@_pollka: I KNOW arthur didn't exist in the time rdr1 was made, but logically he did considering rdr1 happens after rdr2. This is more of a headcanon than a theory #arthurmorgan #reddeadredemption2 #dutchvanderlinde #viral #viralvideos

Nugget :

The second theory is that dutch tought down there was a river like rdr2

NULLS!!!(__--__) :

if they make a remake with a slightly different story where Arthur existed that would be terrifying bro

hazelty :

we need an rdr1 remaster

Zoey 🖤 :

I hate when people say Arthur wasn't in the script in rdr1. Like I KNOW, just let a girl dream man, damn 😭 It's nice to think that Dutch and John remembered him (even if he didn't exist yet)

Heisenberg :

What if gavin was the strange man

Kade. 🇨🇦 :

I like to think he either saw Arthur or Hosea, two people he couldn't save, two people he was close with, two people he couldn't save

miki 🦋 :

i love how they reference it again in rdr2 tho cus i did the mission and was like.. hold on

jc :

i thought he was shirtless this whole time

IvÆÑ :

now imagine if they added a wolf , without saying nothing , just him seeing a wolf walking past him and he doesn't attack , he just looks at him from top of that mountain and walks away

✦𝐓𝐡𝐞𝐲𝐄𝐧𝐯𝐲𝐃𝐨𝐧✦ :

I wish they could re make this game so then they could add references to Arthur.

Hunter Emann :

Redhoodsen :

Imagine you just see Arthur there in the shadows quietly staring at Dutch

Rey Heredia :

The Ghost of the West was present 🔥

Carter😶‍🌫️ :

him and Arthur jumped off that cliff into the water. rmb that yall. there where very simular voice lines in there ad well.

Elijah🏎️💨 :

Since rdr2 is before the first one I’d like the imagine this theory is real because obviously Arthur wasn’t in the first game

Cristian :

Dutch in rdr1 just scares me in general

Alt f4 :

me parece más probable que haya pensando más en la banda en general y no solo en Arthur en concreto

Vescovo Alfonso :

callingcaspian :

They’re gonna remaster rdr1 and during this scene istg they’re gonna do an outline or shadow behind John to symbolize Arthur

Mlody_repcqk :

Arthur said if he die he be blue bird watching in Rdr 2 IF you building House as John the same bird is siting NEXT to you

R🍥 :

If you notice, Dutch was looking at the ground more than he was looking at John at these moments, and I think this theory is true.

ja2o9 :

Not just Arthur but the entire band supposedly

BEAGS59 :