doesn't require you to give your changes back unless you publish the binaries, which is the entire problem.
2026-02-23 15:03:23
1
Tristan Poland :
The ironic thing is that the intent here was clearly that open source maintainers wanted a way to ensure that their code was open source. But the way that they went about it ensured that under the standard definitions it never truly would be
2026-01-09 05:34:14
6
Zaro :
Yeah, but also no. The world has changed quite a bit since gpl2 was created...
2026-01-08 10:40:27
10
ni :
MIT and BSD all the way
2026-02-05 02:25:01
0
marrowcharger :
pure ideology, that's all.
2026-01-09 23:35:08
0
imamdeenmairi :
👍👍👍
2026-02-10 10:56:41
0
WelfareGloryhole :
❤️
2026-01-08 19:13:14
0
Bryce Manley :
I use the buy me a beer license
2026-01-08 23:38:44
3
brandin :
This is stupidest place imaginable to discuss open source software licensing
2026-01-09 01:18:12
31
Dr Calemvir :
I use MIT everywhere for everything, in my GitHub Bio I have it stated that if I didn't mark a specific license in any of my personal repos, assume MIT.
for things I care about, I use a custom license that I have yet to see something similar, it makes contributors OWN their contributions,
https://git.merith.xyz/packages/license/src/commit/87ac27b02a1c914a75c70c14e1c128e7329c23f6/Draconis/v1.2.md
2026-01-08 14:53:53
16
tmp_tmpst :
yall should ask Elastic how great is a permissive licence when Amazon steals your whole business.
2026-01-08 22:34:09
7
To see more videos from user @cusdeb_com, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.