I understand that the first 5 seasons are undeniably better but I think the decline in quality is also very rich for analysis. I could talk for hours about how continuing to live makes the Winchesters less human and turns them into the monsters they spent their lives fighting and how the show shifted from the boys being in this world to the boys being the center of it.
2026-07-11 19:04:05
777
Kelli โ Impulse & Ink :
I watched it for the first time after like 20 years of my friend telling me how good it was. Nobody warned me how many similarities it had to Arthurian legends and the side characters have heavy overlap with Arthurian knights of Camelot.
2026-07-12 23:20:21
131
๐ :
hate the s1-5 are best argument bc S14 is literally one of its very best
2026-07-14 03:48:17
4
peggypieinthesky :
I try to think of 1-5 as a standalone show and 5-15 as a spinoff. While not as good, it expands on the canon lore. People also forget that it was made in the 2000's. It paved the way for so many things. it helped create Tumblr, fandoms, put fresh faces on screens. There's still time for another amazing series to come out, but they'll have to tip their hat to spn for making it possible.
2026-07-13 14:30:52
62
โจ๐kai.t ๐ท๏ธ ๐ :
The mythological lore of their cases were phenomenal. It was okay when it became theological but the cases were the best!
2026-07-12 19:10:35
87
My Haunting Romance :
i was just discussing with a friend how I can't wait for it to be taught in classrooms in 20ish years when its considered a modern classic/part of canon American Lit
2026-06-30 03:13:23
91
Olivia Young-Thompson :
heavy on the first 5 seasons ONLY
2026-06-30 07:18:28
97
vakknight :
I actually enjoyed the later seasons more as I got characters I got to spend more time with personally
2026-07-02 00:31:49
18
phatbeardtv :
As much as I love Supernatural and some moments from the later 10 seasons. If it had ended with season 5 it may have went down as one of the Greatest shows of the era.
It still maybe, but we had a major exchange of quality for quantity and it never found its footing again in my opinion.
2026-07-13 13:37:31
8
Ale M. :
I have a 15 minute persuasive speech in my oral communications class convincing people to watch Supernatural๐ and it wasnโt even hard because even 10 years ago thereโs was SO MUCH TO TALK ABOUT
2026-07-14 07:30:06
1
walkingcoffeestain :
What have I done
2026-07-10 17:32:10
12
NovaCascade :
Do you talk about the sudden shift in how Sam went from an important character in seasons 1-2, to becoming a sidekick to Dean in seasons 3-5? Not to mention how it becomes even more prevalent later on with Cas and Dean becoming even more important to the plot while Sam is just kinda there. Even when being Lucifer's true vessel in S5 and being soulless in S6, he wasn't really that integral to the plot since it all really revolved around Dean and how he dealt with the situations.
2026-07-13 22:08:15
4
Breanna :
As someone whose academic background is in fandom I can say that the way the show co-created with its fans is unheard of. Going from Becky to Charlie to the musical episode where Dean gives creative control and permission to the fans is insane
2026-07-14 01:18:44
3
hazymindstate :
Enough time has passed where we can say Deanโs sudden death is actually a fitting way for the story to end
2026-07-13 17:58:22
3
norman โกs higgs! :
Only the first five seasons tho
2026-07-01 21:03:01
5
Silent screaming :
interview with the vampire is/is getting pretty good. the lore is unfolding beautifully and we're only on book 2ish outta like 8 I believe
2026-06-29 22:57:15
15
Nate Ate Late :
I think you meant Fortunately.
2026-07-02 05:18:06
3
El_Guapo_D1ablo :
I really need to get on with watching this series. I think I might be 2/3 through episode 1.
2026-07-13 03:13:08
0
kimberly.marieee_cosplay :
The fact that the show and his actors are the reason AO3 exists is nuts everytime I think about it
2026-07-14 04:05:37
1
Null :
1-5 were perfect. 6-15 were decent. better than most other shows. but not as good as seasons 1-5.
2026-07-13 15:00:18
1
imogen ๐๐ :
too true
2026-06-29 22:14:50
1
Wylie ๐ค :
NOTHING has hit for me since then
2026-07-13 15:14:52
0
Jessica :
Ummm where can I read your thesis? ๐
2026-07-13 11:25:26
0
To see more videos from user @oonarosewrites, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.