@calmmoneycoach: A viewer left a comment that felt like checkmate. $700K home up 3% = $21,000. TFSA at 7% = $9,100. Homeowner wins, end of debate. The math skips fifteen lines. In this video I run those exact numbers in Ontario. $700K home, 20% down, 4.29% mortgage, 25-year amortization. Year 1 unrecoverable carrying costs come out to $38K, already $17K underwater on cash before any comparison. Same starting cash invested at 7%? Renter ahead by $27K in Year 1. With the home up 3%. Then three reasons the leverage argument feels stronger than it actually is: 1. Leverage and equity move in opposite directions. As you build wealth in the home, you erase the leverage that justified buying it. Day 1 you have 5x leverage. Year 10 you have 2.4x. 2. Leverage works both ways. A 15% drop wipes out the down payment after round-trip costs. Toronto is currently down 9.5% YoY (Teranet, March 2026). The 1989 Toronto cycle took 13 years to recover nominally and 22 years to recover in real terms. 3. The kind of leverage matters. A traced margin loan or a properly structured Smith Manoeuvre is deductible under ITA section 20(1)(c). Mortgage interest on a Canadian principal residence is not. Canada is not the US. Honest version: at 5% appreciation the gap shrinks to $13K. At about 7% appreciation, the owner catches up. The leverage edge isn't fake. It's just contingent on the home outpacing what your portfolio would have done, after the carrying costs eat the first chunk. 📊 Want the multi-city Excel companion covering Vancouver, Toronto, Calgary, Montreal, and Halifax? It's free in the Calm Money Community. 🔗 Calm Money Community: [link] 📚 Sources Income Tax Act of Canada, s.20(1)(c) CRA Income Tax Folio S3-F6-C1 Dimson, Marsh, Staunton — UBS Global Investment Returns Yearbook 2025 Knoll, Schularick, Steger — "No Price Like Home," American Economic Review 2017 Teranet-National Bank House Price Index, March 2026 release ⚠️ Education, not personalized financial advice. Run your own numbers or work with a fee-only planner before making decisions of this size. #PersonalFinanceCanada #RentVsBuy #CanadianMortgage #SmithManoeuvre #FinancialPlanning
Brian | Calm Money Coach
Region: CA
Friday 01 May 2026 19:55:26 GMT
Music
Download
Comments
CrazySingh :
I did the math. I live in Oakville. To buy the house I live in costs $1m. 20% DP leave me with an $800k mortgage. Mortgage payment is about $5k a month property tax is $700 and insurance is $300. So total fixed cost is $6k no maintenance or emergency expenses. I rent the same home for $3k a month. Home was built before Nov 2018 so it is under rent control. All those funds and the monthly difference is in the stock market. To diversify I started buying up RE outside Ont. High cashflow adding those funds in the stock market. Meanwhile my rent went up by $65 this year. You don’t need to own your PR to become wealthy.
2026-05-03 00:45:59
24
Brent 🇨🇦 :
also, the only way to enjoy real estate gains is selling or leveraging. buying a home is a good hedge against inflation, but don't lose the plot and put so much into the home you can't put money in the stock market and stay diversified, you can't eat a home remember
2026-05-01 20:04:07
12
Foundations of Finance :
Well said Brian! The costs add up fast. Make sure you can actually afford the home. You do not want to be house poor
2026-05-24 21:09:00
2
J :
Great analysis.
2026-05-05 02:18:36
1
Ben Ja Min :
If a $3,000 mortgage payment consists of $2,000 in interest and $1,000 in principal, only that $1,000 actually builds wealth.
A fair 'rent versus buy' analysis should isolate these wealth-building components. It must compare the capital actively allocated to homeownership alongside property taxes and maintenance, against the potential yield of renting and investing that equivalent capital into equities.✌️
2026-05-23 00:33:09
0
billsrussel :
Can you talk more about leveraging stocks for investments and maybe throw some suggestions of funds 🙏🏼
2026-05-02 23:19:03
1
Mike Deeps :
The one thing about owning bs renting is after 25 years you can own your home so let’s say you finally pay it off at 55-60 years old then you don’t have a mortgage payment after 60 years old..if renting you continue to pay rent until you die..so another 20 plus years of $2000 rent every month..
2026-05-18 12:54:04
0
Proka$h🇨🇦 :
your theory assumes that someone is renting a similar place to the renter at a loss.
2026-05-02 13:31:57
1
FrogBurnz :
A renter with no car payments is cruising through life.
2026-06-29 02:36:59
1
EM :
Whoops I cannot type. Great content, your estates analysis is bang on
2026-05-01 23:47:20
1
Eliane Bejjani | REALTOR® :
Great content your real estate analysis is great
2026-05-03 17:55:39
1
Xray :
Hey Brian, could you explain this line more ? “building wealth in the home destroys the leverage that justified buying” I dont quite get this, and it seems p important. TIA!
2026-05-01 23:24:15
1
Shazad 🇨🇦 :
How to buy bonds as an individual?
2026-05-02 03:07:05
1
bobwk25 🇺🇦🇨🇦 :
I'm in Montreal. Nobody rents investment property for less than the carrying costs. I bought a condo 20 years ago for, just about what I was paying for rent for a similar sized apartment. Today, I’m paying $600 every 2 weeks which includes property taxes. Rentals in my building are around $2400/month.
2026-06-22 20:46:28
1
Sahib Gaba :
Does this analysis include the inflation of rent, over the same time period of the mortgage?
2026-05-08 21:09:02
0
Memes-R-us :
Keep in mind 7% is conservative.
2026-05-10 14:59:45
4
EM :
Land transfer tax is $21000 on a $700,000 in Toronto- Toronto charges a municipal land transfer tax that doubles the usual tax. All us non city people
2026-05-01 23:46:19
1
Dylan :
Homes in Canada have depreciated over the last 4 years
2026-06-29 05:24:52
0
potato :
7%? Really? This is where your argument falls apart.
2026-05-02 00:12:51
1
mommabrotrades :
Here’s something Brian I learned a lot of people believe they to good to go for the realistic starter home. Husband and me in Ajax (young family and newly wed) 15 years ago bought a hoarders house at 231000 and in 2019 we sold it for 474000. We learned the people and not everyone who go for “their dream home” most of them can barely afford it or are house poor. We took the steps and realistic ones to get out current dream home.
2026-05-22 21:49:51
0
Shazad 🇨🇦 :
👍👍👍
2026-05-02 03:03:03
1
Joaquin :
🥵🥵🥵
2026-05-18 00:35:24
0
To see more videos from user @calmmoneycoach, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.