@sigma.overwatch: Five Nights At Freddy's first victim was NOT The Puppet #fivenightsatfreddys

Edd :

no disrespect to matpat, but I hate how basically everyone took his theories as absolute and never questioned it... he literally says "but that's just a theory, a GAME THEORY" at the end of every video 😭

Nick :

did you HAVE to use that art of chica

Gavin :

huh? yall didn’t know chica was the first?? 🤦‍♂️

Sean "cheese" :

PIZZA564738 :

chica's spirit "i was the first".... nah it has to be the puppet first

🌸Bootz🌸 :

Crop the chica image??

ChilledWolf :

so wait, The first 4 with Chica being first, golden Freddy and then puppet ? then puppet gives life to them ?

brinq42 :

FNAF lore is easily solve able if u understand that there’s no lore, Scott doesn’t have any structured story and he can turn the story at any given time, doesn’t matter if it makes sense, cause Scott often forgets what he made

создатель школьных форм :

yes yes fnaf or sum

Daniel Rug :

It is weird how chica quite literally says shes the first but people just denied it like they just said it dude theres your answer

⠀ :

After Mat Pat stopped retelling the lore after every new addition is when the community could no longer figure out the lore

just natsuki :

he quit because he realised he made too many plot holes and couldn't solve the story himself even if he wanted to

Jay Royale :

it's the giving gifts mini game. it was a straight fuck-up that set this misconception, cause this was a retcon that people didn't accept but that's the problem we have to accept Scott didn't know how to drag out a story that he didn't plan too well

Eli :

chica was always first.

xEvo SpiRiT :

i mean now a day its True that Puppet wasn't first but it didn't "Came from Nowhere" The Fnaf 2 Minigames Clearly show that Puppet Gave life to the Animatronic and was kind of their Leader but yeah the Community still doesn't understand that if Information from Newer Game contradict older Info then we only use the new one

Kade :

Mr. Turner :

honestly what if we are all wrong about everything and the movie is what Scott originally wanted the story to be

Genesis-x :

Hold up what was that picture

лекс 18+ :

And stuff like this is why I won't take "it's not lore accurate" as a critique of the movies, there is no lore accuracy just a mishmash of theories built on theories

jerzy kasprzyk :

any idea seems valid if you ignore the counterpoints

Konnor :

To be fair, it’s not our fault when Scott said MatPat’s FNaF 2 theory was nearly 100% correct. In that video, we know he was wrong about Afton being the phone guy by 3 or 4, so by Scott’s words we had good reasoning to believe the rest of what was put in that video was right. Aka, the puppet was the first. Then again, we now know there was one retcon prior to Custom Night. This being considered with the Puppet’s gender randomly changing, could have been a hint to rethink what we know about the Puppet which is then why Scott started hammering hard on the Puppet being last since he soft confirmed the Puppet as first.

chrispy4370 :

This falls apart the moment you consider the "give gifts give life" minigame.

inx_jxy :

So what i’m hearing is that before charlotte possessed the puppet, Freddy and them were just sitting idle until the puppet woke em up?

dex_save1949 :

You’re forgetting GIVE GIFTS GIVE LIFE, HOW DID THE ANIMATRONICS GET POSSESSED BEFORE THAT