This era of poorly written books has me worried that the new generation of readers that get into reading via booktok will accept this lousy standard of writing and lower the bar for good romantasy. 😭
2026-08-04 22:44:20
33
cass!! :
Irrelevant but what are these really pretty black and white books behind you? 👀👀
2026-08-06 23:06:04
4
mede💋 :
i want so bad to read a GOOD fantasy book/series but it's sooo hard to find one that don't feel like it was written by a teenager and the romance subplot isn't cringe😭😭pls help me out girll
2026-08-04 21:28:47
35
jennas.booked :
I don’t understand why ppl don’t like seeing negative book reviews especially if you’re doing it in a respectful way. Is that not the entire point of being a book reviewer 😭???
2026-08-05 00:02:54
13
Halliguin :
I followed you solely based on your negative views lol I really enjoyed your validation 😂 sometimes I feel gaslit by Booktok like was the book poorly written or am I slipping? oh no it's not me it's a bad book 😮💨
2026-08-04 21:27:42
17
TheJenGLV Booktok 📚 :
I give honest reviews - good or bad ☺️I always try to be respectful and suggest it to audiences that might like it, but I always share what I THINK because that’s the only
2026-08-05 01:18:34
2
antoinettecealopesreads :
Yes! Negative reviews are important for so many reasons.
2026-08-24 19:04:14
1
Nina Verona 📚 :
Yup, it’s totally fine when readers and book influencers are publicly negative about books. That’s their right. What I don’t like is when authors do it to other authors because then there’s a professional line that they’re crossing—AND I think that’s exactly why there are a LOT of booktok influencers who only talk positivity, because they want to keep their options open for future opportunities with those authors/publisher or maybe get published themselves one day. Like this idea of professionalism bleeds over into reader spaces, when it doesn’t need to, if that makes sense?
2026-08-31 19:52:27
0
It’s Courtney :
I actually can't trust ppl who don't post negative reviews.
2026-08-09 04:06:09
5
Katalin Marie Cook📚 :
It’s called HONESTY. And that’s why I love your content because I don’t feel like you’re trying to sell me a book even if you hate it, which a lot of people on here I feel like are trying to do
2026-08-04 22:28:42
7
caup1_writes :
Ooh actually I a little bit disagree with some of this! Most books are not a love or hate for me—they’re somewhere in the middle. And I think saying something is objectively bad is misleading, because most of the time it’s subjectively bad. It didn’t work for you. But that doesn’t mean it’s indisputable fact that it’s bad. This doesn’t mean negative or critical reviews are bad (I think they’re very good and important!) but it is important to put thought into *why* a book didn’t work for you. *Why* is the writing bad? Is it the structure or pacing or style? Why didn’t a character work for you? Lack of growth? Flat or simplistic characterization? That’s the critical (in more ways than one) part imo. It’s just a TikTok and we all use a shorthand but being precise and thoughtful about language is kind of a thing for literary criticism.
2026-08-06 11:48:01
2
L_hentz :
I think the negative reviews are so helpful because it helps me determine if I would want to spend money on a book or not. Especially if we have similar tastes on why you think a book is good. Just saying it “wasn’t for me” is not helpful but saying “it had x y and z in it that I didn’t vibe with is because maybe I don’t like x y and z either and would have wasted money on a book I didn’t end up loving or would dnf. Love your content! ❤️
2026-08-04 21:52:54
1
riareadsalot 📚 :
It's fine to not like things!! I don't understand people who only want positives, that's not reality and if they don't want to hear anything negative scroll on ✨
2026-08-05 01:46:17
1
Jamie Schoonover444 :
I enjoy the negative reviews because it shows me that we have similar taste so when we hate all the same books I know you are a reliable source for good books!!
2026-08-07 03:38:19
1
Cynthia Marie ❤️ 📚🐠🐈⬛ :
Negative reviews are just as important as positive reviews imo.
2026-08-19 16:32:56
0
Jeanny :
Love h8ting the same books as people and im nosey and curious about anyone’s opinion. Makes life interesting
2026-08-04 21:33:38
1
Jes :
I can get behind this
2026-08-04 23:48:02
0
Amber💀🧳🐌🐕🪴🍜🧘🏾♀️🎤 :
You have become my new favorite person
2026-08-25 20:32:16
0
Malia 📖 🫶🏻 | Booktok :
There is negative reviews (which is appropriate and good. Could help other readers figure out if they want to read it and help authors become better writers.) and then there’s being negative/rude. Basically, I’m all for respectable negative reviews! 😂
2026-08-05 23:02:59
0
jamesj3845 :
Negative reviews are for people like me. I’m a critical person, but necessarily a negative person, or not always negative. I don’t see negativity as bad either. But I often think differently than the majority and it can be isolating. I don’t follow fandoms. Also isolating but it’s not my nature. So critical reviews with negativity soothe me. They tell me others see what I see and interpret some parts of the world the same. I love critical/neg reviews even if I liked a book/movie. Because I’m still going to like it! I like seeing how others interpret it. Please keep posting those inflammatory reviews!
2026-08-05 18:14:04
0
Lilly_Cat🍉🆘🇺🇸 :
I believe that negative reviews are just as important as positive reviews. The reason why you hate the book might be why I like the book. Also if every single review is positive and has no depth or anything that anyone can say even slightly negative about a book it gives red flag. There is absolutely nothing on this planet that everyone 100% agree with 100%.
2026-08-30 14:19:06
0
likely 2B Found Reading 📚 :
thank. you. im so concerned about that absolute crap coming out and BEING PUBLISHED. Luna Mason .. read the first in her boxing series... did anyone at the publishing house read it? Why was this thought to be ok? also booktok recommendations honestly all seem to be paid or people desperate for and ARC...
2026-09-06 13:37:15
0
jadeneedsprotein :
aren't they doing the same thing you are? telling you why they didn't enjoy your thoughts on something? 😂 so they can tell you they don't enjoy your stuff but you can't tell others why you didn't enjoy a book? the world, I fear, is doomed.
2026-08-06 01:03:20
0
Helenka.a :
i love when people give negative reviews. It really annoys me when people say one good thing about a book and then skip all the bad parts and i basically end up wasting money.
2026-08-06 10:58:17
0
soph :
tbh i followed you BECAUSE of the books you don’t like. I know that i can now trust your opinion because we have similar icks when it comes to books. If you liked a book I think was bad, I wouldn’t trust what you think is good.
2026-08-05 00:06:19
1
To see more videos from user @joliejentzen, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.