@.vanbur: Do You Believe Any Of These? 🤠 | Ib: @Red Dead Boah | #arthurmorgan #gaming #rdr2 #edit #jcole

️ :

I personally dont think Abigail is the rat, she wouldn't put jack in danger

Capital A :

Trelawny is the strange man because they both have top hats

♛ 𝑪𝒉𝒂𝒅 ♛ :

Gavin is the Strange man

XSET_SILENT😈 :

Uncle is red Harlow is crazy cuz how go from being the fast gunslinger from 80’s to having lumbago

ripvanwinkle :

First playthrough ahh theories

Elias Sprinkle :

I think the strange man is Pearson. They both have too hats

Joe Davis :

Arthur’s son is alive

Massive Mason :

Knowing uncle, if he were to be Red Harlow he would’ve been talking about it non stop

lucas :

Mihai :

trelawny is not the strange man, the strange man appears in rdr2

Dr. Eazy :

How did Red Harlow become THAT? Like no hate to uncle I love uncle but it that’s what Red turned into? That’s just sad. Of course it’s not him though

🔺️✝️🇱🇧☦🔺️ :

first 2 are most likely possible the third is pretty much impossible

🏀 Issa🏀 :

The trelawny and Abigail part are the only ones that make sense

Sertmol11_ :

Uncle is obiusly Red Harlow

Kev :

If Trewlany was the strange man, John would recognize him

RilbroWHU :

All wrong

WIZARD :

Red harlow не дядюшка ведь шрамы бы остались

Manas0a! :

I feel like everything was true except the Abigail one

Adi😜🌟 :

The Strange man is not Trewlany

petarbaloski🫪 :

is Josiah was the strange man john would recognise him

Ty :

Everything you said is wrong

Dark9.9.9 :

"uncle is red harlow"

zoro_900 :

all the theories are wrong red harlow was in 1880 like 20 years uncle in 1899 was 70 at "least" and Abigail wasn't the rat Micah proved he's the rat and the last theory is also wrong because the strange man have a cabin in the swamps in rdr2 search and look he appears in mirror when the game is 100%