Jaco VDM :
The conversation feels familiar, and that’s exactly the point—it is familiar, but not in the sense that it is “the same as something else.” It is not a new issue, and in South Africa this has been raised by citizens since the early 2000s, long before figures like Elon Musk or current global discourse had any influence on it.
What you are doing is comparing things that may sound familiar on the surface but are not actually the same. The concern being raised is something many of us have already warned about when we, as citizens, raised immigration issues with government. At the time, those concerns were often dismissed or downplayed, as if they were unfounded. But they were not.
Because you had no prior knowledge of it before it grabbed your attention does not make it new. In fact, if you are going to analyse it, then it should be done thoroughly—by looking at where it originates, when it originated, why it emerged, and what the specific South African context is before bringing in algorithms, Elon Musk, or global conversations that postdate the issue entirely.
This is not simply part of a global conversation. Framing it that way risks diminishing lived experiences and echoing the same dismissive attitude we have often faced from authorities. These concerns are longstanding, rooted in real conditions, and shaped by the daily experiences of vulnerable people who deal with these realities every day.
The issue deserves to be understood in its own context, not blended with unrelated comparisons.
2026-06-18 10:00:02