brettsthoughts
Region: GB
Friday 17 July 2026 21:21:00 GMT
179667
25546
179
588
Music
Download
Comments
Atlas live :
The character the movies ruined the most is still Ron
2026-07-17 22:03:47
2164
~Mia~ :
hagrid was the father figure harry was looking for and i will die on that hill
2026-07-18 01:44:42
407
Robyn :
These are the reasons the comments of ‘we don’t need the series’ just feel like they are coming from those that didn’t grow up reading the books. They are movie fans only, and that’s ok. But this series should pick up on what the movies didn’t, they have more time to really flesh these things out and show the complexities of the characters
2026-09-03 19:01:48
0
Morlok :
In my mind, this is who Sirius Black is when I read the books….
2026-07-18 10:54:20
513
Dalton Surber :
I thought Gary Oldmam being a but older worked. Sirius should have looked a bit ragged and aged after all those years in Azkaban.
2026-07-18 00:30:33
548
TennesseeTopHat :
I feel like they also made Harry’s parents look too old also
2026-07-18 11:26:11
424
ThackeryBinx :
Yes. Modern books readers won’t really understand how complex Sirius’ death was because each book release afterwards was two years apart so if you didn’t believe he was gone you spent years denying, waiting, processing, it really was the five stages of grief
2026-09-03 19:12:31
0
Allison :
In addition, that's why the statement "Nice one James" in Order of the Phoenix hurt Harry more - but you don't get that as much in the movies because it seems like a moment of weakness rather than the books using it as a point the Sirius really only saw Harry as James 2.0
2026-08-12 19:56:04
58
APX42 :
Your take on this is why I dont like your take on Lupin.
2026-09-03 03:59:06
0
Lex 🖤✨ :
Harry’s grief in the book is so different in the books too, partially because Harry was smoothed around the edges in the movie but because in the books he felt somewhat responsible for Sirius. He had to be the more mature one and when he acted recklessly and went into the trap, he blamed himself. It’s a massive turning point for Harry, he becomes depressed similar to after Cedric’s death and Voldemort’s resurrection but he also curbs his impulses more. He takes more responsibility and starts to see things in a more mature lens.
2026-07-18 09:14:20
124
Zeke :
Gary Goldman infamously said that he wishes he would have taken this role more seriously. He knows he could have done better. He said that knowing the direction. So when you say it was the director, you are not completely correct.
2026-07-17 23:39:52
215
JeniferPhD :
I’m rewatching all the movies in the theater for the 25th anniversary. (One more to go today.) One thing that I’ve really noticed is how much the movies flattened out the details and nuance. I know why and the movies have things the books don’t, but somehow it’s much more noticeable on the big screen after 25 years of rereading the books and only watching on a little screen occasionally
2026-09-03 13:10:01
0
Nate :
He’s a caged animal moved to a slightly more comfortable cage - missing his best friends
2026-08-11 00:21:00
54
Dominiczek2137 :
I think it's good decision casting older actor to show viewers how dementors can drain "life" from you
2026-07-17 23:12:11
834
Erika :
movies also butchered Dumbledore, Ron and ginny
2026-07-20 16:46:34
112
Jordan 📚☕️ :
“How the movies ruined…” and I’m immediately SAT for this content
2026-07-21 14:48:20
174
EAST MENACE :
movies are movies. you can never beat the depth of the books
2026-08-08 04:57:37
67
Irene Altmiller :
Sirius, Ron, Dumbledore, Ginny, Tom Riddle and Harry have such better nuance and complexity in the books that the movies just make so flat
2026-07-17 23:58:12
94
Swamp witch :
In the book OOTP, Hermione tries to articulate her concerns about Sirius, when he approves of DA. That his approval was a red flag
2026-07-18 00:28:14
68
Ibbi 🇩🇰 :
Thats one of the biggest flops in the movies.. All the adults looks so much older then the should.. Sirius should be what 35 and he looks almost 50.. I think you would understand his caracter better if he actually looked like a young man
2026-08-12 17:14:40
7
wickedASMR :
I would argue that Sirius sees himself as a father figure, he just had a warped sense of fatherhood so he tried to recreate what he thought James would want him to be. He lived off rats in those mountains, just to be near Harry. I think he was just an immature guy who saw fatherhood through the lens of friendship.
2026-08-23 23:44:14
6
KB :
Please cover lupin if you haven’t already!! I would love to hear your thoughts on his character between the book and the movie!!
2026-08-15 15:05:24
10
jxnnxfxr :
you may be right but Gary Oldman is fantastic as Sirius and I am very happy with his performance, considering thr material he was given.
2026-07-18 01:17:43
19
Katherine ~Wolfstar version :
“Think about it” I think about it every day 😭 I’m a marauder fan since the book, he’s ma favourite 😭 this is all I think about it! And I totally agree with your analysis
2026-07-18 08:17:31
21
To see more videos from user @brettsthoughts, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.
