@philosophyminis: Here is a test to see if somebody is truly a good person, or whether they are just faking it. You can use this test on your friends and your family to see how well they do. It goes back to Plato, and it's all to do with a magic ring. Suppose somebody gives you a ring that gives you the power of invisibility. You can go where you want, and do as you please. No one will see you, and no one will hear you. In your heart of hearts, what would be the first thing that you did? This Ring of Gyges thought experiment appears in Plato's Republic, and the character of Glaucon supposes that almost everybody who gets this ring would use it for some immoral purpose. They would rob a bank, they would spy on somebody, they would harm somebody they don’t like — all of the things that you don't do in normal times. But, of course, the real test is about why we do the good things that we do. Do we do good because we want to be rewarded and seen as good? Or do we do it because it is just the right thing to do? Because, for Plato, Socrates, the good person, doesn't care at all what other people see, hear, or think about them. They care only about justice. They care only about the good. So, are you a virtuous person, according to Plato? Are your friends? Are you actually a good person, or do you only want to be seen as good?

Jonny Thomson
Jonny Thomson
Open In TikTok:
Region: GB
Saturday 01 August 2026 13:42:01 GMT
100997
6351
283
411

Music

Download

Comments

methodmadness90
methodmadness90 :
I KNOW I’m not a good person. Just an evil person trying to be less evil one decision at a time.
2026-08-01 13:45:31
423
omaralleynelawler
Omar Alleyne :
I just don’t want to use the ring? I have no need for it? Is that wrong?
2026-08-01 23:33:43
1
nikina_mama
nikina_mama :
But, is robbing a bank actually an immoral purpose?!
2026-08-01 15:43:04
311
ryanthepsian
RyyanL'🍉ien :
Would using it to harm people who cause harm to others be considered immoral?
2026-08-01 17:44:15
3
bumblebarnacles
ginger_bee :
I'd use it to escape my life, hide in a cave, and exclusively eat raw fish.
2026-08-01 13:50:40
135
bonabelle_2373
bonabelle_2373 :
I would go steal some food
2026-08-01 14:30:58
76
spreadlovedoodles2025
sld :
Me thinking I’d take evening walks without concern for my safety lol
2026-08-01 21:11:28
13
frannatok
gramcois :
I'm not a good person
2026-08-01 17:05:11
1
ricosauve1988
小妹妹的洞 :
as a Buddhist, I do good things to earn karma points for my afterlife.
2026-08-01 13:59:28
22
whydostthoutormentme
Turin :
Someone who doesn’t care about anything other than justice and doing “good” can actually end up being totally horrifically evil in their actions. Taking away context makes actions impossible to judge, because no action occurs in a moral vacuum.
2026-08-01 13:57:49
56
questionar6
QüestioNar :
My victim:
2026-08-01 20:47:24
7
hganey10
ℍ𝕒𝕟𝕒𝕕 :
I'm sorry Jonny but how does this make any sense? If I put on that magical ring, how am I supposed to interact with anyone? The only way to avoid making everyone uncomfortable would be to stay in my own house. The thought experiment already assumes that having the power to be invisible is morally neutral when it isn't. The moment you have that ability, people have every reason to distrust you no matter how "good" you are because you could spy on them any time or invade their privacy without anyone knowing. So the thought experiment doesn't really test who's genuinely good and who's only pretending to be. It starts with a scenario that already changes how everyone would reasonably judge you
2026-08-01 17:26:20
13
enzomiami11
@ᡕᠵ᠊ᡃ່࡚ࠢ࠘⸝່ࠡࠣ᠊߯᠆ࠣ࠘uPrince :
lets be fr, we are all evil
2026-08-01 14:31:48
7
tulip.futures
terrible angel :
robbing a bank is perfectly ethical actually
2026-08-01 17:23:50
29
deeply.shallow
Deeply Shallow :
I’d probably go sleep in the grass at a park or sit in random beautiful places that aren’t meant for sitting to read books and work on my poetry and short stories. Ever since I came to China there’s been a growing trend of not letting people touch grass in parks and public spaces. Guards kick you out if you try to sit or lay in it. Only some limited designated places allow it. So yeah, I’d probably do that again.🤔
2026-08-01 17:20:53
2
1heartless11
NoBody- :
Plot twist, Everyone now think they are bad person instead of asking a friend. 😂
2026-08-01 19:29:45
4
everscar
EVERSCAR :
I’m pretty invisible already tbh
2026-08-01 15:05:26
20
elpilos7
elpilos :
someone needs to fix the world
2026-08-01 18:20:24
2
melterfly
Melt :
My first thought was going to the movies, my second thought, as a woman, is to have a nice peaceful walk at night in the summer without the fear of being assaulted.
2026-08-01 22:07:19
17
vikki_komori
visiv :
Honestly, my first thought was I'd use the invisibility ring to dress in short sleeve clothes and stand in the sun without worrying about anyone looking at me. I want to feel the sunlight on my skin but I am terribly uncomfortable with being perceived in public.
2026-08-01 17:28:22
12
user4398356066359
￴ ￴ ￴ ￴￴ ￴ ￴ ￴￴￴ ￴￴￴￴ ￴￴ :
straight to the bank for me!
2026-08-01 14:02:29
9
carstenbeinecke
Carsten Beinecke 🇩🇪 :
And would I be a good person if I kill an evil person?
2026-08-01 14:41:35
10
_victor_02_
C :
i would steal from the rich
2026-08-01 20:55:07
7
lm36572
lm36572 :
I genuinely would go sit in like a kids park and listen to like little kid conversations when they don’t think adults are listening because genuinely kids are friggin hilarious 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
2026-08-01 16:14:49
9
mini_life_diaries
Mini🖤Life :
I truthfully don't know what it will do with such a ring😂
2026-08-01 22:44:33
0
To see more videos from user @philosophyminis, please go to the Tikwm homepage.

Other Videos


About