@changatang: i hate the trolley theory sm bc this dude was out here constantly saying things like this and showing his true colors but nobody was smart enough to clock itttt until it was too late #arthurmorgan #rdr2 #dutchvanderlinde
the trolley theory is an insult to a deep character like dutch
2026-06-25 22:02:41
8202
♠️ :
Freudian Slip, never fails to reveal itself
2026-06-27 07:34:38
299
J_Carro :
Why do so many people think Dutch was ever good? He’s a narcissist with a superiority complex and a ton of other issues. Like Rains Falls said “people don’t change, they become more of who they really are”. Part of Arthur’s character arc is figuring out his father figure truly is just a terrible person.
2026-06-26 01:46:20
18344
Tyler Moe :
With every new play through I see his narcissism earlier and earlier it’s crazy…
2026-06-26 15:43:51
8410
andy 🦎 :
“Stay strong. Stay with me.” So early in the game that you don’t realize that line alone is all his insecurities shining through.
2026-06-25 17:23:23
6096
SeanMcCarbomb :
Freudian slip of a lifetime dutch😭
2026-06-25 14:26:08
2457
kitana :
I’ve never liked the trolley theory either, to me it downplays Dutch’s true evil that was present the entire game, and even before the game starts. It’s obvious to me that he was always like this, but the events of the game just pushed him further into madness
2026-06-25 14:03:30
2207
LevinLife :
“There were no signs”
2026-06-25 22:50:00
1100
TROPIE :
You see Dutch in a completely different way after the first play, and I love him for that. In my first playthrough, I thought Dutch was a good leader until the last moment, but after I finished the game for the first time, it was like my eyes were opened to the true nature of Dutch
2026-06-26 06:55:12
302
Jaz :
This boat scene is actually what made me look at him differently BECAUSE of that slip up. I was like ah I see; there is not loyalty in all of our blood.
2026-06-26 15:10:04
346
joachim :
he always was a narcissist he just managed to hide it really well that being said I do think he cares about the gang but he definitely had some sort of saviour complex
2026-06-25 20:36:01
660
Destiny :
First playthrough and I’m in chapter three. He’s constantly putting the gang in harms way by not thinking about everyone involved in his crazy robberies and plans, yet preaches they need to start doing better. He’s annoying me honestly lol
2026-06-29 17:40:43
7
Bill :
I find it interesting how he said to Arthur he was considering “a famous chess move” a chess opening famous for sacrificing alot of pieces. He absolutely knew what he was doing
2026-06-26 09:45:09
55
SEAN MACGUIRE :
i think they were somewhat clocking it but backtracking themselves because it’s dutch and they love him and didn’t want to believe that he was ACTUALLY like that.
2026-06-26 04:32:32
78
Jeff :
I thought it was strange how one of the first camp upgrades in the ledger is for Dutch and Dutch alone.
2026-07-14 02:39:41
34
Lorainne :
I literally captured the moment he said that to both of emmmm😭😭
2026-07-11 02:07:12
11
mr.wixked :
after you rescue micah you lit hear him lying to dutch back at camp and its so obvious
2026-06-25 19:01:33
84
Joseph :
People always forget the key part of his character is that he was always fractured / crazy, he just shows more of who he really is. A huge theme in the game is that, people don’t change they become more of who they really are. Dutch was always a pos and the trolly theory kind of diminishes his character.
2026-06-25 14:23:55
103
Jillian :
The fact that that isn’t even the first time he has that slip in the game and yet people still miss it and are convinced the trolley was the problem 😭😭 not to mention the countless other context clues you get in camp just by getting random dialogue with him
2026-06-26 01:02:59
114
Berna :
I hate Dutch. I HATE HIM
2026-07-20 16:29:53
25
˚𖥔 ݁ ˖𓂃.𝓒hesz. ݁˖🧀 :
“I” was just a simple foreshadowing. He knew HE was always going to be okay, he didn’t care about the rest unless he got what he wanted.
2026-06-26 06:05:03
34
Kian :
Dutch is so complex and fantastically written a genuine goated character imo
2026-06-25 22:05:10
60
David :
Just imagine Arthur left after valentine with that money and went and married Mary
2026-08-12 19:06:47
5
To see more videos from user @changatang, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.