Carnegie Deli is WAYYYY better than Katz imo. They give you giant portions
2026-03-01 16:55:09
33
don__theo :
Katz is not a tourist trap i will die on that hill
2026-02-19 00:29:34
588
rileydeveauu :
Katz’s is a tourist trap AND worth it all the same.
2026-02-19 22:11:20
1618
Robert Lee :
Katz Overpriced and overrated
2026-02-19 10:28:58
137
imouttacrayons :
As a NYer, Gallaghers is legit
2026-02-18 17:05:21
100
Joe Rogan’s micro penis :
$29 for a sandwich tourist trap
2026-03-02 10:43:05
49
Son of a loving mom :
Katz is definitely overpriced but the pickles and pastrami is also the best I’ve ever had. Wouldn’t go there on my lunch break or whatever but would go back every once in a while.
2026-02-19 03:26:22
17
Amy In Ohio :
I worked on a project with Buddy. You should see their offices! There are GIGANTIC FRAMED PHOTOS of him EVERYWHERE!! 😂 Like… EVERYWHERE! His office is deep dark wood and a comically giant desk. It’s so fucking ridiculous 😂
2026-02-19 03:42:19
7
Jane Doe :
1st one HUGE TOURIST TRAP
2026-02-18 19:26:26
44
Chollow :
I was so irritated with Carlos‘s bakery. I used their computer to do my order, and ordered a variety pack of cannolis and lobster tails. Only to be told after I paid that they are out of lobster tails and have been for months. They wouldn’t substitute it for anything but more cannolis. So I ended up with a butt load of cannolis. On his show, he said he was known for the lobster tails, so why would he be out of them for that long? And if you’re out of them, take it off the menu so people don’t pay for it
2026-03-01 15:25:51
7
DaSnake :
That is not the original Carlo's, that is a complete tourist trap. The original is in Hoboken.
2026-02-20 01:24:09
6
Dr. S :
Katz is tourist trap big time, there’s no need for line at 3 pm it’s not lunch or dinner time, it’s a show making the place is busy, the guy making the sandwich keeps talking to the customer if he stop talking and focus on making the sandwich, the lines won’t exist
2026-02-22 01:44:09
6
peteabread00000 :
I don’t love spending money on food and $40 for my meal at Katz felt like a steal.
2026-02-20 03:34:12
7
chevvym43 :
I’d get on a plane right now to go back to Gallaghers.. the food and in particular, the service, was amazing! And next door to a hotel with a rooftop bar.. happy days 👌
2026-02-18 16:45:36
17
Vickyg❤ :
Katz midday or really late at night not packed at all youll have room and enjoy the food. Katz is amazing 🥰
2026-03-13 15:38:45
8
Jo :
Carlos bakery is horrible
2026-02-27 23:39:44
5
A Glutton :
The original is in Hoboken, NJ. the Times Square one is already a tourist trap even before you try the mediocre food.
2026-02-18 23:34:34
0
Charlie Bright :
Gallagher has the BEST onion rings I’ve ever had and their signature steak sauce is absolutely delicious!
2026-02-19 04:57:23
10
user0100011101101111 :
$34 lunch at Gallagher is a great deal
2026-02-19 05:16:19
6
Doublecrutch :
Katz is completely a tourist trap. Uptown delis have way better pastrami sandies.
2026-02-20 19:00:46
7
Coolguy4131 :
I went to famous rays by accident and didn’t even know it was a tourist place. That pizza was awful
2026-02-19 03:54:36
6
nrebarchek :
Katz. Disappointed we didn’t make it there when we were in NY a few years ago.
2026-02-19 23:03:26
5
Donz917 :
Worth the $29 pastrami
2026-02-18 16:54:40
5
LoriGlori :
Delmonico's > Gallaghers
2026-02-18 19:26:40
6
Missmagoozers :
whoa that is NOT what serendipity used to look like. when did they do that??
2026-03-02 01:00:28
2
To see more videos from user @herebebarr, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.