I am getting so mf TIRED of people acting like Jacob can do no wrong. he is just a MAN he can be CRITICIZED!!!
2026-08-08 07:20:34
652
Relevant :
Who I wanted...
2026-08-08 01:53:49
1070
AnnaN :
and since when did society stop seeing chubby/stocky people as plus size? the reference photo rachel has posted, that guy would definitely be labeled plus sized any day of the week, but not during this discussion apparently???
2026-08-09 08:27:14
11
kb :
Also since when has chubby/stocky not implied overweight or fat I feel like I’m being gaslit? You can deff be stocky and muscular but the implication there is still a certain amount of fat so I really don’t get why people are pretending not to understand 😭
2026-08-08 03:43:21
692
Han :
I think even if they had cast Harris with just a non athletic softer bodied actor I would’ve been okay. But justice is skinny skinny. Do I think justice will probably be amazing? Absolutely. But just disappointed we couldn’t get plus size rep
2026-08-08 04:03:24
527
Feisty Omega :
People are glossing over the fact Harris is canonically a thicker character not only because he's described that way but also because of his congenital heart defect which inhibited his ability to do much physical activity because of his many surgical interventions over his life time. Him being a mid to plus sized character and finding confidence in his appearance is a huge part of his story and a huge part of what attracts Troy in the books. It really upsets me to see them take all the heartfelt and meaningful story out of Harris's character inorder to cast a thin person.
2026-08-08 05:25:46
213
Snarki B :
I’m sad Rachel didn’t put her foot down on this one… I’m sure Jacob was thinking “nobody wants to see a dad bod in the smex scenes” - but what made the show so great in the first season was the REALNESS. Not all men are pro athletes and Harris was their rep in these books 😢
2026-08-08 13:57:38
52
Nolyn💕 :
Justice smith is actually very very skinny. It’s not a bad thing, but it’s WILDLY inaccurate for this part
2026-08-08 08:02:18
158
anya🧡🤍🩷 :
mind you chubby is just a sanitised word for fat like that man is fat!!! he still deserves love and to be seen as sexy!!!
2026-08-08 20:20:32
121
Wannabe webslinger :
What’s crazy too is so many people are trying to say his weight was never implied or he was never depicted as chubby like hello?? Did we read the same book did you see the cover??
2026-08-08 05:02:00
73
Amanda :
Let’s not also miss the fact Troy is very much homophobic, which would lend to being possibly racist, to begin with so now we have a black man per source material doing all the work to fix a white man’s reputation or we’re going completely off source material to change the story to balance things out. But hey, we’re supposed to trust them… nah they missed the mark.
2026-08-08 09:13:57
38
🐝❤️ :
I'll be so honest: the fact that they didn't even have the guts to go with someone like the stock photo is so fucking annoying. even if you don't read him as plus size, he still has no business being skinny. such a cowardly casting choice and I feel so bad for Justice because he's been dropped into the middle of a wider discourse that has nothing to do with him.
2026-08-08 06:41:44
120
sunshine :
it's like okay the book doesn't directly say he's fat but plus size comes in all shapes and sizes.
2026-08-08 19:33:21
7
Elaine :
Mind you they didn’t even cast someone with an average weight like Justice is skinny 😭
2026-08-08 03:44:03
133
🦄🏳️🌈🧚 GigglePotz 🐲🇦🇺🧌 :
the fact that they wouldn't even cast midsized??
2026-08-09 03:07:35
115
lifeoftravmoo :
Also chubby and stocky is basically morbidly obese in gay culture. So people say he’s not plus sized, they don’t get it at all.
2026-08-08 05:43:14
89
Kay Taylor Rea :
he’s canonically described as ‘hefty’ and I’m losing my mind how anyone can say JS could EVER be described that way lmao. folks really will cartwheel around the point to avoid their own fatphobia. like I wasn’t hopeful that a true plus size casting would happen, but like THIS SKINNY?? REALLY??
2026-08-08 03:44:52
102
🌿Sage🌿 :
for anyone who thinks he's "stocky", guess what? stocky is a synonym for FAT.
2026-08-08 05:57:34
46
Raine :
And I’m gonna say this the book probably doesn’t use the word fat because society still inherently views fat as a bad word
2026-08-08 13:41:32
23
I am probably asleep :
what does pudgy mean, QUICKLY
2026-08-08 08:41:38
113
Nelly :
Like omg I’m so sick of having to explain this to people like let’s use critical thinking skills. Justice fits more of Fabian’s body type and Harris is no where near that. It’s not hard to understand that chubby and stocky is someone who doesn’t have abs and basically no muscle definition…fluffy. Justice is none of those things..he’s a great actor and that’s about it but he’s not book Harris
2026-08-09 04:17:49
14
Newtti Fruitti :
“Maybe he’ll gain weight” 1) filming starts in a matter of days and this is a pic he posted on his story LAST MONTH 2) why does our chubby body rep have to be a skinny man gaining weight specifically for the role (and probably losing it all immediately after) when we coulda just hired A CHUBBY ACTOR!!!
2026-08-08 04:45:43
125
Nathan Bakken :
It’s because all those people are fat phobic!
2026-08-08 04:11:26
37
Madi :
And I love everything justice smith has ever done, it's just hard to trust Jacob's vision with the erasure of a plus size Harris when season one has so much diversity and was truly a master piece
2026-08-09 19:37:34
7
To see more videos from user @frenchf118, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.