Nigerian Marxist
Region: ZA
Friday 19 June 2026 17:31:03 GMT
16363
2201
148
84
Music
Download
Comments
Bolognio :
I feel like I agree with you on everything except your conclusion. I don’t think the state “restricting” capital is the same as them controlling capital, and likewise just cuz China is not at the end goal of eliminating commodity production and capital as a whole , dosent mean they aren’t socialist. I would need to see proof that China CC has no interest in developing away from capital and further weakening the influence of capital
2026-06-21 12:01:09
13
Mayovoni :
Can a state control cmc ?
2026-06-19 17:40:35
4
tylertheeraser161☭ :
Im not a high enough level of communist to understand ts🥹
2026-06-19 21:10:38
98
☭ Lotte ☭ :
Man I cannot wait to actually catch up on theory with yall.. I love hearing all the perspectives from different variations though. I just wish there was more healthy debate than infighting/just name calling lol
2026-08-15 14:44:05
3
Rodolfo Santos :
capital is dead labor
2026-06-20 17:28:37
3
pinkwolf 🦠 :
Read Hegel please. Youre twisting yourself into religious metaphysical thought.
2026-07-18 18:13:39
7
Sharif Schulze Allen 🔻 :
You correctly state that capital is an anarchic production process. This is because the production of surplus value is its governing logic, which is a consequence of private capitals competing against each other by selling commodities above their individual values but below the social average determined by necessary labour time. This by definition excludes the possibility of a centrally planned economy, since a capitalist economy is dictated by the interests of private capitals in competition. Ernest Mandel makes this point in the introduction to volume I. Now bearing this in mind, how can China’s dominant mode of production be capitalist? China has centrally planned its economy since 1949. Its economy is not anarchic, because profit is not its driving force. It is for this reason that it is a socialist mode of production
2026-06-30 22:32:10
1
🕊️COMMANDING HEIGHTS🐦⬛ :
You had me lost at first but you brought it in. You finish all of capital ?
2026-06-21 13:07:58
0
judas :
Wb the NEP
2026-08-09 17:24:44
0
socialistmtn :
A factory is an example of material capital, a factory can be a tool.
2026-06-21 12:36:46
2
- :
Great video! Very well explained
2026-06-23 15:35:12
4
EsotericKarlHeldFangirl :
Self valorising value. Enforced by a state. You cannot have capital without state. Even as much as capital is its own thing.
2026-06-25 04:43:27
4
Mr Universe :
but who do u think controls the capital..the rich... and if the state controls the rich then we could say the state controls the capital but they don't own the capital themselves
2026-06-19 17:51:35
3
☭ LesbianLeninistStalinist ☭ :
Stalin talks about this in Economic Problems
2026-07-09 15:38:21
2
Red Rainbow :
Please moot me🥹
2026-06-24 15:55:40
3
cc :
china doesnt consider themselves socalist btw.. their own 5 year plan is called the ROAD to socalism
2026-07-24 12:13:55
0
hidden_falcon :
Also have you read Mute Compulsion by Søren Mau? Right up your alley on this topic.
2026-06-20 03:43:39
3
_superchargerwhine :
capitalism IS a tool, already if compared to theory of everything such as Marxism
2026-06-29 03:39:32
1
🌱🚩♫⃠ olii ♫⃠ 🚩🍃 :
Capital is what is needed to profit which is often money, and it can go in the hands of anyone. And i can prove it easily
2026-07-18 00:34:43
1
P :
Capital flows towards the highest profits which creates the total rate of profit across the economy to establish the price of production that all commodities are sold at.
2026-06-26 18:17:32
1
TheDestroyer :
People are not conditioned by history. Economic conditions shape things but don’t erase human freedom. Also states control capital all the time 😭
2026-07-05 01:07:15
0
haenis :
Sorry but this is pure fetichism…ure treating capital as a pure essence floating above its concrete forms (the state, money, law, class). But the relation never exists outside its determinate forms… there’s no ‘capital in itself’ acting beyond mediation. That’s exactly how you determine whether a state is capitalist or not: not by asking if it ‘touches’ some pure essence (social relation), but by looking at which concrete forms (money, market, wage labor, appropriation of the social product) are reproduced, destroyed, or replaced
2026-06-20 11:21:55
26
Ac.m :
“The essence of bourgeois society consists precisely in this, that a priori there is no conscious social regulation of production. The rational and naturally necessary asserts itself only as a blindly working average.”
2026-06-20 04:19:48
15
To see more videos from user @omokirikiri, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.
