Powerlifter - Nathan Kulas :
actually have some screenshots or recordings of a video Keenan made on this topic a while back, because I fully intended to challenge his assertion (based partly on semantics of defining surplus vs maintenance, but also under the belief that a surplus was necessary to maximize growth). However, in researching the topic I came to the conclusion that given that we define maintenance as the state in which all energy demands are met (including the minuscule energy demands (~50kcal/day or less in trained lifters) of increased MyOPS), we have no evidence to suggest that a surplus is strictly necessary, but that instead a very slight surplus may still be merited as an insurance policy against being accidentally in a deficit (it is very hard to exactly hit your exact TDEE).
That said, I think there is one thing you may have missed.
Helms 2023 - They actually found a minor difference in biceps muscles in the higher surplus group, and the biceps muscles were also the muscle group that received the highest volume dosages; suggesting that given training volumes are sufficently low, a surplus may have very little merit, but given that you are doing sufficient volume there may be merit in higher surpluses. Alternative interpretations might be that the biceps are a special condition (doubt), or that a more gratuitous surplus may lead to enhanced recovery (plausible). The effect size here was VERY modest though, but it was still sizable enough to be worth noting. In either case, it seems implausible that a net energy surplus directly contributes to increased MyOPS; but the opposite may not be true (i.e. energy deficit does attenuate MyOPS, which you covered).
2026-04-27 20:39:06