@jkstealingtheinternet: My big cookie should be free, AITA? #reddit #aitareddit #aita #StealingTheInternet #redditstories

Vix :

Carl didnt go over there on purpose he didnt want to give the refund

✮⋆˙𝐌𝐨𝐨𝐧✮⋆˙ :

For this type of contest dont you leave a timer also in the table with like an alarm for the client to pause when its over? is definitely bad organization on the bakery

Ginormous76 :

If you have a timed competition and aren’t watching the last couple minutes, you’re giving them bonus time. That’s the point of the competition.

✨ Tiffany ✨ :

I don't believe a free cookie is worth the bad look this gives the business. As a member of management for my family business, even if it was 2 minutes over and the customer was disputing, I would still probably give them it for free. Some battles are not worth fighting in this economy.

Tara Bates999🇨🇦 :

From owners pov sure maybe he’s in the right but regardless none of the ppl seeing this know that guy and care but they are all currently in your shop so you’re the one who needs to be deferential

Lara :

4 pounds=1,814 Kilogramm

joshua.horton :

Carl!!!

Artic_Chan :

Also Isn't there usally a paper or something to explain how the eating competition works? Or just like explain how it works?

Anari🪷🐛 :

Why did he even make it a stopwatch he should have made it a timer so that even if he was busy the timer would go off and he would know to go check

arsholan :

Josh is being so funny in the last few months I’m crying 😭

︎Isaac :

This guy sounds like lets game it out in YouTube

Charlotte :

Ahh cookie podcast I was wondering why so many stories about cookies

Joe :

‘The title is weird and doesn’t pant me ina good light’… okay you chose the title though right?

Elin :

Im fried and i thought the cat in the womans lap was a table at first and was so convused as to why shr was just stroking a table

travisjackman961 :

cute cate love cat cat orange we lobe orange very orange and cuddly orange

krs :

TrineMachine :

nta

Ueini :

I'm too early

OtakuReddit :

Someone voted YTA 💀 is Carl watching?

Queen Dea🩵 :

I feel like he set a stopwatch on purpose. Setting a timer would’ve been a far more effective way of measuring your hour and alerting when that hours is over.

Jesalynn :

OP was in the right, but even if he wasn't, I would never eat somewhere an employee or manager were allowed to yell at customers

Author-by-Night :

Why… a stopwatch? Just… just set a timer? So an alarm goes off when the time’s up?

AsianHermit :

No he did that on purpose just so he didn’t lose money😭

finnbot_1 :

If Carl wasn’t there to stop the watch, and Cookie was gone, it is free.

Luíza :

1% says YTA and i'd really like to have someone presenting their arguments but i didn't found anyone in the comments 😕 Anyways, why didn't carl just took the alarm with him so he'd know when to come back to check the last 2 minutes of the context? Yeah, Carl is a cheater who just didn't want to give the win to OP. (Also, if i were in Carl's place, I don't think this hill is worth to die on. Even if i thought OP finished 2 minutes later, if i couldn't prove it, I'd just give him the win.)