>:) :
I interpret Blackbeard’s introduction very differently. I think that when you focus on Luffy’s reactions to what Blackbeard is saying, his thoughts come off almost the opposite direction. Luffy isn’t smiling or laughing like you would imagine he would if he met someone with such similar values, he’s almost fearfully looking at Blackbeard and watching him closely like he doesn’t trust how he could act in the next few seconds. He doesn’t even turn away from Blackbeard until Nami and Zoro are safely away from him. I believe that the reason for this mistrust is Luffy’s subconscious picking up on tiny little issues with what Blackbeard is saying that tell Luffy what he is saying is an act or show. He’s getting an uncanny valley response from Blackbeard, he appears similar to the legendary pirates he met in Shanks’ crew, and in the scene, Luffy’s thoughts shift to Shanks, but something is off. Blackbeard is the first person Luffy has encountered who openly preaches these ideals of piracy, upholding dreams against the mockery of others. This was an unspoken philosophy to the other great pirates he’s known, but Blackbeard yells it to all in the middle of the street. His famous declaration that “Peoples’ dreams will never end”, doesn’t sit right with Luffy either. When Chopper finally cures all diseases, he has achieved his dream. When Sanji discovers the All Blue, he has achieved his dream. When Zoro surpasses Mihawk, he has achieved his dream. Luffy knows fully well that dreams do have an end, but he understands the effect that Blackbeard’s speech would have on someone without his innate understanding of and respect for dreams. I believe that this is where Luffy and Zoro are able to intuit that the strange men they had encountered in town already were Blackbeard’s crew (yes the original translation implies directly that Zoro is talking about a crew, not the twin soul theory). Blackbeard was in recruitment mode, trying to inspire these three pirates with strong wills to his allegiance. The biggest thematic element to Blackbeard is that a man who never sleeps couldn’t possibly understand what it means to dream.
2026-06-21 15:26:07