That could work. I think they would need to cast for the season differently, though. Everyone on the season would have to be down with being a traitor, which i think might actually make a really interesting season.
2026-01-14 03:59:01
244
sthomtaa :
Secret Traitor worked well in the UK season. And yeah it should be random.
2026-01-14 05:52:21
5
🌺🌸Adrian_unofficial 🌸🌺 :
When they brought out the boxes on the first episode I thought each person would select a box then hand it to Alan to open so it would’ve been random but no Alan picked the box then called them up one at a time
2026-01-14 06:28:04
109
ZpaziouzMan :
I completely agree where they one by one go into a secret room to learn their fate as a faithful or a traitor.
2026-01-14 21:08:49
8
🏳️⚧️🐾Luna🐾🏳️⚧️ :
I think I could do without gamers but instead be Maura, Kristen, and Ron
2026-01-14 04:39:36
56
John :
I don't watch but I've gotten a lot of talk about this. I feel like a mix is good. sounds like the two groups are gamers and non-gamers. so you could have three bowls. one bowl is all the gamers. one bowl is all the non-gamers. and then one is everyone combined. this way your guaranteed at least one person who thinks more about the game aspect. but they could still be outvoted when it comes to who to murder
2026-01-16 03:48:26
2
Loganmoo :
I don’t like that they aren’t casting new unknown people like in the other countries. I don’t like the gamers vs the non gamers and everyone kinda knowing each other. It makes it less interesting to me and sometimes meaner with the gamers who have a reputation to uphold.
2026-01-17 13:06:12
8
Kanni :
Season 5 should be random to switch it up
2026-01-14 11:39:09
34
Zachary Reality :
I would love for it to be random!
2026-01-14 22:17:34
18
✿Tia✿ :
In my country it’s randomized. Only the first group tho but ye. I do prefer that bc it’s so random hahaha
2026-01-17 15:22:40
0
iteke 🌟 :
no viewer would ever believe it is really random though
2026-01-15 22:01:21
2
Joe Harrington TV :
Big fan of that idea
2026-01-15 01:11:10
4
Inès :
I think they also pay attention to ratings and who people want to see on their screen the longest
2026-01-14 09:16:24
1
Sarah Pop :
I’d be interested in that
2026-01-14 04:36:41
5
Morgan Lund :
would've loved to see Mark as a traitor
2026-01-25 22:32:57
0
Aydolpanatiko :
that will never happen. producers want good tv. so i really doubt that they will even consider this.
2026-02-01 12:13:05
0
Jesika Petrova :
😂😂😂
2026-01-23 10:10:27
0
Emanuel🍂🧸☕️ :
What I’d give for a witch hunt themed Traitors season
2026-01-14 04:22:51
9
audreyratajack :
They should have the entire cast name on ping-pong balls, and then the three balls that out of a bingo ball selector. Three are drawn they’re original turret and they show them drawing them in the first episode so everything is on the up and up
2026-01-14 04:59:04
5
TJay23 :
Randomizing it amongst those who want to be traitors bc some people know they rather be faithfuls to be successful in the game
2026-01-14 22:07:07
3
evan :
But I feel like I could lead to a bad turret like this season if they did that it could be (Steven, Colton, and Micheal) I think the producers need to choose the less obvious chooses instead that can still handle the pressure, because a random pic could also lead to people becoming traitors who don’t even want to be traitors
2026-01-14 15:44:46
3
VonZuben :
100%. Eliminates the dumb "you would make a good Traitor" line of reasoning and also gets rid of the weird balance the producers try to strike with race, gender, etc. The game should not be about meta-gaming and trying to think like a producer.
2026-02-08 15:21:32
0
Chaz Lepley :
Seats preselected for traitors or they each pick a chest when walking into the roundtable room and must open it infont of everyone (kinda like the secret traitors pick)
2026-01-14 06:05:19
7
Sam :
What if we had a season of no gamers
2026-01-16 00:37:47
1
r :
they need to do it survivor style and draw rocks LOL
2026-01-15 21:23:16
3
To see more videos from user @tessdhiggins, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.