@therationalanimal: #philtok #philosophy #theology #philosophyofreligion #philosophytiktok

revequestion :

im atheist and im genuinely embarrased sorry

polarizinglight :

p1 is already false as we cannot comprehend God’s existence out of time it’s literally not possible as we’re bound by time we’re enabled to think by time rather than observe he’s out of time, yet he is out of time we can comprehend how he looks at time tbh

Αντώνιος ✝️ :

God does not merely exist, God is Existence itself.

MendimBlakaj :

Also he seems to be treating time as an abstract concept, which is false as spacetime is a fabric which curves & is relative to the mass of the objects

🐌🛶coolguycolinnn :

What’s your response to problem of evil

♢(Strich) :

What was tht first premise😭

EnvyMe :

“Literally read the first line” I can’t bro it’s out of screen 😭

humanist_77 :

one question if God nature isnt contingent, then why his nature is good, "kind"?

KidFromفلسفة :

We can debate on a temporal god man

king :

how do you define time though? Just asking because i have no idea what time is. I think time is just a change

premtim :

one could js say time is abstract

gm_effect :

🇲🇽Chris🇪🇨 :

I was in that live bro. Him and someone named amateur theologian were talking eith eachother for like 40 or 50 minutes

luhjj :

great points but calling mfs idiots lowk ruining it for me

mr.fishyboi0 :

What would you say to the problem of hell, specifically hell has eternal conscious torment, and how it might be a punishment too harsh?

Thotracker83 :

The temporal framework is hidden in the premise because he posits nothing can logically exist without time, or anything that changes to be more clear which he’d reject the possibility that god can be unchanged because he most go from a state of not creating the universe to a state of creating one which is causal events which are in time. I don’t fully agree with that but that’s what he’s saying

⚡︎ ✹ ℋ ✹ ⚡︎ :

Genuinely amazing

FuturisticRanger :

god is time god is existence god is a necessary cause of existence

.... :

holy strawman😭

Robin :

Are you a theist? If so which religion do you adhere to if any at all? Im curious, no other motive

Jαn :

P2 is just false coz we believe in B theory of time

unDire :

cook