@radfemma2: Replying to @☁️ ( =^ω^ ) 🪽 i love how everyone all of a sudden knows gender dysphoria is a mental illness! normally they kick and whine and insist it’s not😭working in childcare is a lot like talking to TRAs online. the constant switching up keeps you on your toes! since we’re acknowledging gender dysphoria IS a mental illness, and sex and gender are 2 different things, let’s stop allowing males to violate women’s SEX based rights & protections based on their GENDER identity🫣☺️☺️☺️☺️ #radicalfeminism #womensrightsarehumanrights #genderabolitionist #6B #merf

Pico :

💛♡Lotti i książki📚💛 :

you can not pick and choos what women you acept into your feminism, you are not a feminist if you are rasist, or if you are ableist, same goes for trans people - if you are a terf you are not a feminist

johnjasper :

Attempts to mischaracterize this study as not being a clear warning about the ineffectiveness of “trans care” are laughable and lamentable. The Finland, Swedish, and U.K studies have slowed European trans hobbyists to a crawl and is finally protecting children. Here is a round up of the research and concerns: https://segm.org/German-guidelines-gender-dysphoria-youth-2025

hughyr :

Ah yes Finland, the country known for its treatment of trans people! One of the authors of that study is also associated with a anti-trans lobby group advocating for banning trans healthcare in the U.S. That study is not good, I'm sorry.

radfem! ava :

i love you girlie

Pirate gurl :

Oooo I like you!

GoldStar⭐️ :

Thank you so much for your work 🙏🏿

ThePest_xx :

Can I see your necklace pls

gioia ⋆౨ৎ˚⟡˖ ࣪ :

Gender affirming care actually saved my life

🄹eI :

oppressed people (that includes POC's, workers, women, queer folks) need to stand together to get somewhere. Putting down other people who are also systematically discriminated on through the patriarchy is not going to help women get any further.

kittycatlover_22 :

Hi where can I find the study?

💚🍀 :

Hey, I’m really interested in that study (and I totally agree w you) but I’m not sure where to find it? “Pinned to my profile”? I live under a rock. If anyone knows where it is that would help, thanks.

MSS :

The trans agenda reinforces the Patriarchal structure. So I'm not for it. End of.

rose♀ :

also, there's no comprehensive study to show gender dysphoria increases su1cde rates. The only research done IS ONLINE SURVEYS which are completely unreliable

Matthew King :

I've read through this study now, out of curiosity. It doesn't claim what you're implying it does (which I already knew would be the case), but I disagree with other critics who are saying this was a poorly done study-- it wasn't. Was actually incredibly interesting to read. The only issue is that it wasn't measuring whether or not gender affirming care "worked," it was measuring whether or not a cohort of *incredibly high needs psychiatric patients* who presented to the gender clinic still had *the same level of high needs psychiatric care* after reassignment, and turns out a lot of them (67%) still had very high psychiatric needs compared to the general cohort. It absolutely does not say anywhere that it *worsens* their mental health.

LOWTIERGOD'S DISCIPLE :

since everyone loves arguing about "muh treatment of trans people" then please explain how a study in Canada that also measured social support still found high rates of SI in transgender individuals who experienced little to no alienation

OfficialClaneFaith :

The study you qoute does not say that Gender affirming care is unnecessary. what it says is that even after gender affirming care mental health issues continue and can even worsen, it never explicitly says that this care is responsible or unnecessary. the only real conclusion drawn from this study is that the amount of treatment before gender affirming care should be increased. this study also does not take social factors into account. many trans individuals face major social consequences after transitioning, especially for pre-adolescents, which can worse mental condition causing an increase in mental morbidity. stop misqouting research it never says these individuals dont need gender affirming care

isabel :

but why would it matter if both trans and menopausal women are taking the same meds??

Goddesskali :

Why are you so obsessed with Trans people?

. :

You're misrepresenting the study. HRT in itself doesn't worsen mental health, but the culture and society around the individual is what causes mental health issues. Because when trans people transition, the culture hates them for it and ostracizes them.

angel313 :

genuinely why do u even care sm. have u ever actually talked to trans ppl irl?

𝙂𝙧𝙖𝙘𝙚 ♡ :

You are massively overstating what that Finnish study shows. It did not directly measure whether depression, suicidality, dysphoria, anxiety, or quality of life improved after treatment, like other studies. It used recorded specialist psychiatric contact/diagnosis as a proxy for “psychiatric morbidity”, which is a crude measure when gender clinic patients are monitored far more closely than the general population. The study mostly compares gender clinic patients to population controls, rather than treated trans youth to comparable untreated trans youth. That can show that referred youth have complex psychiatric needs, but it cannot prove that gender affirming care worsens mental health / has no benefit. More monitoring also means more chances for psychiatric diagnoses / referrals to be recorded. At most, the “damning” conclusion is that many young people referred to Finnish gender clinics had complex psychiatric needs before referral, and those needs often persisted afterwards. This is careful assessment and followup. It does not support saying trans people have “no medical need” for treatment. The wider evidence also does not support your claim. Doyle et al. 2023 reviewed 46 studies and found gender affirming hormone therapy was consistently associated with reduced depressive symptoms and psychological distress. Baker et al. 2021 reviewed 20 studies and found hormone therapy was associated with improved quality of life and reduced depression and anxiety, while acknowledging limitations in evidence quality (something you ignore when presenting this Finnish study as definitive). Prospective youth evidence, such as Chen et al. 2023, also found improvements in appearance congruence, positive affect and life satisfaction after gender affirming hormone treatment. So no, the evidence does not show that gender affirming care is useless, harmful, or taken “for fun.” A more honest summary is that clinically referred trans youth often have complex mental health needs, and care should include proper assessment and followup. But the broader evidence shows hormone therapy being associated with improved quality of life and reduced depression / distress.

Niaz :

I did my thesis on GAHT at the center of expertise on Gender Dysphoria in Amsterdam and went through so many studies. You’re sharing false information, GAHT does in fact improve quality of life.

Yeon Si-eun 🖊 :

Well, it's not roleplaying, firstly? And if you'd actually take the time to talk to some trans people, i think you'd realize it quite actually does help people. Also, it is medically necessary, as Gender dysphoria is a disorder that needs to be treated just like any. Hormones are the therapy. Gender dysphoria is quite literally in the DSM-5 and nothing people just decide to do. I'm not trying to hate, i just think there's two sides to this topic

:3 :

hrt is very likely to cause reproductive cancers, it will not change ur sex.