@sarahelizabeth_talks: Replying to @Katja like Carlisle’s only hesitation about Jasper and Alice was about their marital status and that’s concerning #twilight #twilightsaga #bellaswan #edwardcullen #BookTok
Carlisle can tolerate Confederacy but divorce is where he draws the line
2026-04-09 03:07:37
3063
The_HR_Department :
How did all the boys avoid the various military drafts
2026-04-09 17:14:21
288
Circe_Witch_Of_Aiaia :
I like to imagine Stephanie Meyer watches your videos and is shaken to her core by your headcanons 😭
2026-04-08 20:43:33
1122
LaurieNotSorry :
Alice and Jasper were Volturi spies.
2026-04-08 17:48:16
671
imafanofeverything :
I have had this question for a really long time. How come in breaking dawn part 1, Alice can show Aro her vision of them defeating the voulturi, even though wolves are involved in the fight? In the books, like in New Moon, Alice says she couldn’t see Bella get saved from the water while cliff jumping because it was Jacob (a wearwolf) that saved her, and that she can’t see wolves in her visions. Did Stephanie Meyer just let the movie producers go against her rules?
2026-04-08 17:37:28
249
🍉Charlie🍉 :
wait.. is there legal vampire marriage? do they send a marriage certificate to the volturi?
2026-04-09 19:35:35
185
Oath of Care :
sometimes I like the idea that in another universe, there is a mlm twilight book of Carlisle and Edward like Stephanie clearly wanted
2026-04-08 22:55:47
64
PC :
At Carlisle’s “suggestion”
2026-04-09 01:13:24
44
Dobby_the_tortoise :
I don't think it's quite that simple.
For one, Carlisle was the son of an Anglican pastor. Divorce is practically the foundation of that particular brand of faith. While Carlisle didn't agree with his father's approach to life, all we know about his faith is that he believes in God, souls, heaven and hell. That's not a whole lot of info and applies to countless people who are not particularly religious and get divorced plenty.
His "suggestion" that Alice and Jasper get married, as controlling as it sounds, is on brand for the 1950s. Living together unmarried is a relatively newly accepted concept.
While Carlisle follows his own moral code, he does not act particularly Christian. Going around playing God changing people into vampires, covering up murders, drugging defenceless humans etc etc are not the actions of someone guided by faith.
Carlisle is hands down my favourite character in the saga, but this image of him as a religious goody two shoes is inconsistent with his actions. He has a lot of good values but is also very shady.
2026-07-24 19:20:52
0
HOEkagay :
Do you think they have vampire marriage therapy?
2026-04-08 17:38:29
22
lajadabjd :
Its upsetting because Carlisle should’ve been 23 in the tavern but he was a preacher’s son who couldn’t mind his own business
2026-04-08 22:15:19
97
Whatever :
I have an unrelated question. If Alice and Jasper joined the Cullens at the same time, why has Jasper been "vegetarian" for less time than Alice ?
2026-04-16 11:30:52
6
madison_taylor :
Alice seems to always see multiple futures depending on choices being made, so when she woke up as a vampire did she like go through a mental file folder of futures and think "yep, the Cullens and the confederate soldier is my best option"? 😂
2026-04-09 01:51:19
74
horatio hornblower :
carlisle is the true villain
2026-04-11 16:26:35
6
🐈💁🏾♀️✊🏾🫶🏾 🪮 :
I feel like everyone eventually figures out that Edward can read their minds so they all just developed shields that he doesn’t know about. One day Alice brings it up to Bella. “Yeah, I knew you would eventually be revealed to have a shield so I just learned how to make one and taught everyone else. Edward was too busy brooding to notice.”
2026-04-09 00:34:57
15
Cece.K :
What do you think happens to them to separate
2026-04-09 19:59:44
8
Jana 🔥🗑️ :
But also, how would you legally divorce as a vampire? Bc you’d have to explain the age discrepancies when you file for divorce lol
2026-05-10 23:43:08
8
🇨🇦KllarkAshwood🇨🇦 :
its so funny because they cant even get divorced legally. they dont exist legally.
2026-04-12 01:13:32
59
actual.puppy :
Based on who we believe Carlisle is inspired by, he's more likely to make them have multiple wives and not divorce any of them.
2026-05-12 17:53:05
9
🌻TheHufflepuffHobbit🌻 :
Carlisle "you are dating your soul if you get a divorce!!"
Edward "🤨we're vampires.....I think we are well past that"
2026-04-10 21:46:39
9
staciesfault :
Jasper - We’re engaged? Alice- Surprised? Good we’d hoped you’d be
2026-04-13 16:16:29
7
Capri Campeau :
Unequivocally!!! 😂😂
2026-04-08 23:41:17
6
Sywar B'a 🪬 :
It's a MUST to take casual "breaks" from eachother tbh imagine being immortal and 500 years old and still living EVERYDAY with the same person? Nightmare
2026-04-15 10:14:02
5
Tiffanie :
Sarah did you see the vouge interview where Robert Pattinson said he loves twilight and it's very serious 😂
2026-04-09 17:01:44
10
chaoticlymedicated :
This is fun to think about but I truly don’t think it’s realistic because how bad Bella fell for Edward in the first place 😅
2026-04-09 01:08:08
5
To see more videos from user @sarahelizabeth_talks, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.