I think they had Phoebe and Piper disregard how Paige felt a little too much it p*ssed me off because most of the time Paige was right and then it blew up in there faces because they didn't listen to Paige
2026-06-22 16:27:58
19
Meghan :
I'd love to hear more about how you think the show could have gone if Prue lived! Plot beats, etc. For example, what do you think she would have thought about Leo wilding out with all the elder nonsense?
2026-06-22 15:17:58
22
Skylar Da Writer :
Piper/Phoebe had some sort of grudge against telekinetics, because they ain’t never listen to Prue or Paige, lol! Remember when Prue caught Cole in that demon trap and they thought PRUE was trippin’? Then they ignored Paige’s warnings about the doll maker. Piper/Phoebe ain’t never learn. 😂
2026-06-23 12:54:13
22
D.C :
I feel like it really emanates the tone of the final episode of season 3 and the beginning of season 4. Prue was becoming too intuitive to the Source and I feel like he noticed how much that intuition was driving her and her Sisters closer to defeating him. So when she was taken out of the picture, he let his guard down, but then heavily underestimated Paige. I think one of the reason I actually love Paige is because she kind of reestablished that "voice of reason" embodiment that Prue used to be for the Sisters when they were actively in the wrong- but still had moments where that voice wasn't always used appropriately or in the right moments which gave her room to be flawed in a sense.
2026-06-22 15:20:28
8
Brandy Johnson :
I think it also sucked for page because she didn't have a lot of authority like she was the new sister and even though she knew that they loved her I mean she's also the the youngest😭 so you're already screwed because you have no authority so even if you do have a point they're not going to listen to you or take you seriously and then you got to take into consideration that she is newer to being a witch a white lighter supernatural in general so they definitely didn't take her seriously
2026-07-26 09:16:12
2
Cartoons & funny videos 📷😂 :
yes I agree Prue was so smart when the plot kicks in....she has discernment allot .... She would've picked up on Cole the moment he absorbed the hollow and started acting weird.. and definitely agree on Piper siding with Prue right away😍
2026-06-22 14:38:09
20
Michael 🏳️🌈 :
Constance M Burge was the main driver of the “sisters who happen to be witches” and Wicca premise of the show. She stepped down as an executive producer ahead of season 3 due to creative differences with Brad Kern, who wanted that more wacky fantasy and also romance storylines. Constance stayed on as an executive consultant but was gone by the end of season 4. And from season 5 onwards well… we saw what happened!
2026-06-23 22:32:09
8
Sorry_Time443 :
I think of prue made it to s4 they would have made her powers go away or make her lose her memory of magic or her sisters something like that to keep it going
2026-06-23 07:18:20
0
peterblake19 :
That was purely because they knew they were going to get rid of her. They used her for so many storylines showing how strong she was. If she wasn’t going to leave, season 3 would have played different. I still wish Shannen had stayed and Alyssa left. That woman ruined shannens life.
2026-06-22 15:57:02
4
justariess0 :
One of Paige’s secret abilities was evil sensing. The way she was able to sense and be around when the magical community is in danger. Unmatched
2026-07-11 09:22:39
1
TJ :
I believe regardless of S3 that Paige would’ve shown up in S4 and I think Paige’s arrival would’ve divided the sisters because Prue wouldve trusted Paige’s intuition which would’ve led to the Source Cole-Evil Phoebe storyline. As for S5 on idk how the storylines would’ve looked
2026-06-22 21:00:03
0
Tay :
I agree! It was much more grounded in the Wicca/Witchcraft stuff in the early seasons and then went too much to the fantastical by s5. I would’ve loved it if they’d stayed more true to the beginning essence of the show.
2026-06-23 03:16:52
2
GraphicSilence :
I am going. To be honest, I wish the actors would have acted like adults and just worked things out so that Prue could have stayed on the show. It was a much better show with her character there.
2026-06-22 17:25:18
3
Apollo☀️🌑✨ :
I feel like the reason why 5-7 were a bit more fantasy is because they literally vanquish the source of all evil twice and the council of high demons! That tipped magic wayyy in the favour of light/good. Until season 7/8 went back darker imo
2026-06-24 02:42:42
3
Skylar Da Writer :
While I appreciated Prue’s career change arc, I kind of wish they kept her as a corporate baddie. I liked the dynamic of having the corporate baddie, the entrepreneur, and the free spirit all in one family. Plus, photography was already not paying like it used to in 2000. Ain’t no way Prue was able to make a living as a freelancer with zero experience. She would’ve needed other income.
2026-06-23 12:57:44
5
Jluv :
LETS👏TAWK👏ABOUT👏IT👏 BC it’s not talked about enough for me how much Prue& Paige were sooo much alike!! I mean they even looked alike to me outside of the show n inside!!(inspector Rodriquez clocked it too!😏) they even shared the same intuitiveness! Prue on multiple occasions would feel that things were different or wrong or something! Even when she fought S💩T… oh I mean SHAX OL PALE, DRY ASS!! She felt him before he attacked. Paige had a bad feeling about the house Finn lived in, COLE! The dreams she had when they turned into goddesses. It’s like they too had some sense of clairvoyance .
2026-06-22 20:55:32
3
Tay :
Also! Always loved the idea (if Prue had lived) that she’d eventually meet a male witch or mortal, who had their first love also die. A little like Richard but not him exactly. And he’d be just very grown and stuff.
2026-06-23 03:21:22
1
To see more videos from user @diamondtalkz, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.