@philosophyminis: Technology was supposed to make our lives less stressful and easier. It was supposed to make things better in almost every way. And yet, for every problem technology solves, it seems to raise three more. This is why the French philosopher Jacques Ellul called it the 'betrayal of technology.' In 1954, Ellul argued that while technology was supposed to liberate us, it has enslaved us not through force, but through necessity. Because while it might solve this or that problem, it also creates three dependencies. For example, the car might have relieved us of the tyranny of distance, but then chained us to traffic, insurance, and oil prices. The smartphone connected us to everyone, then demanded we be always available, and always online. Ellul called this a 'technological society,' it's a world where efficiency is viewed as the highest virtue, and anything that can be optimised should be optimised. And so human rhythms are replaced by mechanical ones. Ellul called this a 'betrayal' because it does so without our consent. Once a technology exists, society reorganises around it. Try banking without the internet. Try getting a job without email. Technology was supposed to offer us freedom, but it gave us a cage. One of invisible obligations and manufactured needs. As Ellul put it, 'modern technology has become a defining force of a new social order in which efficiency is no longer an option, but a necessity.' We didn't adopt technology. Technology adopted us, and now it's raising us in its own image.
Jonny Thomson
Region: GB
Tuesday 10 February 2026 14:57:03 GMT
Music
Download
Comments
hisammy 🇦🇺 :
I remember in the 80s they said personal computers will have us working 4 days a week in the year 2000
2026-02-10 15:31:24
779
Alittis :
Ok, let’s assume there’s no technology. Which 5 of your 10 children would you select to die before reaching puberty?
2026-02-10 19:39:21
33
anatak74 :
Technology has a curve of usefulness vs complexity. Cars are a good example. The first cars were difficult: hand cranking to start. You had to manually pressurize your gasoline tank, maintenance had to be done regularly and they weren’t very fast. Then around the 60’s - 70’s cars became more reliable. Fuel injection, electronic timing, better spark plugs etc. during the 80 - 90’s cars became more or less rust proof and very easy to operate. Then manufactures started to introduce complexity. You could choose between a myriad of options and engines. Around 2015 manufacturers jumped on the car as an income stream: trying to make it impossible to do maintenance yourself and installing confusing software based systems making cars more and more complex. Imo the best cars were made between 1990-2010. Computers (smartphones are included in this) had a similar timeline and now everything has to be online and connected. It doesn’t make the product better but marketing demands it and selling your customers information is a lucrative side business.
2026-02-10 15:51:03
19
Naturnissen Stefan 🌳 :
Literally insane the more you think about it.
2026-02-10 19:10:19
96
Eve :
The technology made our lives easier it the greed of corporations and billionaires is causing the rest of us suffer
2026-02-10 19:21:33
52
herdygerdyDude :
In 1954? My man is complaining about color TVs. Wait till you hear about 4k-3D-gooners
2026-02-10 15:52:27
97
JimCrz 🌍 :
This is because technology is controlled by capital.
2026-02-14 07:54:43
11
Costacus :
All of these problems are completely avoidable. The user is the issue
2026-02-10 16:29:44
17
AMJ :
Excellent post!
2026-02-10 15:01:01
11
País limpio / Clean country :
Grateful for this thoughtful reflection—once technology, especially AI, enters the scene, society reorganizes around it. A short but powerful reminder that adaptation isn’t optional; it’s constant.
2026-04-06 22:17:00
1
ealdfeond :
er... technology was supposed to reduce the cost of labour..
2026-02-12 23:33:16
4
Jordi R Cardona :
This is because people are focused on greed and not in good living
2026-03-09 08:32:09
2
tiktokgodevil :
Im ready to cancel capitalism
2026-04-09 07:21:30
2
Tato Valentine :
so what we can do to prevent this? get a nokia phone again?
2026-03-02 23:10:08
2
_rogwuadi :
This is so real
2026-03-23 15:04:09
2
Foe Hammer :
Civilization in general has had this effect. 💯
2026-02-10 16:12:50
3
N Shackleton-Jones, author :
‘Supposed to’ is doing a lot of work here.
2026-02-13 14:11:47
2
Will Hay Science :
"efficiency isn't an option it's a necessity" like needing two working parents to raise a family
2026-02-10 19:15:41
2
gambleroffate :
You are confusing technology with technocratic social constructs. Technology didn't create those dependencies, we as a society chose to create them and the focus of the conversation should be why we cant solve issues with technology but rather choose to create more with it
2026-02-12 07:16:02
6
V251831 :
nice topic sir
2026-03-19 16:44:25
1
Rye Chu :
you don't have to do this in your personal life btw. once you can afford luxuries of time you can engage in leisure. my parents never understood this so they cannot enjoy free time. meanwhile I'm always stealing free time
2026-02-11 05:48:50
3
Victor :
Isn't that a consequence of competition? Technology could have made our lives easier, but we're forced to utilize technology to maintain an edge. If we don't, we become irrelevant.
2026-02-10 15:52:33
3
φοῖνιξ phoinix :
I did got a job without an email. I lost the job because I was not British enough to fit in. it made the team not very happy to have a single non British team member. I was sacked in public also, so I can taste the humiliation and to remember my place in this God forsaken country. pretty cool right?
2026-02-10 15:19:39
1
Waiiim :
Isn't this exactly what Weber calls the iron cage of rationality
2026-03-02 17:49:08
1
irishbornandbred1 :
There’s nothing new in that—humanity has always been in thrall to one thing or another.
2026-02-10 17:06:10
2
To see more videos from user @philosophyminis, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.