@hackyourhr: Part 6 in my series on how to get promoted this year is about disagreeing productively. If you want to move up, you cannot avoid conflict. A (very) common weakness I see in general is not being able to disagree - we are by nature avoidant of discomfort. You have to learn how to challenge ideas without challenging authority. There’s a Harvard Business Review piece called “How to Disagree with Someone More Powerful Than You” and the core idea is simple: power dynamics change how your message lands. So when your boss makes a call you believe will hurt the business, most people either stay quiet or bluntly say they disagree. Neither of those approaches builds trust. The better approach is more strategic. First, decide if it's worth speaking up. If the risk to the business is bigger than the risk to your ego, you say something. Second, ask permission to engage: “Can I pressure test that with you for a minute?” This language signals that you're on the same side as your boss. And third, frame your point as *curiosity tied to outcomes.* For example "I’m wondering how we’ll protect early retention if onboarding shortens. Do you think we’d see an impact there?” Now you're anchored in shared goals - not in being right. And last point is to strip out judgment language. Stay grounded in data, impact, and the company winning. Leaders are watching how you handle tension. Whether they know it or not, that's what they do. I can attest after being a sounding board for leaders for years. Ok and final thought is that emotional regulation under pressure signals executive maturity. I've always said it's your superpower. The difference between someone who has opinions and someone who gets promoted is how they deliver them. Stick around for Part 7 tomorrow!
Amy Lentz | Hack Your HR
Region: US
Monday 23 February 2026 13:24:10 GMT
Music
Download
Comments
ich :
I'm so glad to have left corporate. Do sick of this bullshit
2026-02-23 14:22:38
685
norman_muc :
done that a lot. got laid off. turns out my company only wants to promote people who fully agree with what the higher ups want without doubting anything. company is going downhill btw 🙃
2026-02-23 18:34:05
236
Plant Mom :
My evaluation rating was threatened after I asked my boss’s boss if they were open to feedback on a slide presented to the team. Don’t actually give feedback. Asked if they were open to feedback. The slide presented was poorly written with grammatical errors with the message to the team being: quality is priority 1. If leadership can’t own their own mistakes, is that not a risk to the business?
2026-02-24 00:20:41
12
lorimaxi3 :
I think a different hair cut could level you up
2026-02-23 18:07:45
15
kloux :
Spark notes version: lead them to a better solution and make it their idea. Gently.
2026-02-24 01:34:06
7
MissFame007 :
What if you suggest something and at the end they take all the credit because it was indeed a good idea ?
2026-02-24 12:41:17
16
SH :
A great thing to bring in during the interview, how they as a boss handle disagreements or a challenge?
2026-02-23 18:18:00
83
Taner :
Are people still trying to get promoted?
2026-02-26 06:22:27
11
Just Jill 🌻 :
Great advice! I struggle immensely with disagreeing. It feels like arguing.
2026-02-23 15:03:43
60
TejB :
HOW we position everything is the diff of being perceived as a problem or partner. Not always but bringing value to THEM/team usually helps and keeps your job (not always)
2026-02-24 22:50:24
5
K.Khadka🎧🪫 :
Naaaaah, I would say just be yourself. If you think something is not right then speak up. If you think it'll actually help the business, customers, and staff then go for it... don't worry about your promotion and all that. Be honest.
2026-03-19 11:02:35
1
Kris Optional :
Great recommendations for good leadership, but I’ve tried this approach and had it back fire. When managers hear you can speak well and are tactful, you instantly identify yourself as a threat. Only use this strategy with people above your manager.
2026-02-25 15:03:26
11
cheryl :
This could be an effective way of disagreeing with anyone, really! Such a good reminder of how to show respect and influence others
2026-02-23 21:31:29
8
Michael 🌙 :
Pressure test. Thought partner. Curiosity. Wondering if we do that if it will impact. Gold!
2026-02-24 02:08:20
58
vi_sg :
dont agree
2026-03-21 19:14:43
1
jocecita93 :
Make me come back pls
2026-04-18 16:41:00
1
Bryan Gaa :
I agree with partnering with them to have a discussion, but I don’t believe in asking for permission. Just a thought.
2026-04-03 19:34:08
1
nyc223 :
Love Rhys
2026-02-23 20:14:25
0
Kaysway :
Spot on! 👏
2026-02-24 20:58:34
2
✨Melissa Moments✨ :
Perfectly put! 👌🏾
2026-02-23 18:09:58
1
RG :
There’s no script. Stop being prescriptive. Everyone’s path is different and everyone has different flaws to work through.
2026-02-26 00:55:57
2
Z :
just listening to this already makes me feel so tireddddd
2026-02-24 13:13:03
3
Λ П T Ө П :
I saw a few tiktoks where they said it helps if you talk to your boss like one would do with children. And I agree, it has helped me greatly to speak with my colleagues and my boss like I used to talk to "my children" in the day care center of an elementary school! 💁🏻♂️😂
2026-02-24 06:12:39
3
Cobrapotato :
it's ok I just change company's every year instead
2026-04-14 18:27:10
1
Fay 🇱🇧 :
The curiosity is key
2026-02-25 04:29:16
1
To see more videos from user @hackyourhr, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.