LesserGoldfinch :
You are 100% correct in your analysis, and it is extremely well presented. I think that the “progress” that Americans seem to bestow upon themselves, at least within the realm of racial politics, is a purely ideological projection based in the shared understanding of the mythological “founding principles”. It goes like this: we fought a war to abolish slavery, and slavery was abolished. Then, even though Jim Crow and segregation were bad, at least it wasn’t slavery. Then the Civil Rights Movement happened, and Jim Crow and segregation were outlawed. Then, even though the War on Drugs and War on Crime era were bad, at least it wasn’t Jim Crow. And so on. The key thing that everyone misses (that you hit very well) is that this framing is completely devoid of a *material* and economic understanding of these political events. They believe that just because segregation was deemed unconstitutional, segregation vanished overnight. And we never had to worry about it again. Along those lines, most Americans view these historic events as representing clean ruptures in political/economic/cultural landscapes. “After the civil war, slavery was dead forever. After the CRM, segregation was completely taken care of.” I think the basis is that Americans have a profoundly idealistic (ie philosophical Idealism) understanding of their history, economy, and political structures. They do not possess a material understanding of the process of historical development, so they will never see the endless cycles that you point out. They will never acknowledge that the system of slavery simply morphed and contorted and hid itself in other institutions, and under other names. They fail to see the concrete linkages in the banks, the corporations, the infrastructure, the capital flows, the militarism, the expansion and extraction, and the social relations. For the average USian, the “progress” they see is: well, we abolished slavery; then we abolished Jim Crow; we gave women the right to vote; SCOTUS handed down Roe v Wade. See? We’re always making “progress”
2026-07-17 04:38:44