@emanatorofyuri: yes, this is about annoying ass Amphoreus fans. Anyways, I enjoyed both planets for what they’re worth. They both have genuinely interesting explorations of existentialism and absurdism, respectively, alongside everything else they bring to the table. There’s really no need to take the moral high ground over which one is “better,” because at the end of the day, they’re both stories in a Hoyo gacha game. Neither is some untouchable masterpiece or top-tier writing, and that’s okay. You can appreciate what each planet does well without pretending either one is flawless #planarcadia #sparxie #yaoguang #hsr #HonkaiStarRail @mercury ☀️🌿 @sol

sora !! | hertamei enthusiast
sora !! | hertamei enthusiast
Open In TikTok:
Region: EG
Thursday 13 August 2026 06:21:31 GMT
25114
5201
148
83

Music

Download

Comments

ricecakeeditz
ricecakeeditz :
Literally what I’ve been saying, the media literacy is GONE nowadays😭 Fulwish had me sobbing bro
2026-08-13 14:33:14
827
parks_productions
J.T.🌙 :
I thinks it’s more of how you could tell major writing changes had to be made because of the sudden political tensions and hsr is still suffering from it. While I think Hoyo did somewhat okay with the time they had, it could’ve been so much better. Fulwish could’ve been fleshed out a lot more, despite evanescia’s importance she was often sidelined, as well as the obvious delay of pearl, Just somethings we can’t really do anything about unfortunately
2026-08-13 16:31:17
131
andy_the_artist
🎨🩸Andy🩸🎨 :
like... the IPC (pretty much a stand in for capitalism) trying to capitalize and monopolize the planet of JOY genuinely the story is in your face and some people dont get it 😭
2026-08-13 19:52:34
610
naninaaaaaa_
ᥒᥲძ¡ᥒᰔᩚ 🍉 :
almost reminds me of earth because global warming is just few years away and nobody actually gaf like ACTUALLY
2026-08-13 08:15:15
757
treer0tten
Tree :
Hot take but i feel like amphoreus should’ve happened later in the story, it feels so like.. endgame to me idk
2026-08-15 07:06:01
58
peepawbeliever
melle (🇧🇦) sunday pilled :
"Amphoreus was better!" Planarcadia was about you like specifically
2026-08-13 06:28:58
198
patsiuk128
Patsiuk :
Never thought I’d see people hating on Amphoreous in this day and age. But anyway. I agree, most people seem to really undermine Planarcadia’s messages. Both Fulwish and Asat were INSANE as antagonist, I’d personally say way better than Sunday, Flame Reaver or any previous antagonists were. Both Asat and Fulwish had me creeped out the entire time
2026-08-13 16:00:28
87
turkuaziniz
mavis :
Dare I say in a sense this story is doing what cabaret did back then
2026-08-13 15:49:56
93
idiotonline4442
Dee|#1❄️🌟(🎈)shipper :
I don't read any stories in hsr but it was giving vibes of "distract them they'll never know" by constantly shoving media and "slop" in our faces to distract from the real problems going on around them. if their favorite streamer isn't upset why should they be? which terrifyingly reflects our own world
2026-08-13 22:29:41
29
ui_zen
Raizen :
Because the presentation and the way they tell it is awful
2026-08-13 20:22:14
26
minih0325
MiniH :
I love all of the planets, I hate all the people that try to make it a competition when each story has a different moral
2026-08-14 06:30:05
26
d3me4
D3me4 :
Oh but they hated Amphoreus for being so long and taking all of 3.X aande being bad, but now Planarcadia was to short… and Amphoreus was best, like wow. Plus they told us The Elation patch extends too two planets , it’s not over like bro.
2026-08-14 23:08:48
7
solivagency
Solivagency :
They literally have Asat say it
2026-08-14 06:20:50
19
kein_plan_vom_leben_
Kein Plan von Leben<3 :
Other than in Amphoreus people ACTUALLY died in Planarcadia.But no Planarcadia is just brainrot. I think these people who call this planet slop only saw the Sparxie trailer and ran with it
2026-08-15 11:21:25
6
curtain_call12
🐕🦈Curtian Call 🐙🦇 :
dare I say this is what happened to the Monkey quest that introduced Rappa as well? a commentary of brain rot and internet trends to a stupid joke
2026-08-13 18:25:05
27
_.hieuhanh._
_.hieuhanh._ :
2.6 kinda did it once and they reduced it to pure brain rot Planarcadia did it again and they still didn't get it 😭
2026-08-13 07:56:03
96
yoonisboredoflife_atp
BL_Yoon~ :
the thing is I actually like Planarcadia a Lot it's not Amphoreous level but it's still good Idk why so many people dislike it specially since it talks abt the problems with the internet and the way it influences masses making it turn away from real problems affecting the world
2026-08-14 03:09:16
18
guinhomodifok
guinho :
planarcadia is one of, if not the best storytelling in hsr, and have so many good dialogues, and ppl still talk so much abt amphoreus, that have shit storytelling and pacing 🥹✌️
2026-08-14 03:32:36
5
theoneandonlyfloppy
Floppy :
planarcadia clears penacony story wise but theyll jump you for saying that
2026-08-13 19:20:27
25
allama888
Nightx :
Hot take, Planarcadia’s story is better paced so far than Amphoreous’ story-
2026-08-15 00:50:18
17
humphry7976
Humphry7976 :
Amphoreus was way too long and over complicated I was bored half the time I’m glad this story has been much clearer than that mess
2026-08-13 23:25:26
15
nabboil
nabboil :
Tbh it has less subtle cultural inspiration,but they had to change every Japanese cultural inspiration in a month bc of the takaichi. (plus the story it’s the original one just with a different planet and theme) it was probably correlated to the mask so my presumption it’s that the theme was the kabuki theatre THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN PEAK
2026-08-14 20:27:10
6
n0tliz4
Liza :
I didn't really like Palnarcadia cuz it waz a bit too overwhelming for my liking especially at first but the story was really nice, I still like Amphoreus better but Planarcadia was definitely very nice as well, though I get qhy some people like it
2026-08-13 21:42:50
41
night.skye.cc
𝐒𝐊𝐘𝐄(𝐄𝐦𝐢𝐥𝐢𝐞 𝐅𝐚𝐧) :
They're gonna do exactly what they did with Amphoreus where they're gonna hate on it for ages and then act like they loved it the whole time. Amphoreus and Planarcadia perfectly compliment imo and they work so well together, both telling compelling stories in two interesting ways to not have people get bored
2026-08-14 09:46:41
10
lastaceinalosthand
Ace of Spades :
yeah, because it wasn't written or executed well.
2026-08-14 01:18:13
5
To see more videos from user @emanatorofyuri, please go to the Tikwm homepage.

Other Videos


About