@hormonespecialist: Mars is gene-editing cacao trees in California. The pollen carrying the proprietary DNA will reach West Africa. So who now owns the cacao tree? Under existing patent law, the smallholder farmer whose trees get cross-pollinated by engineered pollen could lose ownership of the next generation of his own trees. The U.S. and Canadian Supreme Courts have both ruled that ownership of a plant is no defense against a patent on its genes. Cacao is self-incompatible and depends on cross-pollination. There is no biological defense against engineered pollen drifting in from a neighboring plantation. Mars has been running a CRISPR cacao program at UC Berkeley since 2018. Across eight years of press releases, university announcements, and trade coverage, I cannot find a single public statement about how the engineered cacao trees will be prevented from cross-pollinating their neighbors. And beyond. Eight years. No containment disclosed. The technology to build the fence into the seed has existed for thirty years. A 2023 review in the journal Plants catalogs the options. The Berkeley-Mars team has not used any of it. If you own the gene, you own the fence. Or don't plant it. Sources in the show notes. Tag a chocolate company in the comments and ask them where their cacao comes from. This is Part 4 of 4 in a series.
Why can't Mars be sued for contamination of other farmers crop
2026-05-24 15:49:00
405
mine🦩 :
the US supreme court has no jurisdiction on the whole world
2026-05-24 06:27:49
186
Mike Ramsay 🇨🇦 :
This is what Monsant lawyers successfully sued for on their GMO corn and wheat.
2026-06-23 19:45:24
1
TraceyBionicWoman :
This whole thing sickens me!
2026-05-24 02:34:41
204
country___bumpkin :
Didn’t Monsanto sue a farmer for this same thing?
2026-06-05 03:01:17
18
Indigos0n :
Capitalism. This is just capitalism.
2026-05-24 03:34:56
69
The Names Liam :
Fine work on this series, genuinely one of the more careful treatments of this topic I've come across. Something I found while reading around after watching: Mars apparently led a consortium in 2008-2010 to sequence the full cacao genome and put it into the public domain, explicitly blocking patents so breeders anywhere could use it freely. On the courts point.. the Schmeiser precedent does establish that a gene patent can legally override a farmer's ownership of the physical plant, but from I found no court has actually ruled that Mars owns anyone's trees yet. That legal framework existing unused may be the more unsettling version of the story. And the potential for lack of foresight around the current CRISPR situation is quite worrying. It doesn't resolve anything, but it does suggest the relationship between Mars and cacao IP isn't straightforward. Something seems to have changed in how they're approaching it. The smallholder dimension is what stays with me. A tree that takes a decade to mature, farmed by people on subsistence incomes, in countries where the regulatory framework either exempts this or isn't enforced. The timeline for noticing a problem, let alone remedying it, has staggering implications.
2026-05-26 13:59:08
12
Married Missouri Man :
kind of sounds like our corn crop in America
2026-05-24 23:10:36
24
Joe Baker :
This happened with corn and soybeans long ago, right here in North America. 😔
2026-05-24 05:16:37
52
Kat 🦋 :
Saw a video today about the farmers hardly being able to sell their cacao because of the lab cocoa thing, if I'm not mistaken. there's no lack in real cocoa.
2026-05-24 02:41:54
26
Oge🧚🏾 :
I hate capitalism so much
2026-05-25 04:09:41
20
JasonGP :
Find a firm to counter sue pro Bono for Billions in damages, take them to an international court with common sense, firm earns potentially world record case, farmers earn and sensibility precedent is set.
2026-06-06 12:26:19
11
bg_styles :
this is deliberate
2026-05-24 06:19:42
37
Ryza_Altair :
I call it American style capitalism.
2026-05-24 17:42:15
12
🇵🇱❤️🇵🇸 :
Isn’t that the exact same strategy Monsanto used with corn? 🌽
2026-05-26 08:09:25
8
alfie_guy_tiktok :
International law won't accept patent infringement across borders with natural biological plant growth.
2026-05-25 05:13:28
6
slarm :
AGAIN WITH THE COCOA?!?!?
2026-05-24 01:52:43
7
Common sense (。♡‿♡。) :
Awful. So wrong
2026-05-24 03:48:10
5
honeybadgerbae :
Could the farmer get ahead of it and sue Mars for contaminating their crop?
2026-06-11 11:07:04
3
Memphis the farm dog :
So what can be done??? And is there a chocolate option that doesn’t do this?
2026-06-03 17:46:35
3
kamaukings :
Thanks for highlighting this 🙏🏾
2026-06-06 07:22:59
4
fetB :
man, i love snickers
2026-05-29 20:42:36
0
Laylu :
WTH am I watching? Can someone please tell me this is unreal?!
2026-06-11 13:56:13
1
Vinley336 :
FFS
2026-06-08 00:49:05
1
To see more videos from user @hormonespecialist, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.