@maan_alshimary: Fasting on ashura a sunnah or an innovation? #muharram #hussain #karbala #ashura #shia

Banjo Janjo :

Which Ashura were the Jews fasting on?

EMKWAN :

Also important for Sunnis to know according to the majority Sunni historical narration, the fast of Ashura was observed before Ramadan fasting became obligatory, and then its legal status changed after Ramadan was prescribed.

ރ عباس :

Ahsant❤️

m77ab33 :

Ahsant

🇱🇧ميرزا مهدي٣١٣ :

Ahsantom❤️❤️

AbuMaytham313 :

احسنت

بتول الجعفرية 🕯️🤎 :

احسنت اخونا الله يبارك فيك 👏🏼

Ebi313 :

السلامُعلیک یا ابا عبداللہ الحسین السلامُعلیک یا علی ابن الحسین السلامُعلیک یا اولاد الحسین السلامُعلیک یا اصحاب الحسین

🥊suesue 🇵🇸👑🍉🍊 :

Thanks for explaining

Zayn Abiya ރ :

Fasting to celebrate a Judaic celebration? What next fasting for Christmas and Hannukah and Buddhist and Hindu celebrations too? Since when did wahhabis become pluralist?

alikazmi313b :

@lowinteresthomes :

He never fasted although he was there for years.

Osumanu Abubakari :

may almighty Allah guide us from ignorance, Lahaina Yaa Hussain (as)

Yassien :

the true story is the hadieth .

Sir _Tahir :

❣️❣️❣️

Mudah :

Allahuma swali aala Muhammad wa aali Muhammad 🙏🏾

Abdalla Ali :

Jews are still here. If the 10th of Muharram was a special day commemorating the victory of Prophet Moses (AS), what is the name of that day in Judaism? A simple check of the calendar for 631 AD shows that the first ten days of Muharram do not coincide with any Jewish holy day, and Judaism has no special fast associated with Muharram. If this was truly a major Jewish observance, why do the people who inherited and preserved the Mosaic tradition not celebrate it today?

AbuAli :

imagine the prophet needed help from the Jews to know about the relation to Allah.

. :

Who told the prophet the Jews were fasting??

Anonymous :

Not only that brother also Jews don't follow islamic calendar their date is 15th if Nisan, second this narration is from ibn Abbas,he was under 3 years old when prophet pbuh arrived in madina so far too many issues with this story

Soleri :

The Jews don't fast on Ashura. Please, ask a Rabbi. Bring evidence from the Jews that they celebrate, or fast, for the saving of Moses from Pharaoh!